瑜伽与认知加工疗法治疗军事性创伤相关创伤后应激障碍:一项随机临床试验
这项多中心随机临床试验于2015年12月1日至2022年4月30日在美国东南部和西北部2个退伍军人健康管理局医疗系统内开展,纳入22至71岁军事性创伤相关PTSD女性退伍军人,比较创伤中心创伤敏感瑜伽(TCTSY,10次每周60分钟团体课程)与一线认知加工疗法(CPT,12次每周90分钟团体课程)。意向性治疗样本131例(TCTSY组72例,CPT组59例),两组CAPS-5和PCL-5评分随时间均显著改善(时间效应P < .001),但组间效应和组×时间交互效应均不显著;等效性分析显示两组变化评分无显著差异,所有随访时间点CAPS-5的双单侧检验区间均在±10等效界值内。TCTSY组治疗完成率65.3%(47例),CPT组45.8%(27例),TCTSY组完成率高出42.6%(P = .03)。作者认为TCTSY与CPT等效,且完成率更高提示其可接受性更好,可能有助于解决当前VA PTSD治疗的局限性。
要点
- 在MST相关PTSD女性退伍军人中,TCTSY在降低PTSD症状严重程度上与一线CPT等效,所有随访时间点CAPS-5双单侧检验区间均在±10等效界值内。
- 两组CAPS-5和PCL-5评分随时间均显著改善(时间效应P < .001),但组间效应和组×时间交互效应均不显著。
- TCTSY组治疗完成率65.3%(47/72)vs CPT组45.8%(27/59),TCTSY组完成率高出42.6%(P = .03)。
- 3个月时CAPS-5平均(SD)评分:TCTSY组24.03(11.55)vs CPT组22.15(13.56);PCL-5:TCTSY组36.97(17.74)vs CPT组31.76(12.47)。
- 作者认为TCTSY更高的完成率提示其作为有效且可接受的PTSD治疗具有更好的可接受性,可能有助于解决当前VA PTSD治疗的局限性。
适用人群与场景
- 22至71岁、军事性创伤相关PTSD的女性退伍军人,来自美国东南部和西北部2个退伍军人健康管理局医疗系统。
- 意向性治疗样本131例(TCTSY组72例,CPT组59例),平均(SD)年龄48.2(11.2)岁。
处置流程与药物剂量
- TCTSY干预:以内感受和赋权为重点的哈他瑜伽,10次每周60分钟团体课程。
- CPT干预:以修正负性创伤后思维为目标的认知治疗,12次每周90分钟团体课程。
- 评估时间点:基线、干预中期、干预后2周和干预后3个月。
研究设计与关键结果
- 多中心随机临床试验,2015年12月1日至2022年4月30日在美国东南部和西北部2个VA医疗系统开展,200名女性退伍军人同意参与,意向性治疗样本131例(TCTSY组72例,CPT组59例)。
- 治疗完成率:TCTSY组65.3%(47例)vs CPT组45.8%(27例),TCTSY组完成率高出42.6%(P = .03)。
- CAPS-5平均(SD)评分:基线TCTSY组36.73(8.79)vs CPT组35.52(7.49);3个月TCTSY组24.03(11.55)vs CPT组22.15(13.56);时间效应P < .001,组间效应和组×时间交互效应均不显著。
- PCL-5平均(SD)评分:基线TCTSY组49.62(12.19)vs CPT组48.69(13.62);3个月TCTSY组36.97(17.74)vs CPT组31.76(12.47);时间效应P < .001。
- 等效性分析:两组变化评分无显著差异,所有随访时间点CAPS-5的双单侧检验区间均在±10等效界值内。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 研究类型:多中心随机临床试验(比较有效性试验)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,TCTSY与CPT在降低MST相关PTSD女性退伍军人PTSD症状严重程度上等效,且TCTSY治疗完成率更高,提示其作为有效且可接受的PTSD治疗具有更好的可接受性,可能有助于解决当前VA PTSD治疗的局限性。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
IMPORTANCE: First-line treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in the US Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), ie, trauma-focused therapy, while effective, is limited by low treatment initiation, high dropout, and high treatment refraction.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the effectiveness of Trauma Center Trauma-Sensitive Yoga (TCTSY) vs first-line cognitive processing therapy (CPT) in women veterans with PTSD related to military sexual trauma (MST) and the hypothesis that PTSD outcomes would differ between the interventions.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This multisite randomized clinical trial was conducted from December 1, 2015, to April 30, 2022, within 2 VA health care systems located in the southeast and northwest. Women veterans aged 22 to 71 years with MST-related PTSD were enrolled and randomized to TCTSY or CPT.
INTERVENTIONS: The TCTSY intervention (Hatha-style yoga focusing on interoception and empowerment) consisted of 10 weekly, 60-minute group sessions, and the CPT intervention (cognitive-based therapy targeting modification of negative posttraumatic thoughts) consisted of 12 weekly, 90-minute group sessions.
MAIN OUTCOME AND MEASURES: Sociodemographic data were collected via self-report survey. The primary outcome, PTSD symptom severity, was assessed using the Clinician-Administered PTSD Scale for DSM-5 (CAPS-5) and PTSD Checklist for DSM-5 (PCL-5). Assessments were conducted at baseline, midintervention, 2 weeks post intervention, and 3 months post intervention.
RESULTS: Of 200 women veterans who consented to participate, the intent-to-treat sample comprised 131 participants (mean [SD] age, 48.2 [11.2] years), with 72 randomized to TCTSY and 59 randomized to CPT. Treatment was completed by 47 participants (65.3%) in the TCTSY group and 27 (45.8%) in the CPT group, a 42.6% higher treatment completion rate in the TCTSY group (P = .03). Both treatment groups improved over time on the CAPS-5 (mean [SD] scores at baseline: 36.73 [8.79] for TCTSY and 35.52 [7.49] for CPT; mean [SD] scores at 3 months: 24.03 [11.55] for TCTSY and 22.15 [13.56]) and the PCL-5 (mean [SD] scores at baseline: 49.62 [12.19] for TCTSY and 48.69 [13.62] for CPT; mean [SD] scores at 3 months: 36.97 [17.74] for TCTSY and 31.76 [12.47]) (P < .001 for time effects). None of the group effects or group-by-time effects were significant. Equivalence analyses of change scores were not significantly different between the TCTSY and CPT groups, and the two one-sided test intervals fell within the equivalence bounds of plus or minus 10 for CAPS-5 for all follow-up time points.
CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: In this comparative effectiveness randomized clinical trial, TCTSY was equivalent to CPT in reducing PTSD symptom severity, with both groups improving significantly. The higher treatment completion rate for TCTSY indicates its higher acceptability as an effective and acceptable PTSD treatment for women veterans with PTSD related to MST that could address current VA PTSD treatment limitations.
TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT02640690.
参考来源
- Zaccari B, Higgins M, Haywood TN, et al. Yoga vs Cognitive Processing Therapy for Military Sexual Trauma-Related Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Netw Open. 2023. PMID: 38064219. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.44862
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。