急诊医护人员对胸痛模拟患者分诊等级的评定是否因外貌不同而异
该研究向1563名急诊医护人员(平均年龄36±10岁,女性867人占55%;急诊医师777人占50%,急诊医学住院医师180人占11%,护士606人占39%)提供标准化胸痛临床病例,并随机配以8张不同性别和种族外貌(白人、黑人、北非人、东南亚人)的标准化图像。要求对同一病例进行视觉分诊优先级评定(1级需立即处理至5级可等待2小时),分析时将1-2级归为紧急、3-5级归为非紧急。结果发现男性模拟患者获得紧急优先的比例高于女性(62% vs 49%,差异13%,95%CI 8-18%),黑人模拟患者低于白人(47% vs 58%,差异-11%,95%CI -18%至-4%),东南亚人和北非人外貌与白人无显著差异。作者结论认为模拟患者外貌特征改变了分诊决策,黑人和女性患者较少获得紧急处理。
要点
- 男性模拟胸痛患者获得紧急优先的比例高于女性:62% vs 49%,差异13%(95%CI 8-18%)。
- 黑人模拟胸痛患者获得紧急优先的比例低于白人:47% vs 58%,差异-11%(95%CI -18%至-4%)。
- 东南亚人外貌(55% vs 58%,差异-3%,95%CI -10%至5%)和北非人外貌(61% vs 58%,差异3%,95%CI -4%至10%)与白人相比无显著差异。
- 全部应答的优先级分布为1级180人(11%)、2级686人(44%)、3级539人(34%)、4级131人(9%)、5级27人(2%)。
- 研究纳入1563名急诊医护人员,其中急诊医师777人(50%)、急诊医学住院医师180人(11%)、护士606人(39%)。
适用人群与场景
- 急诊医护人员,包括急诊医师777人(50%)、急诊医学住院医师180人(11%)和护士606人(39%),共1563人,平均年龄36±10岁,女性867人(55%)。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 分诊优先级评定采用1级(需立即处理)至5级(可等待至多2小时)的视觉评定;分析时将1级和2级归为紧急(生命危急),3-5级归为非紧急。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究为随机对照的模拟病例研究,向急诊医护人员提供标准化胸痛临床病例并随机配以8张不同性别和种族外貌(白人、黑人、北非人、东南亚人)的标准化图像,要求评定分诊优先级。
- 全部应答的优先级分布:1级180人(11%)、2级686人(44%)、3级539人(34%)、4级131人(9%)、5级27人(2%)。
- 男性模拟患者获得紧急优先的比例高于女性:62% vs 49%,差异13%(95%CI 8-18%)。
- 黑人模拟患者获得紧急优先的比例低于白人:47% vs 58%,差异-11%(95%CI -18%至-4%)。
- 东南亚人外貌模拟患者与白人比较:55% vs 58%,差异-3%(95%CI -10%至5%),未达统计学显著。
- 北非人外貌模拟患者与白人比较:61% vs 58%,差异3%(95%CI -4%至10%),未达统计学显著。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:随机对照的模拟病例研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者结论认为,模拟患者外貌特征改变了分诊决策;与白人患者相比,黑人患者较少获得紧急处理,女性与男性相比同样如此。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND IMPORTANCE: There seems to be evidence of gender and ethnic bias in the early management of acute coronary syndrome. However, whether these differences are related to less severe severity assessment or to less intensive management despite the same severity assessment has not yet been established.
OBJECTIVE: To show whether viewing an image with characters of different gender appearance or ethnic background changes the prioritization decision in the emergency triage area.
METHODS: The responders were offered a standardized clinical case in an emergency triage area. The associated image was randomized among eight standardized images of people presenting with chest pain and differing in gender and ethnic appearance (White, Black, North African and southeast Asian appearance).
OUTCOME MEASURES AND ANALYSIS: Each person was asked to respond to a single clinical case, in which the priority level [from 1 (requiring immediate treatment) to 5 (able to wait up to 2 h)] was assessed visually. Priority classes 1 and 2 for vital emergencies and classes 3-5 for nonvital emergencies were grouped together for analysis.
RESULTS: Among the 1563 respondents [mean age, 36 ± 10 years; 867 (55%) women], 777 (50%) were emergency physicians, 180 (11%) emergency medicine residents and 606 (39%) nurses. The priority levels for all responses were 1-5 : 180 (11%), 686 (44%), 539 (34%), 131 (9%) and 27 (2%). There was a higher reported priority in male compared to female [62% vs. 49%, difference 13% (95% confidence interval; CI 8-18%)]. Compared to White people, there was a lower reported priority for Black simulated patients [47% vs. 58%, difference -11% (95% CI -18% to -4%)] but not people of southeast Asian [55% vs. 58%, difference -3% (95% CI -10-5%)] and North African [61% vs. 58%, difference 3% (95% CI -4-10%)] appearance.
CONCLUSION: In this study, the visualization of simulated patients with different characteristics modified the prioritization decision. Compared to White patients, Black patients were less likely to receive emergency treatment. The same was true for women compared with men.
参考来源
- Coisy F, Olivier G, Ageron FX, et al. Do emergency medicine health care workers rate triage level of chest pain differently based upon appearance in simulated patients? Eur J Emerg Med. 2023. PMID: 38100643. doi:10.1097/MEJ.0000000000001113
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。