促进成人重症监护病房成本效益的干预措施:多学科跨国电子德尔菲研究的共识声明与最佳实践考量
该共识针对成人ICU成本效益干预证据有限的问题,采用三轮改良在线德尔菲法,由21个国家61名多学科ICU专家(医师、护士、相关健康专业人员、管理者)参与,围绕高价值医疗的四大领域(基础要素、基础设施、照护交付优先事项、可靠性与反馈)投票,以超过70%专家投票同意作为共识标准,最终就50条最佳实践考量达成共识;指导委员会进一步认可其中9条为「关键」考量。9条关键考量涵盖多学科ICU照护模式、员工培训与能力评估、持续质量审计、动态排班、多学科临终照护、早期活动及推动「绿色ICU」概念的国际共识等。作者认为,政府机构和专业学会等利益相关方必须在这些最佳实践考量范围内,结合可用资源确定本地适用的具体措施。
要点
- 三轮改良在线德尔菲法,21个国家61名多学科ICU专家参与,以超过70%专家投票同意作为共识标准。
- 共就50条成人ICU成本效益最佳实践考量达成共识,指导委员会最终认可其中9条为「关键」考量。
- 9条关键考量包括采用多学科ICU照护模式、员工培训与能力评估、持续质量审计。
- 关键考量还包括确保ICU内外高质量重症照护、动态排班、多学科临终照护、早期活动及推动「绿色ICU」国际共识。
- 作者认为政府机构与专业学会等利益相关方须主导在可用资源下确定本地适用具体措施。
适用人群与场景
- 成人重症监护病房(ICU)场景,面向医师、护士、相关健康专业人员与管理者等多学科团队。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 共识标准:某拟议干预获得超过70%专家投票同意即视为达成共识。
- 指导委员会认可标准:被超过50%指导委员会成员认定为「关键」的干预措施予以认可。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 采用多学科ICU照护模式(被指导委员会认可为「关键」最佳实践考量)。
- 聚焦员工培训与能力评估(被指导委员会认可为「关键」最佳实践考量)。
- 开展持续质量审计,确保ICU内外高质量重症照护服务(被指导委员会认可为「关键」最佳实践考量)。
- 实施动态员工排班(被指导委员会认可为「关键」最佳实践考量)。
- 以多学科方法实施临终照护(被指导委员会认可为「关键」最佳实践考量)。
- 早期活动(被指导委员会认可为「关键」最佳实践考量)。
- 推动「绿色ICU」概念的国际共识努力(被指导委员会认可为「关键」最佳实践考量)。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:三轮改良在线德尔菲法共识研究,使用网络平台。
- 参与者:来自21个国家的61名多学科ICU专家(医师、护士、相关健康专业人员、管理者)。
- 第一轮为定性,基于高价值医疗四大关键领域(基础要素、基础设施、照护交付优先事项、可靠性与反馈)收集对成本效益标准的意见;第二轮为定性与定量;第三轮为定量,以重申并确立标准;第二、三轮均采用五点李克特量表投票。
- 第三轮结束时,就成人ICU成本效益的50条最佳实践考量达成共识。
- 指导委员会最终认可9条「关键」最佳实践考量,包括采用多学科ICU照护模式、聚焦员工培训与能力评估、持续质量审计、确保ICU内外高质量重症照护、实施动态员工排班、多学科方法实施临终照护、早期活动及推动「绿色ICU」概念的国际共识努力。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:国际多学科专家改良德尔菲共识(共识声明)。
- 共识阈值:超过70%专家投票同意;指导委员会「关键」认可阈值:超过50%指导委员会成员认定。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,利益相关方(政府机构、专业学会)必须主导努力,在这些最佳实践考量范围内结合可用资源确定本地适用的具体措施。
指南或共识出处
- 文章标题:促进成人重症监护病房成本效益的干预措施:多学科跨国电子德尔菲研究的共识声明与最佳实践考量(发表于Crit Care)。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: There is limited evidence to guide interventions that promote cost-effectiveness in adult intensive care units (ICU). The aim of this consensus statement is to identify globally applicable interventions for best ICU practice and provide guidance for judicious use of resources.
METHODS: A three-round modified online Delphi process, using a web-based platform, sought consensus from 61 multidisciplinary ICU experts (physicians, nurses, allied health, administrators) from 21 countries. Round 1 was qualitative to ascertain opinions on cost-effectiveness criteria based on four key domains of high-value healthcare (foundational elements; infrastructure fundamentals; care delivery priorities; reliability and feedback). Round 2 was qualitative and quantitative, while round 3 was quantitative to reiterate and establish criteria. Both rounds 2 and 3 utilized a five-point Likert scale for voting. Consensus was considered when > 70% of the experts voted for a proposed intervention. Thereafter, the steering committee endorsed interventions that were identified as 'critical' by more than 50% of steering committee members. These interventions and experts' comments were summarized as final considerations for best practice.
RESULTS: At the conclusion of round 3, consensus was obtained on 50 best practice considerations for cost-effectiveness in adult ICU. Finally, the steering committee endorsed 9 'critical' best practice considerations. This included adoption of a multidisciplinary ICU model of care, focus on staff training and competency assessment, ongoing quality audits, thus ensuring high quality of critical care services whether within or outside the four walls of ICUs, implementation of a dynamic staff roster, multidisciplinary approach to implementing end-of-life care, early mobilization and promoting international consensus efforts on the Green ICU concept.
CONCLUSIONS: This Delphi study with international experts resulted in 9 consensus statements and best practice considerations promoting cost-effectiveness in adult ICUs. Stakeholders (government bodies, professional societies) must lead the efforts to identify locally applicable specifics while working within these best practice considerations with the available resources.
参考来源
- Kansal A, Latour JM, See KC, et al. Interventions to promote cost-effectiveness in adult intensive care units: consensus statement and considerations for best practice from a multidisciplinary and multinational eDelphi study. Crit Care. 2023. PMID: 38082302. doi:10.1186/s13054-023-04766-2
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。