指南与共识呼吸衰竭与机械通气儿科与产科急症

评估基于证据和共识的德国学校SARS-CoV-2传播控制指南对决策过程的影响:多组分定性分析

Assessing the impact of an evidence- and consensus-based guideline for controlling SARS-CoV-2 transmission in German schools on decision-making processes: a multi-component qualitative analysis.
指南 / 共识 · Health Res Policy Syst · 2023-12-19
一句话结论16个联邦州中9个教育部将该指南视为相关信息源、5个用于核查现有指令,但指南缺乏情境特异性,对决策的影响参差不齐。

本研究采用三组分定性方法评估基于证据和共识的德国学校SARS-CoV-2传播控制指南对决策过程的影响:向各联邦州教育、家庭和卫生部发送信息公开申请,对两个联邦州学校措施决策相关人员及指南专家组成员进行半结构化访谈(共20次访谈)。结果显示,16个联邦州中9个教育部将该指南视为相关信息源,5个用于核查现有学校措施指令;所有参与者均肯定其基于证据和共识的制定过程,但也指出可用性和实用性局限,如缺乏情境特异性;咨询政策制定者的参与者(5次访谈)将该指南与其他证据源一并参考;对指南影响的总体认知参差不齐。作者认为需进一步研究评估公共卫生指南对(政治)决策的影响,指南制定过程可能需要调整以适应公共卫生紧急状态及之后的决策现实。

要点

  • 16个联邦州中9个教育部将该指南视为相关信息源,5个用于核查现有学校措施指令。
  • 共20次访谈,所有参与者肯定指南基于证据和共识的制定过程,但指出可用性和实用性局限,如缺乏情境特异性。
  • 咨询政策制定者的参与者(5次访谈)将该指南与其他证据源一并参考。
  • 对指南影响的总体认知参差不齐。
  • 作者认为需进一步研究评估公共卫生指南对(政治)决策的影响。

适用人群与场景

  • 德国学校措施决策相关人员(两个联邦州参与学校措施决策的个体)及指南专家组成员(科学专家、公共卫生和学校当局以及受学校措施直接影响者)。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型:多组分定性分析,包括三个组分:(1)根据各联邦州信息自由法向教育、家庭和卫生部发送询问;(2)对两个联邦州参与学校措施决策的个体进行半结构化访谈;(3)对指南专家组成员进行半结构化访谈。
  • 组分1回复信内容采用描述性分析;组分2和3数据采用Kuckartz归纳-演绎主题定性内容分析。
  • 信息公开申请回复显示,16个联邦州中9个教育部将该指南视为相关信息源,5个用于核查现有学校措施指令。
  • 共20次访谈,所有参与者强调指南基于证据和共识的制定过程的价值,但也指出可用性和实用性局限,如缺乏情境特异性。
  • 咨询政策制定者的参与者(5次访谈)将该指南与其他证据源一并参考。
  • 对指南影响的总体认知参差不齐。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:多组分定性分析。
  • 局限:原文报告局限性包括指南缺乏情境特异性;对指南影响的总体认知参差不齐。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,进一步研究评估公共卫生指南对(政治)决策的影响是必要的。
  • 作者认为,指南制定过程可能需要调整以适应公共卫生紧急状态及之后的决策现实。

指南或共识出处

  • 指南名称:基于证据和共识的德国学校SARS-CoV-2传播控制公共卫生指南;制定机构:跨学科专家组(科学专家、公共卫生和学校当局以及受学校措施直接影响者);发布年份:原文未写明。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

INTRODUCTION: During the COVID-19 pandemic, decision-making on measures to reduce or prevent transmission of SARS-CoV-2 in schools was rendered difficult by a rapidly evolving and uncertain evidence base regarding their effectiveness and unintended consequences. To support decision-makers, an interdisciplinary panel of scientific experts, public health and school authorities as well as those directly affected by school measures, was convened in an unprecedented effort to develop an evidence- and consensus-based public health guideline for German schools. This study sought to assess whether and how this guideline impacted decision-making processes.

METHODS: This study comprised three components: (1) we sent inquiries according to the Freedom of Information Acts of each Federal State to ministries of education, family, and health. (2) We conducted semi-structured interviews with individuals involved in decision-making regarding school measures in two Federal States, and (3) we undertook semi-structured interviews with members of the guideline panel. The content of response letters in component 1 was analysed descriptively; data for components 2 and 3 were analysed using deductive-inductive thematic qualitative content analysis according to Kuckartz.

RESULTS: Responses to the Freedom of Information Act inquiries showed that the guideline was recognised as a relevant source of information by ministries of education in nine out of 16 Federal States and used as a reference to check existing directives for school measures in five Federal States. All participants (20 interviews) emphasised the value of the guideline given its evidence- and consensus-based development process but also noted limitations in its usability and usefulness, e.g., lack of context-specificity. It was consulted by participants who advised policy-makers (5 interviews) alongside other sources of evidence. Overall, perceptions regarding the guideline's impact were mixed.

CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest that the guideline was relatively well-known in Federal States' decision-making bodies and that it was considered alongside other forms of evidence in some of these. We suggest that further research to evaluate the impact of public health guidelines on (political) decision-making is warranted. Guideline development processes may need to be adapted to account for the realities of decision-making during public health emergencies and beyond.

来源:Health Res Policy Syst,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Wabnitz K, Rueb M, Rehfuess EA, et al. Assessing the impact of an evidence- and consensus-based guideline for controlling SARS-CoV-2 transmission in German schools on decision-making processes: a multi-component qualitative analysis. Health Res Policy Syst. 2023. PMID: 38115061. doi:10.1186/s12961-023-01072-9

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。