变动的实践,变动的结果:重症医学/肺与重症医学专科培训申请者与项目主任面试后沟通实践的影响
该研究在2022-2023年美国住院医师匹配项目专科匹配后,分别调查重症医学(CCM)和肺与重症医学(PCCM)专科培训申请者与项目主任,了解面试后沟通(PIC)的频率、形式、目标、内容及其对排名顺序表(ROL)的影响。回复率申请者34%(n=373)、项目主任32%(n=86)。申请者66%、项目主任49%报告主动发起PIC;PIC未影响大多数申请者(73%)和项目主任(83%)的ROL决策,但21%申请者和17%项目主任因PIC将对方上调。约50%申请者和20%项目主任通过PIC分享排名意向。双方均指出时间、缺乏统一性、同伴压力、误导性语言及对动机、规则和回应协议的不确定性等挑战,并希望有明确指导。
要点
- 申请者66%、项目主任49%报告主动发起面试后沟通(PIC)。
- PIC未影响大多数申请者(73%)和项目主任(83%)的排名顺序表(ROL)决策。
- 21%申请者和17%项目主任因PIC将对方上调排名;约50%申请者和20%项目主任通过PIC分享排名意向。
- 仅23%申请者认为PIC对创建ROL有帮助,27%认为无帮助,29%中立。
- 双方均指出PIC挑战包括时间、缺乏统一性、同伴压力、误导性语言及对动机、规则和回应协议的不确定性,并希望有明确指导。
适用人群与场景
- 2022-2023年美国住院医师匹配项目专科匹配后的重症医学(CCM)和肺与重症医学(PCCM)专科培训申请者与项目主任。
- 申请者中19%申请CCM、69%申请PCCM、12%两者均申请;项目主任代表CCM(17%)、PCCM(57%)或两者(26%)项目。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为对CCM/PCCM申请者和项目主任分别进行的调查,包含多选题、李克特量表和两个自由文本问题,并对自由文本进行主题内容分析。
- 回复率:申请者34%(n=373),项目主任32%(n=86)。
- 申请者66%、项目主任49%报告主动发起PIC。
- PIC未影响大多数申请者(73%)和项目主任(83%)的ROL决策;21%申请者和17%项目主任因PIC将项目或申请者上调。
- 23%申请者强烈同意或同意PIC对创建ROL有帮助,27%强烈不同意或不同意,29%中立。
- 双方指出的PIC挑战包括时间、缺乏统一性、同伴压力、误导性语言及对动机、规则和回应协议的不确定性。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:调查研究的主题内容分析。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,申请者和项目主任均希望有明确的PIC指导,以减少模糊和误导性沟通。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Although postinterview communication (PIC) guidelines exist, adherence is voluntary. There are no studies of PIC practices in critical care medicine (CCM) and pulmonary and critical care medicine (PCCM) fellowship recruitment.
RESEARCH QUESTION: What is the frequency, format, goals, and content of PIC between CCM/PCCM applicants and program directors? What is the impact of PIC on applicant and program rank order lists (ROLs)?
STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: CCM/PCCM applicants and program directors were separately surveyed after the 2022-2023 National Resident Matching Program Specialty Match. Surveys included multiple-choice, Likert-scale, and two free text questions. Thematic content analysis of free text responses was performed.
RESULTS: One-third of eligible participants responded (applicants: n = 373 [34%]; program directors: n = 86 [32%]). Applicant respondents applied to CCM (19%), PCCM (69%), or both (12%). Program directors represented CCM (17%), PCCM (57%), or both (26%) programs. Applicant (66%) and program director (49%) respondents reported initiating PIC. PIC did not impact ROL decision for most applicants (73%) or program directors (83%), though 21% of applicants and 17% of program directors moved programs or applicants up on their ROL in response to PIC. One-quarter (23%) of applicants strongly agreed or agreed that PIC was helpful in creating their ROL, 27% strongly disagreed or disagreed, and 29% were neutral. PIC challenges identified by both groups included time; lack of uniformity; peer pressure; misleading language; and uncertainty about motives, rules, and response protocols.
INTERPRETATION: PIC is common among CCM/PCCM applicants and program directors. About 50% of applicants and 20% of program directors share ranking intentions via PIC. Although PIC did not impact ROL for most applicants and program directors, a minority of applicants and program directors moved programs up on their ROL after receiving PIC from the other party. Applicants have mixed perspectives on PIC value. Applicants and program directors alike desire clear guidance on PIC to minimize ambiguous and misleading communication.
参考来源
- John MM, Starks H, Allam JS, et al. Variable Practice, Variable Results: Impact of Postinterview Communication Practices Among Critical Care Medicine/Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Fellowship Applicants and Program Directors. Chest. 2023. PMID: 37977268. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2023.11.015
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。