重症医学队列研究中数据缺失的报告与处理方法使用情况
该研究检索2022年29种影响因子≥3的重症/亚专业期刊目录,纳入≥100例的前瞻性临床或回顾性数据库队列研究,由两名研究者重复进行PDF词搜索「missing*」并提取数据。共纳入656项研究,334项(50.9%)提及缺失,其中234项(70.1%)报告了至少1个变量的缺失,160项(47.9%)至少1个变量缺失>5%。334项中88项(26.3%)使用排除标准,36项(10.8%)使用完整病例分析,164项(49.1%)使用正式方法。仅缺失>5%(≥1个变量)与更多使用缺失处理方法独立相关(aOR 2.91;95%CI 1.85-4.60)。作者认为需要教育策略促进缺失报告与解决方法。
要点
- 656项重症医学队列研究中仅334项(50.9%)提及数据缺失,234项(70.1%)报告了至少1个变量的缺失。
- 仅160项(47.9%)至少1个变量缺失超过5%,且仅此因素与使用缺失处理方法独立相关(aOR 2.91;95%CI 1.85-4.60)。
- 334项提及缺失的研究中,88项(26.3%)使用排除标准,36项(10.8%)使用完整病例分析,164项(49.1%)使用正式方法。
- 164项使用正式方法的研究中,100项(61.0%)仅用插补,24项(14.6%)仅用分析策略,40项(24.4%)两者兼用。
- 140项使用插补的研究中,87项(62.1%)用多重插补,49项(35.0%)用简单插补;64项使用分析方法的研究中,12项(18.8%)将缺失设为未知类别,47项(73.4%)用敏感性分析。
适用人群与场景
- 2022年目录中29种2021年影响因子≥3的重症/重症亚专业期刊发表的前瞻性临床或回顾性数据库队列研究
- 纳入标准为入组≥100例患者
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为对已发表重症医学队列研究的文献审查;共审查656项研究,来自29种重症/重症亚专业期刊2022年目录。
- 656项中334项(50.9%)提及数据缺失;334项中234项(70.1%)报告了至少1个变量的缺失,160项(47.9%)至少1个变量缺失>5%。
- 334项提及缺失的研究中,88项(26.3%)使用排除标准,36项(10.8%)使用完整病例分析,164项(49.1%)使用正式方法避免缺失。
- 164项使用正式方法的研究中,100项(61.0%)仅用插补,24项(14.6%)仅用分析策略,40项(24.4%)两者兼用。
- 仅缺失>5%(≥1个变量)与更多使用缺失处理方法独立相关(校正比值比2.91;95%CI 1.85-4.60)。
- 140项使用插补的研究中,87项(62.1%)用多重插补,49项(35.0%)用简单插补。
- 64项使用分析方法的研究中,12项(18.8%)将缺失设为未知类别,47项(73.4%)用敏感性分析。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:对已发表队列研究的文献审查(观察性研究的方法学审查)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,需要教育策略以促进重症医学队列研究中数据缺失的报告和解决方法。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
IMPORTANCE: Failure to recognize and address data missingness in cohort studies may lead to biased results. Although Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology reporting guidelines advocate data missingness reporting, the degree to which missingness is reported and addressed in the critical care literature remains unclear.
OBJECTIVES: To review published ICU cohort studies to characterize data missingness reporting and the use of methods to address it.
DESIGN SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: We searched the 2022 table of contents of 29 critical care/critical care subspecialty journals having a 2021 impact factor greater than or equal to 3 to identify published prospective clinical or retrospective database cohort studies enrolling greater than or equal to 100 patients.
MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: In duplicate, two trained researchers conducted a manuscript/supplemental material PDF word search for "missing*" and extracted study type, patient age, ICU type, sample size, missingness reporting, and the use of methods to address it.
RESULTS: A total of 656 studies were reviewed. Of the 334 of 656 (50.9%) studies mentioning missingness, missingness was reported for greater than or equal to 1 variable in 234 (70.1%) and it exceeded 5% for at least one variable in 160 (47.9%). Among the 334 studies mentioning missingness, 88 (26.3%) used exclusion criteria, 36 (10.8%) used complete-case analysis, and 164 (49.1%) used a formal method to avoid missingness. In these 164 studies, imputation only was used in 100 (61.0%), an analytic strategy only in 24 (14.6%), and both in 40 (24.4%). Only missingness greater than 5% (in ≥ 1 variable) was independently associated with greater use of a missingness method (adjusted odds ratio 2.91; 95% CI, 1.85-4.60). Among 140 studies using imputation, multiple imputation was used in 87 studies (62.1%) and simple imputation in 49 studies (35.0%). For the 64 studies using an analytic method, 12 studies (18.8%) assigned missingness as an unknown category, whereas sensitivity analysis was used in 47 studies (73.4%).
CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Among published critical care cohort studies, only half mentioned result missingness, one-third reported actual missingness and only one-quarter used a method to manage missingness. Educational strategies to promote missingness reporting and resolution methods are required.
参考来源
- Wu TT, Smith LH, Vernooij LM, et al. Data Missingness Reporting and Use of Methods to Address It in Critical Care Cohort Studies. Crit Care Explor. 2023. PMID: 37954900. doi:10.1097/CCE.0000000000001005
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。