制定国家创伤研究行动计划:监管挑战德尔菲调查结果
2016年美国国家科学院、工程院和医学院发布报告呼吁制定国家创伤研究行动计划(NTRAP),并建议识别创伤研究的监管障碍。NTRAP监管挑战专家组由创伤研究人员和监管专业人员组成,于2021至2022年招募,基于全面范围综述制定挑战陈述,采用9点李克特量表对每项陈述的挑战程度进行评分,经过三轮在线德尔菲调查,共识预先定义为≥60%同意。38名主题专家对175项监管挑战进行评级,其中141项(81%)达到共识阈值,42项共识挑战陈述的挑战评级为6或更高。最高评级的挑战涉及院前研究、知情同意例外、不同种族和族裔群体对研究的不信任以及儿科创伤研究特有的问题。
要点
- 38名主题专家对175项监管挑战进行评级,141项(81%)达到预先定义的≥60%共识阈值。
- 42项达成共识的挑战陈述挑战评级为6或更高(9点李克特量表)。
- 最高评级的挑战涉及院前研究、知情同意例外、不同种族和族裔群体对研究的不信任以及儿科创伤研究特有的问题。
- 专家组在网络研讨会上讨论德尔菲结果,并参加分组会议制定解决方案、分享经验教训并确定需要更多监管指导的领域。
- 研究结果用于开发NTRAP研究者工具包,已在互联网上作为创伤研究人员的资源提供。
适用人群与场景
- 创伤研究人员和监管专业人员(主题专家),参与识别和评级创伤研究中监管过程的挑战方面。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 共识预先定义为≥60%同意。
- 挑战程度采用9点李克特量表评分,挑战评级为6或更高被视为高挑战。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 挑战陈述基于全面范围综述制定,专家对每项陈述的挑战程度进行评级。
- 德尔菲调查通过三轮在线轮次进行。
- 德尔菲调查结果在网络研讨会上向专家组展示,参与者随后参加分组会议制定解决方案、分享经验教训并确定需要更多监管指导的领域。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:德尔菲调查(三轮在线轮次)。
- 样本量:38名主题专家。
- 人群:创伤研究人员和监管专业人员,于2021至2022年招募。
- 干预/方法:基于全面范围综述制定挑战陈述,专家对175项监管挑战进行评级。
- 主要终点结果:141项(81%)挑战陈述达到预先定义的≥60%共识阈值;42项共识挑战陈述挑战评级为6或更高。
- 最高评级的挑战涉及院前研究、知情同意例外、不同种族和族裔群体对研究的不信任以及儿科创伤研究特有的问题。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:德尔菲调查(专家共识方法)。
- 证据等级:预后和流行病学;Level IV。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 研究结果用于开发NTRAP研究者工具包,已在互联网上作为创伤研究人员的资源提供。
- 专家组识别了创伤研究中人体受试者保护最具挑战性的方面,并推荐了应对策略和最佳实践(原文结论)。
指南或共识出处
- 2016年美国国家科学院、工程院和医学院报告呼吁制定国家创伤研究行动计划(NTRAP)并建议识别创伤研究的监管障碍。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: In 2016, the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine issued a report calling for a National Trauma Research Action Plan (NTRAP) requiring a resourced, coordinated, joint approach to trauma care research. The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine report recommended the identification of regulatory barriers to trauma research. The NTRAP Regulatory Challenges Panel of trauma researchers and regulatory professionals was convened to identify the most challenging aspects of regulatory processes involved in conducting research.
METHODS: Trauma researchers and regulatory experts were recruited to identify and rate challenging regulatory issues in 2021 to 2022. Challenge statements were developed from a comprehensive scoping review. Panelists rated the challenge level for each statement on a 9-point Likert scale. The Delphi survey was conducted over three online rounds. Consensus was defined a priori as ≥60% agreement. Results of the Delphi survey were presented to the panel during a webinar. Panel participants then participated in breakout sessions to strategize solutions, share lessons learned, and identify where more regulatory guidance is needed.
RESULTS: Thirty-eight subject matter experts rated 175 regulatory challenges, of which 141 (81%) reached the consensus threshold. Of the consensus-reaching challenge statements, 42 had a challenge rating of 6 or higher. Among the highest-rated challenges were issues pertaining to conducting prehospital research, exception from informed consent, mistrust of research among various racial and ethnic groups, and issues specific to conducting pediatric trauma research.
CONCLUSION: This Delphi survey rated challenges culled from a regulatory literature scoping review. The panel identified the most challenging aspects of human subjects protection while conducting trauma research and recommended strategies and best practices to address them. The findings from this study were used to develop the NTRAP Investigator Toolkit, which is available on the internet as a resource for trauma researchers.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Prognostic and Epidemiological; Level IV.
参考来源
- Price MA, Villarreal CL, Moreno AN, et al. Developing a National Trauma Research Action Plan: Results from the regulatory challenges Delphi survey. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2023. PMID: 38031274. doi:10.1097/TA.0000000000004185
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。