基于气道压力的指标检测压力支持通气下高与低吸气努力的诊断准确性研究
这是一项在2家学术医院4个ICU开展的前瞻性诊断准确性研究,纳入28例接受压力支持通气的成人急性呼吸衰竭患者。研究者从20 cmH2O到2 cmH2O、每2 cmH2O逐级下调压力支持,通过呼气末气道阻断测P0.1与ΔPocc、吸气末气道阻断测PMI,并以食管压监测所得吸气肌压力(Pmus)及每分钟Pmus时间乘积(PTPmus/min)为参考标准。共测试246个压力支持水平,低吸气努力分别有145个(59.0%,Pmus标准)与136个(55.3%,PTPmus/min标准)水平;三项气道压力指标识别低努力的ROC曲线下面积为0.87~0.95,敏感性0.83~0.96、特异性0.74~0.88、阳性预测值0.80~0.91、阴性预测值0.78~0.94。高吸气努力分别有34个(13.8%)与17个(6.9%)水平,三项指标ROC曲线下面积0.93~0.95,敏感性0.80~1.00、阴性预测值0.97~1.00,但阳性预测值仅0.23~0.64。作者结论认为气道阻断动作测得的气道压力指标可可靠检测低吸气努力,无创易得支持其床旁用于避免过度辅助,但在高努力人群中仍需更多评估。
要点
- 低吸气努力(Pmus<5 cmH2O或PTPmus/min<50 cmH2O s min-1)时,P0.1、ΔPocc、PMI的ROC曲线下面积0.87~0.95,敏感性0.83~0.96、特异性0.74~0.88,可床旁识别过度辅助
- 高吸气努力(Pmus>10 cmH2O或PTPmus/min>200 cmH2O s min-1)时,三项指标ROC曲线下面积0.93~0.95、敏感性0.80~1.00、阴性预测值0.97~1.00,但阳性预测值仅0.23~0.64
- 方法为逐级下调压力支持(20 cmH2O至2 cmH2O、间隔2 cmH2O),呼气末气道阻断测P0.1与ΔPocc、吸气末气道阻断测PMI,以食管压Pmus与PTPmus/min为参考标准
- 研究共测试246个压力支持水平,低努力占59.0%(Pmus标准)与55.3%(PTPmus/min标准),高努力占13.8%与6.9%,高努力例数少
适用人群与场景
- 2家学术医院4个ICU的28例接受压力支持通气的成人急性呼吸衰竭患者
- 在压力支持通气期间、压力支持从20 cmH2O逐级下调至2 cmH2O(间隔2 cmH2O)的各个水平进行测量
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 以食管压监测的吸气肌压力(Pmus)与每分钟Pmus时间乘积(PTPmus/min)为参考标准
- 高吸气努力定义为Pmus>10 cmH2O或PTPmus/min>200 cmH2O s min-1
- 低吸气努力定义为Pmus<5 cmH2O或PTPmus/min<50 cmH2O s min-1
- 呼气末气道阻断后测最初100 ms内产生的负向气道压(P0.1)和气道压最大负向摆动(ΔPocc)
- 吸气末气道阻断后气道压达平台,平台压与气道压峰值的差值幅度为压力肌肉指数(PMI)
处置流程与药物剂量
- 第一步:在压力支持通气下从20 cmH2O起以2 cmH2O为间隔逐级下调压力支持至2 cmH2O
- 第二步:行呼气末气道阻断动作,测量P0.1与ΔPocc
- 第三步:行吸气末气道阻断,待气道压达平台后测量PMI
- 以三项气道压力指标判断低吸气努力,用于避免过度辅助;高吸气努力时阳性预测值低(0.23~0.64),作者认为需在高努力人群中进一步评估其性能
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:前瞻性诊断准确性研究,4个ICU(2家学术医院),28例成人急性呼吸衰竭患者,共246个压力支持水平
- 低吸气努力:Pmus标准145个水平(59.0%),PTPmus/min标准136个水平(55.3%)
- 低努力识别:三项气道压力指标ROC曲线下面积0.87~0.95,敏感性0.83~0.96、特异性0.74~0.88、阳性预测值0.80~0.91、阴性预测值0.78~0.94
- 高吸气努力:Pmus标准34个水平(13.8%),PTPmus/min标准17个水平(6.9%)
- 高努力识别:三项指标ROC曲线下面积0.93~0.95,敏感性0.80~1.00、阴性预测值0.97~1.00,阳性预测值0.23~0.64
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:前瞻性诊断准确性研究
- 局限:作者指出其性能仍需在存在高吸气努力的人群中进一步评估(More evaluation of their performance is required in cohorts with high effort)
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,通过简易气道阻断动作测得的气道压力指标可可靠检测低吸气努力;其无创、易获取的特点支持在床旁用于避免过度辅助
- 高吸气努力时三项指标敏感性高、阴性预测值高但阳性预测值低(0.23~0.64),作者指出需在高努力人群中进一步评估其性能
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Assessment of the patient's respiratory effort is essential during assisted ventilation. We aimed to evaluate the accuracy of airway pressure (Paw)-based indices to detect potential injurious inspiratory effort during pressure support (PS) ventilation.
METHODS: In this prospective diagnostic accuracy study conducted in four ICUs in two academic hospitals, 28 adult acute respiratory failure patients undergoing PS ventilation were enrolled. A downward PS titration was conducted from 20 cmH2O to 2 cmH2O at a 2 cmH2O interval. By performing an end-expiratory airway occlusion maneuver, the negative Paw generated during the first 100 ms (P0.1) and the maximal negative swing of Paw (∆Pocc) were measured. After an end-inspiratory airway occlusion, Paw reached a plateau, and the magnitude of change in plateau from peak Paw was measured as pressure muscle index (PMI). Esophageal pressure was monitored and inspiratory muscle pressure (Pmus) and Pmus-time product per minute (PTPmus/min) were used as the reference standard for the patient's effort. High and low effort was defined as Pmus > 10 and < 5 cmH2O, or PTPmus/min > 200 and < 50 cmH2O s min-1, respectively.
RESULTS: A total of 246 levels of PS were tested. The low inspiratory effort was diagnosed in 145 (59.0%) and 136 (55.3%) PS levels using respective Pmus and PTPmus/min criterion. The receiver operating characteristic area of the three Paw-based indices by the respective two criteria ranged from 0.87 to 0.95, and balanced sensitivity (0.83-0.96), specificity (0.74-0.88), and positive (0.80-0.91) and negative predictive values (0.78-0.94) were obtained. The high effort was diagnosed in 34 (13.8%) and 17 (6.9%) support levels using Pmus and PTPmus/min criterion, respectively. High receiver operating characteristic areas of the three Paw-based indices by the two criteria were found (0.93-0.95). A high sensitivity (0.80-1.00) and negative predictive value (0.97-1.00) were found with a low positive predictive value (0.23-0.64).
CONCLUSIONS: By performing simple airway occlusion maneuvers, the Paw-based indices could be reliably used to detect low inspiratory efforts. Non-invasive and easily accessible characteristics support their potential bedside use for avoiding over-assistance. More evaluation of their performance is required in cohorts with high effort.
参考来源
- Yang YL, Liu Y, Gao R, et al. Use of airway pressure-based indices to detect high and low inspiratory effort during pressure support ventilation: a diagnostic accuracy study. Ann Intensive Care. 2023. PMID: 37955842. doi:10.1186/s13613-023-01209-7
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。