基于模拟的随机试验:院前急救中ABCDE式认知辅助检查表——CHIPS研究
CHIPS为前瞻性随机病例对照研究,专业急救团队在成人高保真模拟人上完成心肺复苏并达到ROSC。干预组使用将ERC的ROSC指南条目转化为ABCDE结构的检查表,对照组不用。通过分析模拟的连续音视频记录测量指南依从性(绩效评分PS)、时间利用效率(项目/分钟)和工作流程。干预组平均检查表使用时间6.32分钟(2.39–9.18分钟,SD=2.08分钟),PS显著高于对照组(p=0.001,d=0.935),每分钟完成项目数1.48 vs 1.15(差0.33/分钟,25%,p=0.001,d=1.11),工作流程差异未达统计学显著(p=0.079,d=0.563)。作者认为检查表可能对院前结局产生积极影响,使用可能节省时间,并推荐团队暂停以开始和结束检查表。
要点
- 模拟院前ROSC场景中,使用ABCDE检查表的干预组指南依从性评分显著高于对照组(p=0.001,效应量d=0.935)。
- 干预组每分钟完成1.48个项目 vs 对照组1.15个项目,差异0.33/分钟(25%),p=0.001,效应量大(d=1.11)。
- 干预组检查表平均使用时间为6.32分钟(范围2.39–9.18分钟,SD=2.08分钟)。
- 两组工作流程与ABCDE合规性的差异未达统计学显著(p=0.079),但效应量中等(d=0.563),对照组偏离ABCDE的趋势更强。
- 作者建议采用「do verify」方式使用基于ABCDE的检查表,并推荐团队暂停(Team Time Outs)以开始和结束检查表。
适用人群与场景
- 专业急救医疗服务团队,在成人高保真模拟人上执行心肺复苏并达到ROSC的模拟院前场景。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 干预组使用将ERC指南ROSC相关陈述转化为ABCDE记忆结构的检查表;对照组不使用检查表。
- 作者建议检查表可按照「do verify」方式使用,并推荐团队暂停(Team Time Outs)以开始和结束检查表。
研究设计与关键结果
- CHIPS为前瞻性随机病例对照研究,干预组20个场景、对照组21个场景纳入评估。
- 干预组平均检查表使用时间6.32分钟(2.39–9.18分钟;SD=2.08分钟)。
- 干预组平均绩效评分显著高于对照组(p=0.001,d=0.935),效应量大。
- 干预组每分钟完成1.48个项目 vs 对照组1.15个项目,差异0.33/分钟(25%),p=0.001,效应量大(d=1.11)。
- 两组工作流程差异未达统计学显著(p=0.079),效应量中等(d=0.563),对照组偏离ABCDE的趋势更强。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:前瞻性随机病例对照研究(模拟研究)。
- 显著性水平定义为p<0.05,效应量以Cohen's d计算。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 在模拟院前ROSC场景中,使用ABCDE结构检查表可显著提高对指南推荐动作的依从性(PS p=0.001)并提高单位时间完成项目数(1.48 vs 1.15项/分钟,p=0.001)。
- 作者认为检查表可能对院前结局产生积极影响,并可能在院前环境中节省时间。
- 作者建议基于ABCDE记忆法的检查表可按照「do verify」方式使用,并推荐团队暂停以开始和结束检查表。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Checklists are a powerful tool for reduction of mortality and morbidity. Checklists structure complex processes in a reproducible manner, optimize team interaction, and prevent errors related to human factors. Despite wide dissemination of the checklist, effects of checklist use in the prehospital emergency medicine are currently unclear. The aim of the study was to demonstrate that participants achieve higher adherence to guideline-recommended actions, manage the scenario more time-efficient, and thirdly demonstrate better adherence to the ABCDE-compliant workflow in a simulated ROSC situation.
METHODS: CHIPS was a prospective randomized case-control study. Professional emergency medical service teams were asked to perform cardiopulmonary resuscitation on an adult high-fidelity patient simulator achieving ROSC. The intervention group used a checklist which transferred the ERC guideline statements of ROSC into the structure of the 'ABCDE' mnemonic. Guideline adherence (performance score, PS), utilization of process time (items/minute) and workflow were measured by analyzing continuous A/V recordings of the simulation. Pre- and post-questionnaires addressing demographics and relevance of the checklist were recorded. Effect sizes were determined by calculating Cohen's d. The level of significance was defined at p < 0.05.
RESULTS: Twenty scenarios in the intervention group (INT) and twenty-one in the control group (CON) were evaluated. The average time of use of the checklist (CU) in the INT was 6.32 min (2.39-9.18 min; SD = 2.08 min). Mean PS of INT was significantly higher than CON, with a strong effect size (p = 0.001, d = 0.935). In the INT, significantly more items were completed per minute of scenario duration (INT, 1.48 items/min; CON, 1.15 items/min, difference: 0.33/min (25%), p = 0.001), showing a large effect size (d = 1.11). The workflow did not significantly differ between the groups (p = 0.079), although a medium effect size was shown (d = 0.563) with the tendency of the CON group deviating stronger from the ABCDE than the INT.
CONCLUSION: Checklists can have positive effects on outcome in the prehospital setting by significantly facilitates adherence to guidelines. Checklist use may be time-effective in the prehospital setting. Checklists based on the 'ABCDE' mnemonic can be used according to the 'do verify' approach. Team Time Outs are recommended to start and finish checklists.
参考来源
- Droege H, Trentzsch H, Zech A, et al. A simulation-based randomized trial of ABCDE style cognitive aid for emergency medical services CHecklist In Prehospital Settings: the CHIPS-study. Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med. 2023. PMID: 37978554. doi:10.1186/s13049-023-01144-3
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。