疑似脓毒症成人院前早期预警评分:回顾性诊断队列研究
该回顾性诊断队列研究纳入2019年由Yorkshire Ambulance Service转运至Sheffield Teaching Hospitals急诊科的成人急救病例,链接医院记录后识别符合脓毒症-3定义并接受紧急医院治疗者作为参考标准。共链接12 870/24 955(51.6%)例,其中348/12 870(2.7%)参考标准阳性。没有任何策略同时达到敏感度>0.80且阳性预测值>0.15;在诊断印象为脓毒症或感染的患者中,NEWS2的AUC为0.756(95%CI 0.729, 0.783),其他评分未显示明显优于NEWS2。作者认为,将NEWS2与急救人员感染或脓毒症诊断印象结合使用,可识别三分之一至一半的脓毒症病例而不优先处理不可管理的数量。
要点
- 在诊断印象为脓毒症或感染的患者中,NEWS2的AUC为0.756(95%CI 0.729, 0.783),无其他早期预警评分明显更优。
- 急救人员脓毒症或感染印象的敏感度为0.572(95%CI 0.519, 0.623),阳性预测值为0.156(95%CI 0.137, 0.176)。
- 对诊断印象为脓毒症或感染的患者应用NEWS2阈值>4时,敏感度0.522(95%CI 0.469, 0.574)、阳性预测值0.216(95%CI 0.189, 0.245)。
- 对诊断印象为脓毒症或感染的患者应用NEWS2阈值>6时,敏感度0.447(95%CI 0.395, 0.499)、阳性预测值0.274(95%CI 0.239, 0.313)。
- 对诊断印象为脓毒症或感染的患者应用NEWS2阈值>8时,敏感度0.314(95%CI 0.268, 0.365)、阳性预测值0.333(95%CI 0.284, 0.386)。
适用人群与场景
- 2019年由Yorkshire Ambulance Service转运至Sheffield Teaching Hospitals急诊科的成人急救病例。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 参考标准:符合脓毒症-3定义并接受紧急医院治疗的脓毒症。
- 急救人员诊断印象分类为脓毒症、感染、非特异性表现或其他表现。
- 计算21种早期预警评分,并在不同阳性阈值下与急救人员诊断印象组合评估。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:回顾性诊断队列研究;链接12 870/24 955(51.6%)例,参考标准阳性348/12 870(2.7%)。
- 无任何策略同时达到敏感度>0.80且阳性预测值>0.15。
- 在诊断印象为脓毒症或感染的患者中,NEWS2的AUC为0.756(95%CI 0.729, 0.783);无其他早期预警评分明显优于NEWS2。
- 急救人员脓毒症或感染印象的敏感度0.572(95%CI 0.519, 0.623),阳性预测值0.156(95%CI 0.137, 0.176)。
- 对诊断印象为脓毒症或感染的患者,NEWS2阈值>4时敏感度0.522(95%CI 0.469, 0.574)、阳性预测值0.216(95%CI 0.189, 0.245);阈值>6时敏感度0.447(95%CI 0.395, 0.499)、阳性预测值0.274(95%CI 0.239, 0.313);阈值>8时敏感度0.314(95%CI 0.268, 0.365)、阳性预测值0.333(95%CI 0.284, 0.386)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:回顾性诊断队列研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,没有策略是理想的,但将NEWS2与急救人员感染或脓毒症诊断印象结合使用,可识别三分之一至一半的脓毒症病例而不优先处理不可管理的数量。
- 作者认为,没有其他评分明显优于NEWS2。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Ambulance services need to identify and prioritise patients with sepsis for early hospital assessment. We aimed to determine the accuracy of early warning scores alongside paramedic diagnostic impression to identify sepsis that required urgent treatment.
METHODS: We undertook a retrospective diagnostic cohort study involving adult emergency medical cases transported to Sheffield Teaching Hospitals ED by Yorkshire Ambulance Service in 2019. We used routine ambulance service data to calculate 21 early warning scores and categorise paramedic diagnostic impressions as sepsis, infection, non-specific presentation or other presentation. We linked cases to hospital records and identified those meeting the sepsis-3 definition who received urgent hospital treatment for sepsis (reference standard). Analysis determined the accuracy of strategies that combined early warning scores at varying thresholds for positivity with paramedic diagnostic impression.
RESULTS: We linked 12 870/24 955 (51.6%) cases and identified 348/12 870 (2.7%) with a positive reference standard. None of the strategies provided sensitivity greater than 0.80 with positive predictive value greater than 0.15. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve for the National Early Warning Score, version 2 (NEWS2) applied to patients with a diagnostic impression of sepsis or infection was 0.756 (95% CI 0.729, 0.783). No other early warning score provided clearly superior accuracy to NEWS2. Paramedic impression of sepsis or infection had sensitivity of 0.572 (0.519, 0.623) and positive predictive value of 0.156 (0.137, 0.176). NEWS2 thresholds of >4, >6 and >8 applied to patients with a diagnostic impression of sepsis or infection, respectively, provided sensitivities and positive predictive values of 0.522 (0.469, 0.574) and 0.216 (0.189, 0.245), 0.447 (0.395, 0.499) and 0.274 (0.239, 0.313), and 0.314 (0.268, 0.365) and 0.333 (0.284, 0.386).
CONCLUSION: No strategy is ideal but using NEWS2 alongside paramedic diagnostic impression of infection or sepsis could identify one-third to half of sepsis cases without prioritising unmanageable numbers. No other score provided clearly superior accuracy to NEWS2.
TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: researchregistry5268, https://www.researchregistry.com/browse-the-registry%23home/registrationdetails/5de7bbd97ca5b50015041c33/.
参考来源
- Goodacre S, Sutton L, Thomas B, et al. Prehospital early warning scores for adults with suspected sepsis: retrospective diagnostic cohort study. Emerg Med J. 2023. PMID: 37673643. doi:10.1136/emermed-2023-213315
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。