临床医生对急诊科「不适当」就诊的共识:Better Data, Better Planning 普查——爱尔兰急诊科利用的多中心横断面研究
本研究为 Better Data, Better Planning 多中心横断面研究,旨在就爱尔兰急诊科就诊的「适当性」在跨诊疗场景的临床医生间建立共识。患者摘要文件由学术全科医生与学术急诊医学顾问组成的国家小组评估,未达成共识者由独立评审小组评估,各站点所有文件由当地全科医生-急诊医学顾问小组自主评估。国家小组判定 11%(全科医生)至 38%(急诊医学顾问)的 n=306 例低急症度就诊可在 24–48 小时内由全科医生处理(k=0.259;p<0.001),18%(全科医生)至 35%(急诊医学顾问)的就诊可视为「不适当」(k=0.341;p<0.001)。被认为「适当」的就诊入院率为 47%,而「不适当」就诊者为 0%。45% 的病例(n=136)未达成共识。独立评审小组的亚组分析确定,适当就诊的共识范围为 0 至 59%,不适当就诊的共识范围为 0 至 29%。当地小组评审(n=306)中,各急诊站点对适当性的共识范围为 40% 至 76%。作者认为,引入针对可避免就诊的循证照护路径可能有助于缓解急诊科拥挤问题。
要点
- 国家小组判定 11%(全科医生)至 38%(急诊医学顾问)的 n=306 例低急症度就诊可在 24–48 小时内由全科医生处理(k=0.259;p<0.001)。
- 国家小组判定 18%(全科医生)至 35%(急诊医学顾问)的就诊可视为「不适当」(k=0.341;p<0.001)。
- 被认为「适当」的就诊入院率为 47%,而「不适当」就诊者为 0%。
- 45% 的病例(n=136)国家小组未达成共识;独立评审小组亚组分析中适当就诊共识范围为 0 至 59%,不适当就诊为 0 至 29%。
- 当地小组评审(n=306)各急诊站点对适当性的共识范围为 40% 至 76%。
适用人群与场景
- 爱尔兰急诊科就诊患者,纳入 n=306 例低急症度就诊的摘要文件。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 就诊「适当性」由学术全科医生与学术急诊医学顾问国家小组评估;未达成共识的病例由独立评审小组评估;各站点所有文件由当地全科医生-急诊医学顾问小组自主评估。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:多中心横断面研究(Better Data, Better Planning 研究),样本量 n=306 例低急症度就诊。
- 国家小组判定 11%(全科医生)至 38%(急诊医学顾问)的低急症度就诊可在 24–48 小时内由全科医生处理(k=0.259;p<0.001)。
- 国家小组判定 18%(全科医生)至 35%(急诊医学顾问)的就诊可视为「不适当」(k=0.341;p<0.001)。
- 被认为「适当」的就诊入院率为 47%,而「不适当」就诊者为 0%。
- 45% 的病例(n=136)未达成共识。
- 独立评审小组亚组分析:适当就诊的共识范围为 0 至 59%,不适当就诊的共识范围为 0 至 29%。
- 当地小组评审(n=306)中,各急诊站点对适当性的共识范围为 40% 至 76%。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:多中心横断面研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,引入针对可避免就诊的循证照护路径可能有助于缓解急诊科拥挤问题。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Utilisation of the Emergency Department (ED) for non-urgent care increases demand for services, therefore reducing inappropriate or avoidable attendances is an important area for intervention in prevention of ED crowding. This study aims to develop a consensus between clinicians across care settings about the "appropriateness" of attendances to the ED in Ireland.
METHODS: The Better Data, Better Planning study was a multi-centre, cross-sectional study investigating factors influencing ED utilisation in Ireland. Data was compiled in patient summary files which were assessed for measures of appropriateness by an academic General Practitioner (GP) and academic Emergency Medicine Consultant (EMC) National Panel. In cases where consensus was not reached charts were assessed by an Independent Review Panel (IRP). At each site all files were autonomously assessed by local GP-EMC panels.
RESULTS: The National Panel determined that 11% (GP) to 38% (EMC) of n = 306 lower acuity presentations could be treated by a GP within 24-48 h (k = 0.259; p < 0.001) and that 18% (GP) to 35% (EMC) of attendances could be considered "inappropriate" (k = 0.341; p < 0.001). For attendances deemed "appropriate" the admission rate was 47% compared to 0% for "inappropriate" attendees. There was no consensus on 45% of charts (n = 136). Subset analysis by the IRP determined that consensus for appropriate attendances ranged from 0 to 59% and for inappropriate attendances ranged from 0 to 29%. For the Local Panel review (n = 306) consensus on appropriateness ranged from 40 to 76% across ED sites.
CONCLUSIONS: Multidisciplinary clinicians agree that "inappropriate" use of the ED in Ireland is an issue. However, obtaining consensus on appropriateness of attendance is challenging and there was a significant cohort of complex heterogenous presentations where agreement could not be reached by clinicians in this study. This research again demonstrates the complexity of ED crowding, the introduction of evidence-based care pathways targeting avoidable presentations may serve to alleviate the problem in our EDs.
参考来源
- Cummins NM, Barry LA, Garavan C, et al. Clinician consensus on "Inappropriate" presentations to the Emergency Department in the Better Data, Better Planning (BDBP) census: a cross-sectional multi-centre study of emergency department utilisation in Ireland. BMC Health Serv Res. 2023. PMID: 37723478. doi:10.1186/s12913-023-09760-6
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。