通过德尔菲研究就医疗应急团队(MET)撤停决策达成共识
本研究采用德尔菲设计,招募10名在急性医院场景具有近期MET响应经验的专家,进行两轮邮件调查且无脱落,按CREDES指南报告。共识将MET撤停决策分为两步:第一步是受患者情况和病房/组织背景共同影响的撤停决策;第二步是执行撤停前所需的沟通。决策后沟通需口头讨论和书面记录以移交患者责任,具体患者信息、管理计划和升级计划被视为必备。作者认为该要素清单可作为MET响应者和病房员工的核对表,以减少可预防的重复恶化。
要点
- MET撤停决策由患者情况和病房/组织背景两方面共同影响,需同时评估患者与病房安全。
- 执行撤停前必须完成沟通:包括口头讨论和书面记录,以将患者责任移交回病房员工。
- 患者交接必备要素:具体患者信息、管理计划和升级计划。
- 作者建议离开病房前沟通商定的患者治疗与升级计划,以降低重复MET呼叫和可预防的重复恶化。
- 该共识要素可作为MET响应者决策和病房员工MET后照护的核对表,但需观察MET撤停决策过程来验证这些要素。
适用人群与场景
- 急性医院场景中具有近期临床MET响应经验的专家,用于形成MET撤停决策共识。
- 适用场景为MET响应结束、将患者责任交回病房员工进行持续管理时。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- MET撤停决策分两步:第一步为撤停决策,受患者情况和病房/组织背景共同影响;第二步为执行撤停前所需的沟通。
- 撤停前沟通需包括口头讨论和书面记录,以移交患者责任。
- 交接必备要素包括具体患者信息、管理计划和升级计划。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 第一步:综合患者情况和病房/组织背景做出MET撤停决策。
- 第二步:在执行撤停前完成沟通,包括口头讨论和书面记录,移交患者责任。
- 交接内容需包含具体患者信息、管理计划和升级计划。
- 作者建议离开病房前沟通商定的患者治疗与升级计划。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究为德尔菲设计,专家 panel 10名成员,基于专家知识和近期急性医院MET响应经验招募。
- 通过电子邮件发送知情同意书和电子交互式PDF进行每轮调查,共进行两轮,两轮之间无脱落。
- 共识生成MET撤停决策的必备要素,包括两步:撤停决策(受患者情况和病房/组织背景影响)和执行撤停前沟通。
- 决策后沟通需要口头讨论和书面记录以移交患者责任;具体患者信息、管理计划和升级计划被视为必备。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:德尔菲专家共识研究。
- 报告方法:采用CREDES指南报告德尔菲研究的实施与报告。
- 局限:原文报告需观察MET撤停决策过程以验证这些必备要素。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为该共识要素可为临床和MET员工提供从MET向病房员工移交临床责任的过程支持,并明确管理计划以减少重复MET呼叫和改善患者结局。
- 作者建议离开病房前沟通商定的患者治疗和升级计划。
- 该研究可作为MET响应者做出撤停决策和病房员工负责MET后照护的核对表,目标是降低MET患者群体中可预防的重复恶化可能性。
指南或共识出处
- J Clin Nurs 发表的德尔菲研究(CREDES指南报告)
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: A medical emergency team (MET) stand-down decision is the decision to end a MET response and hand responsibility for the patient back to ward staff for ongoing management. Little research has explored this decision. This study aimed to obtain expert consensus on the essential elements required to make optimal MET call stand-down decisions and the communication required before MET departure.
DESIGN: A Delphi design was utilised.
METHODS: An expert panel of 10 members were recruited based on their expert knowledge and recent clinical MET responder experience in acute hospital settings. Participants were emailed a consent form and an electronic interactive PDF for each survey. Two rounds were conducted with no attrition between rounds. The CREDES guidance on conducting and reporting Delphi studies was used to report this study.
RESULTS: Consensus by an expert panel of 10 MET responders generated essential elements of MET stand-down decisions. Essential elements comprised of two steps: (1) the stand-down decision that was influenced by both the patient situation and the ward/organisational context; and (2) the communication required before actioning stand-down. Communication after the decision required both verbal discussions and written documentation to hand over patient responsibility. Specific patient information, a management plan and an escalation plan were considered essential.
CONCLUSION: The Delphi surveys reached consensus on the actions and communication required to stand down a MET call. Passing responsibility back to ward staff after a MET call requires both patient and ward safety assessments, and a clearly articulated patient plan for ward staff. Observation of MET call stand-down decision-making is required to validate the essential elements.
IMPLICATION FOR THE PROFESSION AND PATIENT/OR PATIENT CARE: In specifying the essential elements, this study offers clinical and MET staff a process to support the handing over of clinical responsibility from the MET to the ward staff, and clarification of management plans in order to reduce repeat MET calls and improve patient outcomes.
IMPACT: Minimal research has been focussed on the decision to hand responsibility back to ward staff so the MET may leave the ward with safety plan in place. This study provided expert consensus to optimise MET stand-down decision-making and the ultimate decision to end a MET call. Communication of agreed patient treatment and escalation plans is recommended before leaving the ward. This study can be used as a checklist for MET responder staff making these decisions and ward staff responsible for post-MET call care. The aim being to reduce the likelihood of potentially preventable repeat deterioration in the MET patient population.
REPORTING METHOD: The CREDES guidance on conducting and reporting Delphi studies.
PATIENT OR PUBLIC CONTRIBUTION: None.
参考来源
- Kondos NA, Barrett J, McDonall J, et al. A Delphi study to obtain consensus on medical emergency team (MET) stand-down decision making. J Clin Nurs. 2023. PMID: 37607900. doi:10.1111/jocn.16859
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。