文献速递重症综合管理与镇静镇痛消化、代谢与肾脏急症

临床医生在推定同意制度下的器官捐献对话中如何讨论患者的捐献登记:一项定性嵌入式多案例研究

How clinicians discuss patients' donor registrations of consent and presumed consent in donor conversations in an opt-out system: a qualitative embedded multiple-case study.
PubMed 文献 · Crit Care · 2023-07-28
一句话结论在荷兰推定同意制度下,临床医生讨论患者捐献登记时存在四种路径,严格统一应用推定同意制度不可行,作者建议将四种路径纳入临床培训。

该研究在荷兰八家医院开展定性嵌入式多案例研究,基于15次捐献对话的录音和直接观察(7例同意、8例推定同意)及对16名相关临床医生的访谈进行主题分析。结果显示,临床医生的个人考量、既往与家属的经历及职业背景因素决定其对话出发点,并构建出四条讨论患者捐献登记的路径:同意路径(A)遵循患者明确捐献意愿;推定同意路径(B)依法意图实现捐献,家属认可登记时更易达成;共识路径(C)让家属部分参与决策;家庭同意路径(D)赋予家属完全决策权以促进最优哀伤处理。结论认为,推定同意制度下的捐献对话是看似明确的捐献登记与医患互动之间的复杂交织,当临床医生对患者同意或家属应对存有顾虑时,家属被赋予更大决策角色,严格统一应用推定同意制度不可行。作者建议将四种路径纳入临床培训、促进跨案例讨论并鼓励公众关于捐献的对话。

要点

  • 在推定同意制度下,临床医生讨论患者捐献登记存在四条路径:同意路径(A)、推定同意路径(B)、共识路径(C)、家庭同意路径(D)。
  • 推定同意时,临床医生对解读患者捐献意愿的不确定性增加,促使他们以「法律」作为对话开场并多次与家属核实患者意愿。
  • 推定同意路径(B)中,当家属认可并同意登记时,依法实现捐献更容易达成。
  • 共识路径(C)让家属部分参与决策,家庭同意路径(D)赋予家属完全决策权以促进最优哀伤处理。
  • 作者认为严格统一应用推定同意制度不可行,建议将四种路径纳入临床培训、促进跨案例讨论并鼓励公众关于捐献的对话。

适用人群与场景

  • 荷兰八家医院中参与捐献对话的临床医生及其对话的家属,涉及患者登记为同意(7例)和推定同意(8例)的捐献对话。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型为定性嵌入式多案例研究,在荷兰八家医院开展,基于15次捐献对话的录音和直接观察(7例同意、8例推定同意)及对16名相关临床医生的访谈进行主题分析。
  • 临床医生的个人考量、既往与家属的经历及职业背景因素决定其对话出发点,构建出四条讨论患者捐献登记的路径。
  • 同意路径(A):临床医生遵循患者明确的捐献意愿。
  • 推定同意路径(B):临床医生依法意图实现捐献,当家属认可并同意登记时更容易达成。
  • 共识路径(C):临床医生让家属部分参与决策。
  • 家庭同意路径(D):家属被赋予完全决策权以促进最优哀伤处理。
  • 推定同意时,临床医生对解读患者捐献意愿的不确定性增加,促使他们以「法律」作为对话开场并多次与家属核实患者意愿。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:定性嵌入式多案例研究。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,当临床医生对患者同意或家属应对存有顾虑时,家属被赋予更大决策角色,严格统一应用推定同意制度不可行。
  • 作者建议将四种路径(同意路径、推定同意路径、共识路径、家庭同意路径)纳入临床培训,促进跨案例讨论,并鼓励公众关于捐献的对话。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: The Netherlands introduced an opt-out donor system in 2020. While the default in (presumed) consent cases is donation, family involvement adds a crucial layer of influence when applying this default in clinical practice. We explored how clinicians discuss patients' donor registrations of (presumed) consent in donor conversations in the first years of the opt-out system.

METHODS: A qualitative embedded multiple-case study in eight Dutch hospitals. We performed a thematic analysis based on audio recordings and direct observations of donor conversations (n = 15, 7 consent and 8 presumed consent) and interviews with the clinicians involved (n = 16).

RESULTS: Clinicians' personal considerations, their prior experiences with the family and contextual factors in the clinicians' profession defined their points of departure for the conversations. Four routes to discuss patients' donor registrations were constructed. In the Consent route (A), clinicians followed patients' explicit donation wishes. With presumed consent, increased uncertainty in interpreting the donation wish appeared and prompted clinicians to refer to "the law" as a conversation starter and verify patients' wishes multiple times with the family. In the Presumed consent route (B), clinicians followed the law intending to effectuate donation, which was more easily achieved when families recognised and agreed with the registration. In the Consensus route (C), clinicians provided families some participation in decision-making, while in the Family consent route (D), families were given full decisional capacity to pursue optimal grief processing.

CONCLUSION: Donor conversations in an opt-out system are a complex interplay between seemingly straightforward donor registrations and clinician-family interactions. When clinicians are left with concerns regarding patients' consent or families' coping, families are given a larger role in the decision. A strict uniform application of the opt-out system is unfeasible. We suggest incorporating the four previously described routes in clinical training, stimulating discussions across cases, and encouraging public conversations about donation.

来源:Crit Care,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. van Oosterhout SPC, van der Niet AG, Abdo WF, et al. How clinicians discuss patients' donor registrations of consent and presumed consent in donor conversations in an opt-out system: a qualitative embedded multiple-case study. Crit Care. 2023. PMID: 37507800. doi:10.1186/s13054-023-04581-9

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。