基于实施研究整合框架在急诊科实施老年筛查
本研究报告急诊科基于证据的老年筛查项目(谵妄、跌倒风险、脆弱性筛查并转诊)的最终实施结果与可持续性,使用实施研究整合框架(CFIR)分类障碍、CFIR-ERIC分类实施策略,追踪2021年1月至2022年12月≥65岁成人每月筛查比例。实施策略使老年筛查率从5%升至68%,未达预设80%目标,但在多轮COVID-19疫情中得以维持。内部环境障碍包括文化与实施氛围,且急诊不同单元(夜班与白班)文化与接受度不同;个体特征障碍包括临床与行政岗位高人员流动及压力与流动导致的极低自我效能。个体化审计反馈未能改善自我效能、可能造成道德伤害,改为团队/单元层面反馈与单元范围延展目标后效果更好;识别早期采纳者与在岗教育提高接受度。结论认为疫情加剧了实施障碍,将大型急诊视为多个小单元之和并应用CFIR模型带来了改善。
要点
- 实施策略使急诊≥65岁老年筛查率从5%升至68%,未达到预设80%目标。
- 筛查项目由护士进行谵妄(谵妄分诊筛查)、跌倒风险(4级平衡测试)和脆弱性(老年人风险识别评分)筛查,并随后转诊至医生、治疗专家或社工。
- 改善在多轮COVID-19疫情中得以维持。
- 内部环境障碍包括文化与实施氛围;急诊不同单元(夜班与白班)文化和接受度不同。
- 个体化审计与反馈未能改善自我效能、可能造成道德伤害;团队/单元层面反馈与单元范围延展目标效果更好,识别早期采纳者与在岗教育提高接受度。
适用人群与场景
- 急诊科≥65岁成人,接受护士主导的谵妄、跌倒风险和脆弱性筛查并转诊。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 谵妄筛查采用谵妄分诊筛查(Delirium Triage Screen)。
- 跌倒风险筛查采用4级平衡测试(4-Stage Balance Test)。
- 脆弱性筛查采用老年人风险识别评分(Identification of Seniors at Risk score)。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 护士对≥65岁患者进行谵妄、跌倒风险和脆弱性筛查,随后适当转诊至医生、治疗专家或社工。
- 实施策略按CFIR-ERIC分类,包括识别早期采纳者、在岗教育、团队/单元层面审计与反馈及单元范围延展目标。
研究设计与关键结果
- 实施策略使老年筛查率从5%升至68%,未达到预设80%目标。
- 改善在多轮COVID-19疫情中得以维持。
- 内部环境障碍包括文化与实施氛围;最初将急诊视为单一内部环境,但发现不同急诊单元(包括夜班与白班)之间文化和接受度不同。
- 个体特征障碍包括临床与行政岗位高人员流动,以及压力和人员流动导致的极低自我效能。
- 初始个体化审计与反馈未能改善自我效能,并可能造成道德伤害;调整为团队/单元层面反馈与单元范围延展目标后效果更好。
- 识别早期采纳者与开展在岗教育提高了接受度。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:实施研究,报告基于证据的筛查项目最终实施结果与可持续性。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,将大型急诊视为多个小单元之和并应用CFIR模型可带来改善。
- 作者报告,团队/单元层面反馈与单元范围延展目标比个体化审计与反馈效果更好,且个体化反馈可能造成道德伤害。
- 作者报告,识别早期采纳者与在岗教育可提高接受度。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Implementation of evidence-based care processes (EBP) into the emergency department (ED) is challenging and there are only a few studies of real-world use of theory-based implementation frameworks. We report final implementation results and sustainability of an EBP geriatric screening program in the ED using the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR).
METHODS: The EBP involved nurses screening older patients for delirium (Delirium Triage Screen), fall risk (4-Stage Balance Test), and vulnerability (Identification of Seniors at Risk score) with subsequent appropriate referrals to physicians, therapy specialists, or social workers. The proportions of screened adults ≥65 years old were tracked monthly. Outcomes are reported January 2021-December 2022. Barriers encountered were classified according to CFIR. Implementation strategies were classified according to the CFIR-Expert Recommendations for Implementing Change (ERIC).
RESULTS: Implementation strategies increased geriatric screening from 5% to 68%. This did not meet our prespecified goal of 80%. Change was sustained through several COVID-19 waves. Inner setting barriers included culture and implementation climate. Initially, the ED was treated as a single inner setting, but we found different cultures and uptake between ED units, including night versus day shifts. Characteristics of individuals barriers included high levels of staff turnover in both clinical and administrative roles and very low self-efficacy from stress and staff turnover. Initial attempts with individualized audit and feedback were not successful in improving self-efficacy and may have caused moral injury. Adjusting feedback to a team/unit level approach with unitwide stretch goals worked better. Identifying early adopters and conducting on-shift education increased uptake. Lessons learned regarding ED culture, implementation in interconnected health systems, and rapid cycle process improvement are reported.
CONCLUSIONS: The pandemic exacerbated barriers to implementation in the ED. Cognizance of a large ED as a sum of smaller units and using the CFIR model resulted in improvements.
参考来源
- Southerland LT, Gulker P, Van Fossen J, et al. Implementation of geriatric screening in the emergency department using the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research. Acad Emerg Med. 2023. PMID: 37449967. doi:10.1111/acem.14776
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。