儿童心脏停搏的床旁超声判读
该单中心、在线、横断面、便利抽样调查纳入263名儿科急诊主治医师和fellows,其中110名为曾判读≥25次心脏POCUS的主治医师(主要亚组)。问卷包含11段儿童无脉性停搏期间采集的6秒心脏POCUS视频,询问是否代表心脏停搏。经验≥25次者在全部视频上的观察者间一致性可接受(Kα=0.740;95%CI 0.735-0.745),室壁运动与瓣膜运动一致时一致性最高,而室壁运动无瓣膜运动时一致性降至不可接受(Kα=0.304;95%CI 0.287-0.321)。作者认为,室壁与瓣膜运动不一致、图像质量欠佳及缺乏正式参考标准可能影响一致性,更具体的儿童心脏停搏共识参考标准可能有助于提高观察者间一致性。
要点
- 在曾判读≥25次心脏POCUS的儿科急诊主治医师中,判读儿童心脏停搏的总体观察者间一致性可接受(Kα=0.740;95%CI 0.735-0.745)。
- 室壁运动与瓣膜运动一致的视频片段一致性最高。
- 室壁运动出现而瓣膜运动缺失的视频片段一致性降至不可接受(Kα=0.304;95%CI 0.287-0.321)。
- 作者认为影响一致性的因素包括室壁与瓣膜运动不一致、图像质量欠佳及缺乏正式参考标准。
- 作者认为更具体的儿童心脏停搏共识参考标准可能有助于提高观察者间一致性,并应包含室壁与瓣膜运动的更具体细节。
适用人群与场景
- 儿科急诊主治医师和fellows,超声经验不等;主要亚组为曾判读≥25次心脏POCUS的儿科急诊主治医师(依据美国急诊医师学会设定的超声熟练度标准)。
- 视频片段来自儿童无脉性停搏期间采集的心脏POCUS。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:单中心、在线、横断面、便利抽样调查;共263名儿科急诊主治医师和fellows完成问卷(应答率9.9%),其中110名来自曾判读≥25次心脏POCUS的儿科急诊主治医师主要亚组。
- 问卷包含11段独特的6秒视频片段,均为儿童无脉性停搏期间采集的心脏POCUS,询问判读者该片段是否代表心脏停搏。
- 曾判读≥25次者在全部视频片段上的观察者间一致性可接受(Kα=0.740;95%CI 0.735-0.745)。
- 室壁运动与瓣膜运动一致的视频片段一致性最高。
- 室壁运动出现而瓣膜运动缺失的视频片段一致性降至不可接受(Kα=0.304;95%CI 0.287-0.321)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:单中心、在线、横断面、便利抽样调查。
- 局限:应答率9.9%。
- 局限:作者指出影响一致性的因素包括室壁与瓣膜运动不一致、图像质量欠佳及缺乏正式参考标准。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,更具体的儿童心脏停搏共识参考标准可能有助于提高观察者间一致性,并应包含室壁与瓣膜运动的更具体细节。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
STUDY OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to determine the level of agreement among pediatric emergency medicine (PEM) physicians in whether various point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS) video clips represent cardiac standstill in children and to highlight the factors that may be associated with the lack of agreement.
METHODS: A single, online, cross-sectional, convenience sample survey was administered to PEM attendings and fellows with variable ultrasound experience. PEM attendings with an experience of 25 cardiac POCUS scans or more were the primary subgroup based on ultrasound proficiency set by the American College of Emergency Physicians. The survey contained 11 unique, 6-second video clips of cardiac POCUS performed during pulseless arrest in pediatric patients and asked the respondent if the video clip represented a cardiac standstill. The level of interobserver agreement was determined using the Krippendorff's α (Kα) coefficient across the subgroups.
RESULTS: A total of 263 PEM attendings and fellows completed the survey (9.9% response rate). Of the 263 total responses, 110 responses were from the primary subgroup of experienced PEM attendings with at least 25 previously seen cardiac POCUS scans. Across all video clips, PEM attendings with 25 scans or more had an acceptable agreement (Kα=0.740; 95% CI 0.735 to 0.745). The agreement was the highest for video clips wherein the wall motion corresponded to the valve motion. However, the agreement fell to unacceptable levels (Kα=0.304; 95% CI 0.287 to 0.321) across video clips wherein the wall motion occurred without the valve motion.
CONCLUSION: There is an overall acceptable interobserver agreement when interpreting cardiac standstill among PEM attendings with an experience of at least 25 previously reported cardiac POCUS scans. However, factors that may influence the lack of agreement include discordances between the wall and valve motion, suboptimal views, and the lack of a formal reference standard. More specific consensus reference standards of pediatric cardiac standstill may help to improve interobserver agreement moving forward and should include more specific details regarding the wall and valve motion.
参考来源
- Yanni E, Tsung JW, Hu K, et al. Interpretation of Cardiac Standstill in Children Using Point-of-Care Ultrasound. Ann Emerg Med. 2023. PMID: 37269261. doi:10.1016/j.annemergmed.2023.04.003
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。