文献速递创伤与烧伤

军事创伤研究中引用次数与被颠覆性评分的对比分析:颠覆性军事创伤研究论文前100名分析

Citation versus disruption in the military: Analysis of the top disruptive military trauma research publications.
PubMed 文献 · J Trauma Acute Care Surg · 2023-05-15
一句话结论引用次数与颠覆性评分在军事创伤文献中重叠很少,仅用引用次数可能遗漏改变军事范式的论文。

该文献计量分析检索1954年至2014年间32040篇军事创伤相关文章,比较颠覆性评分前100名(最颠覆)与前100名被引论文。颠覆性前100名论文平均颠覆性评分0.148,多发表于《军事医学》(51%);被引前100名平均颠覆性评分0.009,多发表于《创伤杂志》(53%);仅5篇同时位列两榜。引用次数与颠覆性评分无相关性(r=-0.134;p=0.07),与发育性评分仅弱相关(r=0.215;p=0.003)。作者结论认为颠覆性评分可识别引用次数未捕捉的、改变军事范式的论文,应联合使用多种文献计量指标。

要点

  • 颠覆性评分前100名论文平均评分0.148,其中被引最多者仅列颠覆性第40位,提示引用次数不能替代颠覆性评价。
  • 被引前100名论文平均颠覆性评分0.009,仅5篇同时进入颠覆性前100名和被引前100名,两榜单重叠很少。
  • 引用次数与颠覆性评分无相关性(r=-0.134;p=0.07),与发育性评分仅弱相关(r=0.215;p=0.003)。
  • 全部32040篇文章平均颠覆性评分0.01、平均引用次数22次,68%发表于《军事医学》。
  • 作者结论认为应联合使用多种文献计量指标,避免遗漏有影响力的军事创伤研究。

适用人群与场景

  • 1954年至2014年间发表的军事创伤相关文献,包括军事期刊全部出版物及查询其他顶级外科期刊获得的军事专题出版物。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 颠覆性评分:评分越正越具创新性(颠覆性,DR),越负越趋固化(发育性,DV);引用次数通过iCite NIH工具获取。
  • 以颠覆性评分排序取前100名颠覆性和前100名发育性论文,与引用次数前100名论文比较。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型为文献计量分析,共纳入1954年至2014年间发表的32040篇文章,平均颠覆性评分0.01、平均引用次数22次,68%发表于《军事医学》。
  • 颠覆性前100名论文中51%发表于《军事医学》,平均颠覆性评分0.148;其中被引最多的文章仅列颠覆性第40位。
  • 被引前100名论文平均颠覆性评分0.009,53%发表于《创伤杂志》。
  • 仅5篇论文同时位列颠覆性前100名和被引前100名;19篇同时位列发育性前100名和被引前100名。
  • 引用次数与颠覆性评分无相关性(r=-0.134;p=0.07),与发育性评分仅弱相关(r=0.215;p=0.003)。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:文献计量分析;证据等级:诊断性检验或标准,Ⅳ级。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为颠覆性评分可识别引用次数未捕捉的、改变军事范式和未来研究方向的论文,应联合使用多种文献计量指标以避免遗漏有影响力的军事创伤研究。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Bibliometric analysis of surgical research has become increasingly prevalent. Citation count (CC) is a commonly used marker of research quality, but may overlook impactful military research. The disruption score (DS) evaluates manuscripts on a spectrum from most innovative with more positive scores (disruptive [DR]) to most entrenched with more negative scores (developmental; DV). We sought to analyze the most DR and DV versus most cited research in military trauma.

METHODS: Top trauma articles by DS and by CC were identified via professional literature search. All publications in military journals were included. Military trauma-related keywords were used to query additional top surgical journals for military-focused publications. Publications were linked to the iCite NIH tool for CC and related metrics. The top 100 DR and DV publications by DS were analyzed and compared with the top 100 articles by CC.

RESULTS: Overall, 32,040 articles published between 1954 and 2014 were identified. The average DS and CC were 0.01 and 22, respectively. Most articles were published in Mil Med ( 68%). The top 100 DR articles were frequently published in Mil Med (51%) with a mean DS of 0.148. Of these, the most cited article was only the 40th most disruptive. The top 100 CC articles averaged a DS of 0.009 and were commonly found in J Trauma (53%). Only five publications were on both the top 100 DR and top 100 CC lists; 19 were on both the top DV and CC lists. Citation count was not correlated with DR ( r = -0.134; p = 0.07) and only weakly correlated with DV ( r = 0.215; p = 0.003).

CONCLUSION: DS identifies publications that changed military paradigms and future research directions previously overlooked by citation count alone. The DR and DV articles are distinct with little overlap between highly cited military articles. Multiple bibliometric measures should be employed to avoid overlooking impactful military trauma research.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Diagnostic Test or Criteria; Level IV.

来源:J Trauma Acute Care Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Dilday J, Gallagher S, Bram R, et al. Citation versus disruption in the military: Analysis of the top disruptive military trauma research publications. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2023. PMID: 37184517. doi:10.1097/TA.0000000000004009

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。