文献速递复苏、休克与脓毒症心脑血管急症

量化医生终止复苏的偏倚:TERMINATOR研究

Quantifying physician's bias to terminate resuscitation. The TERMINATOR study.
PubMed 文献 · Resuscitation · 2023-05-05
一句话结论医生个体偏倚显著影响终止复苏决策(OR 2.48),其影响大于无血流时间10–20分钟(OR 1.60)。

该研究从RéAC登记处提取2013年1月至2021年9月期间管理的院外心脏骤停(OHCA)数据,采用广义线性混合模型分析终止复苏(TOR)的二分类决策,以Utstein数据作为固定效应、医生个体作为随机效应。共纳入5,144例OHCA、涉及173名医生,队列平均年龄69岁(SD 18),女性占62%,中位无血流时间和低血流时间分别为6分钟(IQR [0,12])和18分钟(IQR [10,26])。分析显示医生对TOR决策有显著影响(p < 0.001),医生效应OR为2.48 [2.13–2.94](医生高于均值一个SD时),低于日常生活依赖(OR 41.18 [24.69–65.50])和年龄>85岁(OR 38.60 [28.67–51.08]),但高于肿瘤、心血管、呼吸系统疾病或无血流时间10–20分钟(OR 1.60 [1.26–2.00])。作者认为,医生个体偏倚在TOR决策中存在,其影响大于无血流时间10–20分钟,并呼吁开发工具和指南以指导医生决策。

要点

  • 医生个体效应对TOR决策有显著影响(p < 0.001),医生高于均值一个SD时OR为2.48 [2.13–2.94]。
  • 医生效应OR 2.48低于日常生活依赖(OR 41.18 [24.69–65.50])和年龄>85岁(OR 38.60 [28.67–51.08])对TOR的影响。
  • 医生效应OR 2.48高于肿瘤、心血管、呼吸系统疾病或无血流时间10–20分钟(OR 1.60 [1.26–2.00])对TOR的影响。
  • 共纳入5,144例OHCA、173名医生;中位无血流时间6分钟(IQR [0,12]),低血流时间18分钟(IQR [10,26])。
  • 作者认为医生个体偏倚影响TOR决策,呼吁开发工具和指南指导决策。

适用人群与场景

  • 2013年1月至2021年9月期间在RéAC登记处管理的院外心脏骤停(OHCA)患者,共5,144例,涉及173名医生。
  • 队列平均年龄69岁(SD 18),女性占62%。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型:基于RéAC登记处的统计分析,采用广义线性混合模型,以Utstein数据为固定效应、医生个体为随机效应,建模TOR二分类决策。
  • 共纳入5,144例OHCA、173名医生;中位无血流时间6分钟(IQR [0,12]),中位低血流时间18分钟(IQR [10,26])。
  • 医生对TOR决策有显著影响(p < 0.001);医生高于均值一个SD时,医生效应OR为2.48 [2.13–2.94]。
  • 日常生活依赖的OR为41.18 [24.69–65.50],年龄>85岁的OR为38.60 [28.67–51.08],均高于医生效应OR。
  • 肿瘤、心血管、呼吸系统疾病或无血流时间10–20分钟的OR为1.60 [1.26–2.00],低于医生效应OR。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:基于登记处的观察性统计分析(广义线性混合模型)。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,医生个体偏倚在TOR决策中存在,其影响大于无血流时间10–20分钟。
  • 作者呼吁开发工具和指南以指导医生做出TOR决策。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

CONTEXT: Deciding on "termination of resuscitation" (TOR) is a dilemma for any physician facing cardiac arrest. Due to the lack of evidence-based criteria and scarcity of the existing guidelines, crucial arbitration to interrupt resuscitation remains at the practitioner's discretion.

AIM: Evaluate with a quantitative method the existence of a physician internal bias to terminate resuscitation.

METHOD: We extracted data concerning OHCAs managed between January 2013 and September 2021 from the RéAC registry. We conducted a statistical analysis using generalized linear mixed models to model the binary TOR decision. Utstein data were used as fixed effect terms and a random effect term to model physicians personal bias towards TOR.

RESULTS: 5,144 OHCAs involving 173 physicians were included. The cohort's average age was 69 (SD 18) and was composed of 62% of women. Median no-flow and low-flow times were respectively 6 (IQR [0,12]) and 18 (IQR [10,26]) minutes. Our analysis showed a significant (p < 0.001) physician effect on TOR decision. Odds ratio for the "doctor effect" was 2.48 [2.13-2.94] for a doctor one SD above the mean, lower than that of dependency for activities of daily living (41.18 [24.69-65.50]), an age of more than 85 years (38.60 [28.67-51.08]), but higher than that of oncologic, cardiovascular, respiratory disease or no-flow duration between 10 to 20 minutes (1.60 [1.26-2.00]).

CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrate the existence of individual physician biases in their decision about TOR. The impact of this bias is greater than that of a no-flow duration lasting ten to twenty minutes. Our results plead in favor developing tools and guidelines to guide physicians in their decision.

来源:Resuscitation,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Laurenceau T, Marcou Q, Agostinucci JM, et al. Quantifying physician's bias to terminate resuscitation. The TERMINATOR study. Resuscitation. 2023. PMID: 37150394. doi:10.1016/j.resuscitation.2023.109818

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。