证据整合到院前急救教育及高风险考核的共识标准
该共识由美国国家急救员注册机构(National Registry)与院前指南联盟(PGC)召集专家组,采用德尔菲法(虚拟会议与电子调查)经四轮构建证据表矩阵。第一轮识别24类证据来源,第二轮按质量分为高质量4类、中等质量15类、低质量5类,并按用途分为提供推荐10类、原始研究7类、教育内容7类。第四轮建立分层整合系统,高质量来源可立即纳入,低质量来源需更严格条件。该框架为院前急救能力评估快速、标准化整合新证据提供方法。
要点
- 专家组共识别24类院前急救证据来源,按质量分为高质量4类、中等质量15类、低质量5类。
- 按用途分为提供推荐10类、原始研究7类、教育内容7类。
- 第四轮建立分层整合系统:高质量来源可立即纳入考核,低质量来源需满足更严格条件。
- 框架目标为将新证据快速、标准化地整合进院前急救初始及持续能力考核。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 分层整合系统:高质量证据来源可立即纳入能力考核;低质量证据来源需满足更严格的条件方可纳入。
研究设计与关键结果
- 制定机构:美国国家急救员注册机构(National Registry of Emergency Medical Technicians)与院前指南联盟(Prehospital Guidelines Consortium)召集专家组。
- 方法:德尔菲法,包括虚拟会议和电子调查,共四轮;描述性统计计算,定性分析由两名独立评审员和第三名仲裁者完成。
- 第一轮:识别24类可用于院前急救教育的证据来源。
- 第二轮:按证据质量分为高质量4类、中等质量15类、低质量5类;按用途分为提供推荐10类、原始研究7类、教育内容7类。
- 第三轮:根据参与者反馈修订证据表。
- 第四轮:专家组制定分层证据整合系统,从高质量来源立即整合到低质量来源需更严格要求。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:专家共识(德尔菲法)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为证据表为将新来源材料快速、标准化地整合进院前急救能力考核提供了框架。
- 未来目标是评估证据表框架在初始和持续能力考核中的应用。
指南或共识出处
- 共识标准:证据整合到院前急救教育及高风险考核(Consensus Standard for Evidence Integration into EMS Education and High-Stakes Testing),来源期刊 Prehosp Disaster Med。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「适用人群与场景」「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Incorporating emerging knowledge into Emergency Medical Service (EMS) competency assessments is critical to reflect current evidence-based out-of-hospital care. However, a standardized approach is needed to incorporate new evidence into EMS competency assessments because of the rapid pace of knowledge generation.
OBJECTIVE: The objective was to develop a framework to evaluate and integrate new source material into EMS competency assessments.
METHODS: The National Registry of Emergency Medical Technicians (National Registry) and the Prehospital Guidelines Consortium (PGC) convened a panel of experts. A Delphi method, consisting of virtual meetings and electronic surveys, was used to develop a Table of Evidence matrix that defines sources of EMS evidence. In Round One, participants listed all potential sources of evidence available to inform EMS education. In Round Two, participants categorized these sources into: (a) levels of evidence quality; and (b) type of source material. In Round Three, the panel revised a proposed Table of Evidence. Finally, in Round Four, participants provided recommendations on how each source should be incorporated into competency assessments depending on type and quality. Descriptive statistics were calculated with qualitative analyses conducted by two independent reviewers and a third arbitrator.
RESULTS: In Round One, 24 sources of evidence were identified. In Round Two, these were classified into high- (n = 4), medium- (n = 15), and low-quality (n = 5) of evidence, followed by categorization by purpose into providing recommendations (n = 10), primary research (n = 7), and educational content (n = 7). In Round Three, the Table of Evidence was revised based on participant feedback. In Round Four, the panel developed a tiered system of evidence integration from immediate incorporation of high-quality sources to more stringent requirements for lower-quality sources.
CONCLUSION: The Table of Evidence provides a framework for the rapid and standardized incorporation of new source material into EMS competency assessments. Future goals are to evaluate the application of the Table of Evidence framework in initial and continued competency assessments.
参考来源
- Gage CB, Terry M, McKenna KD, et al. Consensus Standard for Evidence Integration into EMS Education and High-Stakes Testing. Prehosp Disaster Med. 2023. PMID: 37139715. doi:10.1017/S1049023X2300047X
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。