指南与共识呼吸衰竭与机械通气儿科与产科急症

公共卫生紧急状态下快速制定基于证据与共识的SARS-CoV-2学校传播控制指南——一项过程评估

Rapid development of an evidence- and consensus-based guideline for controlling transmission of SARS-CoV-2 in schools during a public health emergency - A process evaluation.
指南 / 共识 · Front Public Health · 2023-03-30
一句话结论德国首次在3个月内用WHO-INTEGRATE框架制定学校SARS-CoV-2防控指南,过程评估显示时间压力与证据基础有限是主要挑战。

该研究对德国学校SARS-CoV-2防控措施指南的制定过程进行定性评估,指南采用WHO-INTEGRATE框架、由多利益相关方小组在3个月内完成。研究对15名参与指南制定的对象进行半结构化访谈,包括小组成员(科学家、实践者、学校家庭和观察员)及指南秘书处,采用Kuckartz演绎-归纳主题质性文本分析。结果显示:时间压力导致指南秘书处深度参与证据合成与推荐起草;仅由科学家起草推荐并应用WHO-INTEGRATE框架受到参与者批评,框架潜力可能未充分发挥;参与者对有效证据的理解不同,可用证据基础有限;科学证据类专长与生活经验类专长影响参与程度。结论认为3个月内制定此类指南具有挑战性,吸取经验有助于公共卫生指南制定的制度化与方法完善。

要点

  • 指南在3个月内制定完成,时间压力使指南秘书处不仅负责证据合成,还深度参与推荐的形成与起草。
  • 仅由科学家起草推荐并应用WHO-INTEGRATE框架,参与者批评该做法,认为框架的全部潜力可能未被发挥。
  • 参与者对相关且有效证据的理解存在差异,且可用的证据基础有限。
  • 参与者代表科学证据类专长与生活经验类专长,两类专长影响其在指南制定过程和会议讨论中的参与。
  • 作者认为,从该过程吸取经验、将公共卫生指南制定制度化并完善方法,有助于德国及其他地区在平时和突发公共卫生事件中做出更循证的公共卫生决策。

适用人群与场景

  • 德国学校SARS-CoV-2防控措施指南制定过程的参与者,包括小组成员(科学家、实践者、学校家庭和观察员)及指南秘书处。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型:过程评估,采用半结构化访谈的质性研究;共进行15次半结构化访谈,以线上方式开展。
  • 研究对象:旨在纳入参与指南制定的所有群体视角,包括小组成员(科学家、实践者、学校家庭和观察员)和指南秘书处。
  • 分析方法:采用Kuckartz演绎-归纳主题质性文本分析,以类别系统结构化研究发现。
  • 主要发现:时间压力下指南秘书处不仅负责证据合成,还深度参与推荐的形成与起草。
  • 主要发现:参与者批评仅由科学家起草推荐并应用WHO-INTEGRATE框架等方法学决策,框架的全部潜力可能未被发挥。
  • 主要发现:参与者对相关且有效证据的理解存在差异,可用的证据基础有限。
  • 主要发现:参与者代表不同类型专长,尤其是科学证据类专长与生活经验类专长,影响其参与指南制定过程和会议讨论。
  • 结论:在仅3个月内制定基于证据与共识的公共卫生指南具有挑战性,尤其因涉及广泛利益相关方并使用新型证据到决策框架,两者在德国均属首次。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:过程评估(质性访谈研究)。
  • 局限:原文在结果中报告了参与者对方法学决策的批评、框架潜力可能未充分发挥、参与者对证据理解存在差异、可用证据基础有限等过程局限。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,从该过程吸取经验、将公共卫生指南制定制度化并完善方法,可有助于德国及其他地区在平时和突发公共卫生事件中做出更循证的公共卫生决策。

指南或共识出处

  • WHO-INTEGRATE框架(原文提及用于指南制定)。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

INTRODUCTION: Different measures to prevent and control the spread of SARS-CoV-2 have been implemented in German schools. Decisions regarding such measures should be informed by evidence regarding their effectiveness, and their unintended consequences for health and society. A multi-stakeholder panel was convened to develop an evidence- and consensus-based guideline for school measures, using the novel WHO-INTEGRATE framework. Developing a guideline to inform decision-making outside of the clinical realm during a public health emergency was unprecedented in Germany. This study aims to identify lessons learnt for similar endeavours by addressing the following research question: What were the strengths and weaknesses of the guideline development process as perceived by the different groups involved?

METHODS: Fifteen semi-structured interviews were conducted virtually. We recruited participants aiming to include the perspectives of all groups contributing to the guideline development, including both panel members (scientists, practitioners, school family and observers) and the guideline secretariat. For analysis, we carried out deductive-inductive thematic qualitative text analysis according to Kuckartz, structuring findings using a category system.

RESULTS: Due to time pressure, the guideline secretariat was heavily involved not only in synthesising the evidence but also in developing and drafting recommendations. Participants critically reflected on certain methods-related decisions, including the development of draft recommendations and application of the WHO-INTEGRATE framework by scientists only. The full potential of the framework might not have been harnessed. Participants' understanding of relevant and valid evidence varied, and the available evidence base was limited. Participants represented different types of expertise, notably expertise informed by scientific evidence and expertise grounded in lived experience, influencing their involvement in the guideline development process and discussions during meetings.

CONCLUSION: Developing an evidence- and consensus-based public health guideline in only three months was challenging, notably because of the involvement of a broad range of stakeholders and the use of a novel Evidence-to-Decision framework, both unprecedented in Germany. Learning from this process with a view to "institutionalising" the development of public health guidelines and refining methods can contribute to more evidence-informed public health decision-making in Germany and beyond, in general and during a public health emergency.

来源:Front Public Health,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Wabnitz K, Rueb M, Pfadenhauer LM, et al. Rapid development of an evidence- and consensus-based guideline for controlling transmission of SARS-CoV-2 in schools during a public health emergency - A process evaluation. Front Public Health. 2023. PMID: 37064706. doi:10.3389/fpubh.2023.1075210

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。