重症监护医师的道德取向、道德决策与道德困境:一项定性研究
该研究为访谈式定性研究,采用归纳主题分析,纳入20名在加拿大ICU执业的重症监护医师,这些医师此前完成了一项全国性ICU医师道德困境横断面调查并表示有兴趣参加半结构化访谈。研究归纳出四种临床道德取向:美德型、顺从型、授权型与共情型,由个人道德信念强度与对道德临床决策的感知权力独特组合形成,并受社会文化、法律与临床背景影响。照护团队内个体道德取向之间的失调程度部分决定了医师从同事处获得的「负面评判」和/或「社会支持」的数量。道德困境、道德满足感、社会评判与社会支持水平最终影响ICU医师所经历的负面后果类型与严重程度。作者认为,对道德取向的扩展理解提供了应对重症监护环境中道德困境问题的额外工具。
要点
- 研究归纳出四种临床道德取向:美德型、顺从型、授权型与共情型,由个人道德信念强度与对道德临床决策的感知权力组合形成。
- 照护团队内个体道德取向之间的失调程度部分决定医师从同事处获得的「负面评判」和/或「社会支持」的数量。
- 社会文化、法律与临床背景影响个体医师的道德取向,道德取向又改变感知到的道德困境与道德满足感。
- 道德困境、道德满足感、社会评判与社会支持水平最终影响ICU医师所经历的负面后果类型与严重程度。
- 作者认为道德取向的多样性可能部分解释临床医师道德困境水平的差异,并可能促成ICU环境中的人际冲突。
适用人群与场景
- 在加拿大ICU执业的重症监护医师,此前完成一项全国性ICU医师道德困境横断面调查并表示有兴趣参加半结构化访谈。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究设计为访谈式定性研究,采用归纳主题分析,纳入20名在加拿大ICU执业的重症监护医师。
- 参与者描述了感知和解决道德挑战性临床情境的不同方式,归纳为四种临床道德取向:美德型、顺从型、授权型与共情型。
- 道德取向由个人道德信念强度与对道德临床决策的感知权力独特组合形成,导致不同的道德决策理由。
- 社会文化、法律与临床背景影响个体医师的道德取向,道德取向改变感知到的道德困境与道德满足感。
- 照护团队内个体道德取向之间的失调程度部分决定医师从同事处获得的「负面评判」和/或「社会支持」的数量。
- 道德困境、道德满足感、社会评判与社会支持水平最终影响ICU医师所经历的负面后果类型与严重程度。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:访谈式定性研究(归纳主题分析)。
- 作者认为,对道德取向的扩展理解提供了应对重症监护环境中道德困境问题的额外工具。
- 作者指出,道德取向的多样性可能部分解释临床医师道德困境水平的差异,并可能促成ICU环境中的人际冲突。
- 作者指出,非常需要对不同临床环境中的不同道德取向进行进一步调查,以为设计有效的系统性和机构性干预提供信息,从而应对医疗专业人员的道德困境并减轻其负面后果。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,对道德取向的扩展理解提供了应对重症监护环境中道德困境问题的额外工具。
- 作者认为,道德取向的多样性可能部分解释临床医师道德困境水平的差异,并可能促成ICU环境中的人际冲突。
- 作者指出,非常需要对不同临床环境中的不同道德取向进行进一步调查,以为设计有效的系统性和机构性干预提供信息。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
UNLABELLED: Moral distress is common among critical care physicians and can impact negatively healthcare individuals and institutions. Better understanding inter-individual variability in moral distress is needed to inform future wellness interventions.
OBJECTIVES: To explore when and how critical care physicians experience moral distress in the workplace and its consequences, how physicians' professional interactions with colleagues affected their perceived level of moral distress, and in which circumstances professional rewards were experienced and mitigated moral distress.
DESIGN: Interview-based qualitative study using inductive thematic analysis.
SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: Twenty critical care physicians practicing in Canadian ICUs who expressed interest in participating in a semi-structured interview after completion of a national, cross-sectional survey of moral distress in ICU physicians.
RESULTS: Study participants described different ways to perceive and resolve morally challenging clinical situations, which were grouped into four clinical moral orientations: virtuous, resigned, deferring, and empathic. Moral orientations resulted from unique combinations of strength of personal moral beliefs and perceived power over moral clinical decision-making, which led to different rationales for moral decision-making. Study findings illustrate how sociocultural, legal, and clinical contexts influenced individual physicians' moral orientation and how moral orientation altered perceived moral distress and moral satisfaction. The degree of dissonance between individual moral orientations within care team determined, in part, the quantity of "negative judgments" and/or "social support" that physicians obtained from their colleagues. The levels of moral distress, moral satisfaction, social judgment, and social support ultimately affected the type and severity of the negative consequences experienced by ICU physicians.
CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: An expanded understanding of moral orientations provides an additional tool to address the problem of moral distress in the critical care setting. Diversity in moral orientations may explain, in part, the variability in moral distress levels among clinicians and likely contributes to interpersonal conflicts in the ICU setting. Additional investigations on different moral orientations in various clinical environments are much needed to inform the design of effective systemic and institutional interventions that address healthcare professionals' moral distress and mitigate its negative consequences.
参考来源
- Piquette D, Burns KEA, Carnevale F, et al. Moral Orientation, Moral Decision-Making, and Moral Distress Among Critical Care Physicians: A Qualitative Study. Crit Care Explor. 2023. PMID: 36895887. doi:10.1097/CCE.0000000000000879
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。