指南与共识消化、代谢与肾脏急症

低确定性证据下的强推荐:对国家指南套件的横断面分析

Strong recommendations from low certainty evidence: a cross-sectional analysis of a suite of national guidelines.
指南 / 共识 · BMC Med Res Methodol · 2023-03-25
一句话结论爱尔兰国家指南中63.6%的强推荐基于低或极低确定性证据,其中73.7%可归入GRADE五种范式情境但指南均未明确说明。

该横断面分析纳入爱尔兰国家临床有效性委员会(NCEC)网站上使用GRADE方法(完全或部分)的全部国家临床指南,提取所有推荐及其证据确定性、推荐强度和理由,将低确定性证据下的强推荐(不一致推荐)归类至GRADE五种范式情境。在8部指南的202条推荐中,151条(74.7%)为强推荐,其中96条(63.6%)基于低或极低确定性证据;96条不一致推荐中55条(73.7%)与五种范式情境一致,但无一部指南明确描述。作者认为指南制定者需要进一步指导以提高不一致推荐理由报告的透明度。

要点

  • 202条推荐中151条(74.7%)为强推荐,51条(25.3%)为条件推荐。
  • 151条强推荐中96条(63.6%)基于低或极低确定性证据,被归为不一致推荐。
  • 96条不一致推荐中55条(73.7%)符合GRADE五种范式情境之一,但指南均未明确说明。
  • 不一致推荐比例高于部分既往国际研究(所有强推荐中不一致占30-50%),但与其它聚焦急诊情境的指南相似。
  • 作者认为指南制定者需要进一步指导,以更透明地报告不一致推荐的理由。

适用人群与场景

  • 使用GRADE方法(完全或部分)的爱尔兰国家临床有效性委员会(NCEC)国家临床指南,纳入分析时共29部指南中8部符合条件。
  • 8部纳入指南中一半聚焦急诊情境。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • GRADE将推荐强度分为强推荐与条件推荐,证据确定性分为高、中、低、极低。
  • 低或极低确定性证据下的强推荐定义为不一致推荐(discordant recommendation),可归类至GRADE五种范式情境(如危及生命的情境)。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 横断面分析:从29部NCEC临床指南中识别8部使用GRADE的指南,共240条推荐,排除38条未使用GRADE的推荐,最终分析202条推荐。
  • 202条推荐中151条(74.7%)为强推荐,51条(25.3%)为条件推荐。
  • 151条强推荐中55条(36.4%)有高或中等确定性证据支持,96条(63.6%)基于低或极低确定性证据,为不一致推荐。
  • 96条不一致推荐中55条(73.7%)与GRADE五种范式情境之一一致,但指南内均未明确描述。
  • 不一致推荐比例高于部分既往国际研究(所有强推荐中不一致占30-50%),但与其它聚焦急诊情境的指南相似。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:对爱尔兰国家临床指南的横断面分析。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,指南制定者需要进一步指导,以便更透明地报告不一致推荐的理由。

指南或共识出处

  • 爱尔兰国家临床有效性委员会(NCEC)国家临床指南(使用GRADE方法)

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Clinical guidelines should be based on a thorough evaluation of the evidence and generally include a rating of the quality of evidence and assign a strength to recommendations. Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) guidance warns against making strong recommendations when the certainty of the evidence is low or very low, but has identified five paradigmatic situations (e.g. life-threatening situations) where this may be justified.

AIMS AND OBJECTIVES: We aimed to characterize the strength of recommendations and certainty of the evidence in Irish National Clinical Guidelines using the GRADE approach.

METHODS: All National Clinical Guidelines from the National Clinical Effectiveness Committee (NCEC) website using the GRADE approach (fully or partially) were included. All recommendations and their corresponding certainty of the evidence, strength of recommendations and justifications were extracted. Authors classified instances of strong recommendations with low certainty evidence (referred to as discordant recommendations) into one of the five paradigmatic situations. Descriptive statistics were calculated.

RESULTS: From the 29 NCEC Clinical Guidelines available at the time of analysis, we identified 8 guidelines using GRADE with a total of 240 recommendations; 38 recommendations did not use the GRADE approach and were excluded. Half of the included guidelines focused on emergency situations. In the final dataset of 202 recommendations, 151 (74.7%) were classified as strong and 51 (25.3%) as conditional. Of the 151 strong recommendations, 55 (36.4%) were supported by high or moderate certainty evidence and 96 (63.6%) by low or very low certainty evidence and were considered discordant. Of these 96 discordant recommendations, 55 (73.7%) were consistent with one of the five paradigmatic situations. However, none were specifically described as such within the guidelines.

CONCLUSIONS: The proportion of discordant recommendations identified in this analysis was higher than some previous international studies (range of all strong recommendations being discordant 30-50%), but similar to other guidelines focused on emergency situations. The majority of discordant recommendations could be mapped to one of the five situations, but no National Clinical Guideline explicitly referenced this. Guideline developers require further guidance to enable greater transparency in the reporting of the reasons for discordant recommendations.

来源:BMC Med Res Methodol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Chong MC, Sharp MK, Smith SM, et al. Strong recommendations from low certainty evidence: a cross-sectional analysis of a suite of national guidelines. BMC Med Res Methodol. 2023. PMID: 36966277. doi:10.1186/s12874-023-01895-8

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。