基于数字照片的蘑菇识别软件准确性比较
该研究比较了三款蘑菇识别软件(Picture Mushroom、Mushroom Identificator、iNaturalist)对 2020—2021 年两年间送至维多利亚毒物信息中心与维多利亚皇家植物园的 78 份标本数字照片的识别准确性,由三位研究者独立测试,蘑菇鉴定由专家真菌学家确认。Picture Mushroom 最准确,正确识别 49%(95%CI [0-100]),Mushroom Identificator 为 35%(95%CI [15-56]),iNaturalist 为 35%(95%CI [0-76])。对有毒蘑菇,Picture Mushroom 正确识别 44%(95%CI [0-95]),Mushroom Identificator 为 30%(95%CI [1-58]),iNaturalist 为 40%(95%CI [0-84)。对毒鹅膏(Amanita phalloides),Mushroom Identificator 正确识别 67%,高于 Picture Mushroom 的 60% 和 iNaturalist 的 27%。作者结论认为,蘑菇识别软件未来可能有助于临床毒理学家和公众准确识别蘑菇种类,但目前单独使用尚不可靠,不足以排除潜在有毒蘑菇暴露。
要点
- 三款软件对 78 份标本的整体正确识别率:Picture Mushroom 49%(95%CI [0-100])、Mushroom Identificator 35%(95%CI [15-56])、iNaturalist 35%(95%CI [0-76])。
- 对有毒蘑菇的正确识别率:Picture Mushroom 44%(95%CI [0-95])、Mushroom Identificator 30%(95%CI [1-58])、iNaturalist 40%(95%CI [0-84)。
- 对毒鹅膏(Amanita phalloides)的正确识别率:Mushroom Identificator 67%、Picture Mushroom 60%、iNaturalist 27%;毒鹅膏被 Picture Mushroom 错误识别 2 次、被 iNaturalist 错误识别 1 次。
- 作者结论:蘑菇识别软件目前单独使用尚不可靠,不足以排除潜在有毒蘑菇暴露。
适用人群与场景
- 送至维多利亚毒物信息中心与维多利亚皇家植物园的蘑菇标本,数字照片用于软件测试。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 毒鹅膏(Amanita phalloides)被 Picture Mushroom 错误识别 2 次、被 iNaturalist 错误识别 1 次。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为三款软件准确性比较研究,样本为 2020—2021 年两年间送至维多利亚毒物信息中心与维多利亚皇家植物园的 78 份标本数字照片,每款软件由三位研究者独立测试,蘑菇鉴定由专家真菌学家确认。
- Picture Mushroom 整体正确识别 49%(95%CI [0-100]),Mushroom Identificator 35%(95%CI [15-56]),iNaturalist 35%(95%CI [0-76])。
- 有毒蘑菇正确识别率:Picture Mushroom 44%(95%CI [0-95]),Mushroom Identificator 30%(95%CI [1-58]),iNaturalist 40%(95%CI [0-84)。
- 毒鹅膏(Amanita phalloides)正确识别率:Mushroom Identificator 67%、Picture Mushroom 60%、iNaturalist 27%;毒鹅膏被 Picture Mushroom 错误识别 2 次、被 iNaturalist 错误识别 1 次。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:软件准确性比较研究;局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为蘑菇识别软件未来可能有助于临床毒理学家和公众准确识别蘑菇种类,但目前单独使用尚不可靠,不足以排除潜在有毒蘑菇暴露。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To compare the accuracy of three popular mushroom identification software applications in identifying mushrooms involved in exposures reported to the Victorian Poisons Information Centre and Royal Botanic Gardens Victoria.
BACKGROUND: Over the past 10 years, an increasing number of software applications have been developed for use on smart phones and tablet devices to identify mushrooms. We have observed an increase in poisonings after incorrect identification of poisonous species as edible, using these applications.
DESIGN: We compared the accuracy of three iPhone™ and Android™ mushroom identification applications: Picture Mushroom (Next Vision Limited©), Mushroom Identificator (Pierre Semedard©), and iNaturalist (iNaturalist, California Academy of Sciences©). Each app was tested independently by three researchers using digital photographs of 78 specimens sent to the Victorian Poisons Information Centre and Royal Botanic Gardens Victoria over a two-year period, 2020-2021. Mushroom identification was confirmed by an expert mycologist. For each app, individual and combined results were compared.
RESULTS: Picture Mushroom was the most accurate of the three apps and correctly identified 49% (95% CI [0-100]) of specimens, compared with Mushroom Identificator (35% [15-56]) and iNaturalist (35% [0-76]). Picture Mushroom correctly identified 44% of poisonous mushrooms [0-95], compared with Mushroom Identificator (30% [1-58]) and iNaturalist (40% [0-84), but Mushroom Identificator identified more specimens of Amanita phalloides correctly (67%), compared to Picture Mushroom (60%) and iNaturalist (27%). Amanita phalloides was falsely identified, twice by Picture Mushroom and once by iNaturalist.
CONCLUSIONS: Mushroom identification applications may be useful future tools to assist clinical toxicologists and the general public in the accurate identification of mushrooms species but, at present, are not reliable enough to exclude exposure to potentially poisonous mushrooms when used alone.
参考来源
- Hodgson SE, McKenzie C, May TW, et al. A comparison of the accuracy of mushroom identification applications using digital photographs. Clin Toxicol (Phila). 2023. PMID: 36794335. doi:10.1080/15563650.2022.2162917
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。