重症监护远程医疗项目对流程质量改进的有效性(ERIC):多中心阶梯楔形整群随机对照试验
本研究为研究者发起的多中心、开放标签、阶梯楔形整群随机对照试验,纳入预计ICU停留≥24小时的成人ICU患者,在柏林和勃兰登堡12个ICU整群中比较标准治疗与远程医疗干预(每日远程查房结合8项德国急性ICU质量指标及专家会诊)对患者每日质量指标依从性的影响。2018年9月4日至2020年3月31日共纳入1463例患者(对照414例,干预1049例),评估14783个患者日。干预显著提高镇静镇痛谵妄、通气、脱机、感染管理、肠内营养、患者与家属沟通、早期活动7项指标依从性,日常多专业联合查房依从性无显著差异,并检测到与干预相关及无关的时间趋势。作者结论认为远程医疗质量改进项目提高了7项循证绩效指标的依从性,但需在更广泛区域非学术社区医院及其他医疗体系中进一步确认。
要点
- 阶梯楔形整群随机对照试验纳入1463例成人ICU患者(对照414例,干预1049例),共评估14783个患者日。
- 干预显著提高「镇静、镇痛和谵妄」指标依从性(校正OR 5.328,99.375%CI 3.395-8.358)。
- 干预显著提高「脱机」指标依从性(OR 9.049,99.375%CI 2.707-30.247)及「通气」指标依从性(OR 2.248,99.375%CI 1.198-4.217)。
- 干预显著提高「感染管理」(OR 4.397,99.375%CI 1.482-13.037)、「患者与家属沟通」(OR 6.787,99.375%CI 3.976-11.589)、「早期活动」(OR 3.161,99.375%CI 2.160-4.624)及「肠内营养」(OR 1.579,99.375%CI 1.032-2.416)依从性。
- 「每日多专业跨学科临床查房」依从性两组间无显著差异(OR 1.606,99.375%CI 0.780-3.309)。
适用人群与场景
- 德国柏林和勃兰登堡区域ICU网络的成人ICU患者,预计ICU停留≥24小时。
- 12个ICU整群随机分为三个序列组,从标准治疗过渡到远程医疗干预;最终10个整群纳入患者(2个随机整群未纳入患者:1个撤回知情同意,1个退出)。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 干预为多维度远程医疗项目:每日远程医疗查房,以8项德国急性ICU质量指标为指导,并进行专家会诊。
- 对照条件为标准治疗。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:研究者发起的、大规模、开放标签、阶梯楔形整群随机对照试验;2018年9月4日至2020年3月31日纳入1463例患者(对照414例,干预1049例),来自10个整群,共评估14783个患者日;主要终点为患者每日对质量指标的依从性(是/否),由中央终点裁定委员会评估,采用校正时间的混合效应逻辑回归模型分析。
- 干预显著提高「镇静、镇痛和谵妄」指标依从性(校正OR 5.328,99.375%CI 3.395-8.358)。
- 干预显著提高「通气」指标依从性(OR 2.248,99.375%CI 1.198-4.217)。
- 干预显著提高「脱机」指标依从性(OR 9.049,99.375%CI 2.707-30.247)。
- 干预显著提高「感染管理」指标依从性(OR 4.397,99.375%CI 1.482-13.037)。
- 干预显著提高「肠内营养」指标依从性(OR 1.579,99.375%CI 1.032-2.416)。
- 干预显著提高「患者与家属沟通」指标依从性(OR 6.787,99.375%CI 3.976-11.589)。
- 干预显著提高「早期活动」指标依从性(OR 3.161,99.375%CI 2.160-4.624);「每日多专业跨学科临床查房」依从性两组间无显著差异(OR 1.606,99.375%CI 0.780-3.309);检测到与干预相关及无关的时间趋势;149例患者在指数ICU住院期间死亡(对照45例,干预104例)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:多中心阶梯楔形整群随机对照试验(ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03671447),开放标签。
- 局限:作者指出结果需在更广泛的区域非学术社区医院及其他医疗体系中进一步确认。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,远程医疗质量改进项目提高了急性ICU治疗中7项循证德国绩效指标的依从性,但结果需在更广泛的区域非学术社区医院及其他医疗体系中进一步确认。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Supporting the provision of intensive care medicine through telehealth potentially improves process quality. This may improve patient recovery and long-term outcomes. We investigated the effectiveness of a multifaceted telemedical programme on the adherence to German quality indicators (QIs) in a regional network of intensive care units (ICUs) in Germany.
METHODS: We conducted an investigator-initiated, large-scale, open-label, stepped-wedge cluster randomised controlled trial enrolling adult ICU patients with an expected ICU stay of ≥ 24 h. Twelve ICU clusters in Berlin and Brandenburg were randomly assigned to three sequence groups to transition from control (standard care) to the intervention condition (telemedicine). The quality improvement intervention consisted of daily telemedical rounds guided by eight German acute ICU care QIs and expert consultations. Co-primary effectiveness outcomes were patient-specific daily adherence (fulfilled yes/no) to QIs, assessed by a central end point adjudication committee. Analyses used mixed-effects logistic modelling adjusted for time. This study is completed and registered with ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT03671447).
RESULTS: Between September 4, 2018, and March 31, 2020, 1463 patients (414 treated on control, 1049 on intervention condition) were enrolled at ten clusters, resulting in 14,783 evaluated days. Two randomised clusters recruited no patients (one withdrew informed consent; one dropped out). The intervention, as implemented, significantly increased QI performance for "sedation, analgesia and delirium" (adjusted odds ratio (99.375% confidence interval [CI]) 5.328, 3.395-8.358), "ventilation" (OR 2.248, 1.198-4.217), "weaning from ventilation" (OR 9.049, 2.707-30.247), "infection management" (OR 4.397, 1.482-13.037), "enteral nutrition" (OR 1.579, 1.032-2.416), "patient and family communication" (OR 6.787, 3.976-11.589), and "early mobilisation" (OR 3.161, 2.160-4.624). No evidence for a difference in adherence to "daily multi-professional and interdisciplinary clinical visits" between both conditions was found (OR 1.606, 0.780-3.309). Temporal trends related and unrelated to the intervention were detected. 149 patients died during their index ICU stay (45 treated on control, 104 on intervention condition).
CONCLUSION: A telemedical quality improvement program increased adherence to seven evidence-based German performance indicators in acute ICU care. These results need further confirmation in a broader setting of regional, non-academic community hospitals and other healthcare systems.
参考来源
- Spies CD, Paul N, Adrion C, et al. Effectiveness of an intensive care telehealth programme to improve process quality (ERIC): a multicentre stepped wedge cluster randomised controlled trial. Intensive Care Med. 2023. PMID: 36645446. doi:10.1007/s00134-022-06949-x
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。