成人肾创伤管理:东部创伤外科协会实践管理指南
东部创伤外科协会(EAST)针对成人钝性与穿透性肾创伤制定实践管理指南,围绕四个PICO问题(血流动力学稳定且持续出血者血管栓塞的作用、不稳定患者稳定型II区血肿是否探查、不稳定患者扩大型II区血肿肾切除与保肾技术、高级别肾损伤重复影像频率)进行系统综述与Meta分析,共纳入20篇文章,其中仅2项前瞻性研究,多数为回顾性单机构研究。PICO 1和PICO 4因研究设计差异未能得出关键结局;PICO 2和PICO 3的分析支持非侵入或微创方法,与当前国际实践趋势一致。最终指南对稳定患者血管栓塞与观察无法给出推荐,对不稳定患者稳定型II区血肿条件性推荐不探查、扩大型II区血肿条件性推荐保肾技术,对高级别肾损伤重复影像时机无法给出推荐。
要点
- 血流动力学稳定的成人肾创伤伴临床或影像学持续出血证据:血管栓塞与观察之间无法给出推荐(EAST指南)。
- 血流动力学不稳定的成人肾创伤、稳定型II区血肿:条件性推荐不探查优于肾探查(EAST指南)。
- 血流动力学不稳定的成人肾创伤、扩大型II区血肿:条件性推荐保肾技术优于肾切除(EAST指南)。
- 高级别肾创伤重复影像的最佳时机(常规或按症状):无法给出推荐(EAST指南)。
- 证据基础以回顾性单机构研究为主(20篇中仅2项前瞻性),PICO 1和PICO 4因研究设计差异未得出关键结局。
适用人群与场景
- 成人肾创伤患者,涵盖钝性与穿透性损伤。
- PICO 1:血流动力学稳定且有持续出血临床或影像学证据的成人患者。
- PICO 2和PICO 3:血流动力学不稳定的成人患者,分别针对稳定型II区血肿和扩大型II区血肿。
- PICO 4:高级别创伤性肾损伤患者,评估重复影像频率(常规或按症状)。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 血流动力学稳定的成人肾创伤伴持续出血证据:血管栓塞与观察之间的作用无法给出推荐。
- 血流动力学不稳定的成人肾创伤、稳定型II区血肿:条件性推荐不探查,而非肾探查。
- 血流动力学不稳定的成人肾创伤、扩大型II区血肿:条件性推荐保肾技术,而非肾切除。
- 高级别肾损伤重复影像的最佳时机:无法给出推荐。
研究设计与关键结果
- 制定机构:东部创伤外科协会(EAST);方法:系统综述与Meta分析,使用RevMan 5和GRADEpro软件,由工作组投票形成推荐并达成一致。
- 共纳入20篇文章进行分析,其中2项为前瞻性研究,多数为回顾性单机构研究;并非所有研究均报告PICO问题预设的所有结局。
- 除PICO 3因纳入患者人群差异未行Meta分析外,其余PICO问题均行Meta分析;PICO 1纳入Meta分析的研究最多(9项),但因研究设计差异未得出关键结局;PICO 4因较小样本研究间的类似差异也未观察到关键结局。
- PICO 2和PICO 3的分析支持非侵入或微创方法,与当前国际实践趋势一致。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:指南;系统综述,证据水平III。
- 局限:仅2项前瞻性研究,多数为回顾性单机构研究;并非所有研究均报告PICO预设的所有结局;PICO 1和PICO 4因研究设计差异未得出关键结局;PICO 3因纳入患者人群差异未行Meta分析。
对床旁实践的改变
- 对血流动力学不稳定的成人肾创伤合并稳定型II区血肿,条件性推荐不探查(EAST指南)。
- 对血流动力学不稳定的成人肾创伤合并扩大型II区血肿,条件性推荐保肾技术而非肾切除(EAST指南)。
- 对血流动力学稳定的成人肾创伤伴持续出血证据,血管栓塞与观察之间的选择无法给出推荐(EAST指南)。
- 对高级别肾损伤重复影像的最佳时机无法给出推荐(EAST指南)。
指南或共识出处
- Management of adult renal trauma: a practice management guideline from the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma(东部创伤外科协会成人肾创伤实践管理指南),BMC Surg。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: The kidney is the most frequently injured component of the genitourinary system, accounting for 5% of all trauma cases. Several guidelines by different societies address the management of urological trauma. However, unanswered questions remain regarding optimal use of angioembolization in hemodynamically stable patients, indications for operative exploration of stable retroperitoneal hematomas and renal salvage techniques in the setting of hemodynamic instability, and imaging practices for patients undergoing non-operative management. We performed a systematic review, meta-analysis, and developed evidence-based recommendations to answer these questions in both blunt and penetrating renal trauma.
METHODS: The working group formulated four population, intervention, comparator, outcome (PICO) questions regarding the following topics: (1) angioembolization (AE) usage in hemodynamically stable patients with evidence of ongoing bleeding; (2) surgical approach to stable zone II hematomas (exploration vs. no exploration) in hemodynamically unstable patients and (3) surgical technique (nephrectomy vs. kidney preservation) for expanding zone II hematomas in hemodynamically unstable patients; (4) frequency of repeat imaging (routine or symptom based) in high-grade traumatic renal injuries. A systematic review and meta-analysis of currently available evidence was performed. RevMan 5 (Cochran Collaboration) and GRADEpro (Grade Working Group) software were used. Recommendations were voted on by working group members and concurrence was obtained for each final recommendation.
RESULTS: A total of 20 articles were identified and analyzed. Two prospective studies were encountered; the majority were retrospective, single-institution studies. Not all outcomes projected by PICO questions were reported in all studies. Meta-analysis was performed for all PICO questions except PICO 3 secondary to the discrepant patient populations included in those studies. PICO 1 had the greatest number of articles included in the meta-analysis with nine studies; yet, due to differences in study design, no critical outcomes emerged; similar differences among a smaller set of articles prevented observation of critical outcomes for PICO 4. Analyses of PICOs 2 and 3 favored a non-invasive or minimally invasive approach in-line with current international practice trends.
CONCLUSION: In hemodynamically stable adult patients with clinical or radiographic evidence of ongoing bleeding, no recommendation could be made regarding the role of AE vs. observation. In hemodynamically unstable adult patients, we conditionally recommend no renal exploration vs. renal exploration in stable zone II hematomas. In hemodynamically unstable adult patients, we conditionally recommend kidney preserving techniques vs. nephrectomy in expanding zone II hematomas. No recommendation could be made for the optimal timing of repeat imaging in high grade renal injury.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Guideline; systematic review, level III.
参考来源
- Aziz HA, Bugaev N, Baltazar G, et al. Management of adult renal trauma: a practice management guideline from the eastern association for the surgery of trauma. BMC Surg. 2023. PMID: 36707832. doi:10.1186/s12893-023-01914-x
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。