体外冲击波治疗对膝骨关节炎患者疼痛和功能的影响:系统评价与Meta分析及GRADE推荐
该系统评价与Meta分析纳入12项随机临床试验,共403例干预组和331例对照组膝骨关节炎患者,比较体外冲击波与假冲击波或运动疗法的效果。与假冲击波相比,冲击波在短期功能(SMD=-1.93,95%CI:[-2.77;-1.09];I²=83%;P<0.01)以及短期(MD=-2.05,95%CI:[-2.59;-1.51];I²=84%;P<0.01)、中期(MD=-3.46,95%CI:[-4.03;-2.89];I²=0%;P<0.01)和长期(MD=-2.01,95%CI:[-3.36;-0.65];I²=98%;P<0.01)疼痛方面均更优。与运动疗法联用时,短期功能更优(SMD=-1.88,95%CI:[-2.98;-0.78];I²=94%;P<0.01),短期(MD=-1.44,95%CI:[-1.81;-1.07];I²=37%;P=0.14)、中期(MD=-1.31,95%CI:[-1.76;-0.85];I²=0%;P=0.41)和长期(MD=-1.63,95%CI:[-1.73;-1.52];I²=0%;P=0.43)疼痛也均更优。作者认为冲击波可能改善短期功能及各期疼痛,但联用运动疗法时疼痛改善可能无临床意义。
要点
- 与假冲击波相比,冲击波改善短期功能(SMD=-1.93,95%CI:[-2.77;-1.09];I²=83%;P<0.01)。
- 与假冲击波相比,冲击波改善短期疼痛(MD=-2.05,95%CI:[-2.59;-1.51];I²=84%;P<0.01)、中期疼痛(MD=-3.46,95%CI:[-4.03;-2.89];I²=0%;P<0.01)和长期疼痛(MD=-2.01,95%CI:[-3.36;-0.65];I²=98%;P<0.01)。
- 与运动疗法联用时,冲击波改善短期功能(SMD=-1.88,95%CI:[-2.98;-0.78];I²=94%;P<0.01)。
- 与运动疗法联用时,冲击波改善短期疼痛(MD=-1.44,95%CI:[-1.81;-1.07];I²=37%;P=0.14)、中期疼痛(MD=-1.31,95%CI:[-1.76;-0.85];I²=0%;P=0.41)和长期疼痛(MD=-1.63,95%CI:[-1.73;-1.52];I²=0%;P=0.43)。
- 作者认为,与假冲击波相比,冲击波可能改善膝骨关节炎患者的短期功能及各期疼痛;与运动疗法联用时疼痛改善可能无临床意义。
适用人群与场景
- 膝骨关节炎患者,纳入随机临床试验,比较冲击波与假冲击波或运动疗法的效果,以疼痛和身体功能为结局变量。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 纳入标准:(1)随机临床试验;(2)比较冲击波与假冲击波或运动疗法对膝骨关节炎个体的效果;(3)以疼痛和身体功能为结局变量。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:系统评价与Meta分析,检索Cochrane Library、PubMed、PEDro、Web of Science、EMBASE、Scopus、LILACS和Scielo,在线检索截至2022年10月,PROSPERO注册号CRD42021235597;共鉴定4217项研究,纳入12项随机临床试验进行定性合成和Meta分析,共403例接受干预的个体和331例对照个体。
- 与假冲击波相比,冲击波在短期功能结局上更优(SMD=-1.93;95%CI:[-2.77;-1.09];I²=83%;P<0.01)。
- 与假冲击波相比,冲击波在疼痛结局上短期(MD=-2.05;95%CI:[-2.59;-1.51];I²=84%;P<0.01)、中期(MD=-3.46;95%CI:[-4.03;-2.89];I²=0%;P<0.01)和长期(MD=-2.01;95%CI:[-3.36;-0.65];I²=98%;P<0.01)均更优。
- 与运动疗法联用时,冲击波在短期功能结局上更优(SMD=-1.88;95%CI:[-2.98;-0.78];I²=94%;P<0.01)。
- 与运动疗法联用时,冲击波在疼痛结局上短期(MD=-1.44;95%CI:[-1.81;-1.07];I²=37%;P=0.14)、中期(MD=-1.31;95%CI:[-1.76;-0.85];I²=0%;P=0.41)和长期(MD=-1.63;95%CI:[-1.73;-1.52];I²=0%;P=0.43)均更优。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:系统评价与Meta分析,纳入12项随机临床试验,使用PEDro量表评估偏倚风险;作者认为与假冲击波相比,冲击波可能改善短期功能及各期疼痛,与运动疗法联用时可能改善短期功能及各期疼痛,但疼痛改善可能无临床意义。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,与假冲击波相比,体外冲击波可能改善膝骨关节炎患者的短期功能以及短期、中期和长期疼痛。
- 作者认为,体外冲击波与运动疗法联用时可能改善短期功能以及短期、中期和长期疼痛,尽管疼痛改善可能无临床意义。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To investigate extracorporeal shock wave therapy effect on knee osteoarthritis compared to a sham or kinesiotherapy by a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials.
DATA SOURCES: The search was performed in: Cochrane Library, PubMed, PEDro, Web of Science, EMBASE, Scopus, LILACS, and Scielo.
REVIEW METHODS: We performed the online search until October, 2022. The following terms were used (Osteoarthritis) AND ("knee joint") AND ("Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy"). Eligibility criteria: (1) randomized clinical trials; (2) effects comparison of shockwave therapy to a sham or kinesiotherapy in individuals with knee osteoarthritis; (3) pain and physical function as outcome variables. Risk of bias assessed using the PEDro scale. PROSPERO registration (CRD42021235597).
RESULTS: We identified 4217 studies, and 12 were included in the qualitative synthesis and the meta-analysis, totaling 403 individuals submitted to the intervention and 331 control individuals. Compared to sham, shockwave was favored in short-term for the function outcome (SMD = -1.93; 95%CI: [-2.77; -1.09]; I² = 83%; P < 0.01). For the pain outcome, the shockwave was favored in the short (MD = -2.05; 95%CI: [-2.59; -1.51]; I² = 84%; P < 0.01), medium (MD = -3.46; 95%CI: [-4.03; -2.89]; I² = 0%; P < 0.01) and long-term (MD = -2.01; 95%CI: [-3.36; -0.65]; I² = 98%; P < 0.01). The association with kinesiotherapy was favored in the short term for the function outcome (SMD = -1.88; 95%CI: [-2.98; -0.78]; I² = 94%; P < 0.01) and favored for the pain outcome in the short (MD = -1.44; 95%CI: [-1.81; -1.07]; I² = 37%; P = 0.14), medium (MD = -1,31; 95%CI: [-1.76; -0,85]; I² = 0%; P = 0.41), and long terms (MD = -1.63; 95%CI: [-1.73; -1.52]; I² = 0%; P = 0.43).
CONCLUSION: Shockwave therapy may improve functionality in patients with knee osteoarthritis in the short term and pain in all follow-up moments, compared with sham. When associated to kinesiotherapy, it may improve function in the short term and pain in all follow-up time points, although improvement in pain may not be clinically significant.
参考来源
- Silva AC, Almeida VS, Veras PM, et al. Effect of extracorporeal shock wave therapy on pain and function in patients with knee osteoarthritis: a systematic review with meta-analysis and grade recommendations. Clin Rehabil. 2022. PMID: 36524275. doi:10.1177/02692155221146086
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。