中国产科医生对极早产儿治疗的态度
该横断面在线问卷调查研究于2021年6月至7月通过问卷星平台在中国各省市产科医生中开展,共回收2817份有效问卷(平均年龄41.76岁,标准差8.50;男性156人占5.5%,女性2661人占94.5%;副主任或主任医师1339人占47.5%;三级医院1662人占59.0%;有极早产儿接生经验2048人占72.7%)。结果显示,支持对早产儿复苏的比例在胎龄24周为19.1%(539人)、25周为24.1%(679人)、26周为54.8%(1543人)、27周为100.0%(2817人);1326名产科医生(47.1%)报告极早产儿被放弃复苏、未收入NICU治疗的情况常见或非常常见。对于存活可能性较高的极早产儿,1621名(57.5%)主张应告知适当信息但尊重父母意愿;2051名(72.8%)认为中国提供全力救治的界限为28周,766名(27.2%)认为该界限不合适、应小于28周。作者结论认为中国产科医生对极早产儿治疗多持保守态度,生后未入NICU即放弃治疗非常常见,多数支持28周为全力救治界限。
要点
- 支持复苏的比例随胎龄升高:24周19.1%(539人)、25周24.1%(679人)、26周54.8%(1543人)、27周100.0%(2817人)。
- 1326名产科医生(47.1%)报告极早产儿被放弃复苏、未收入NICU治疗的情况常见或非常常见。
- 对存活可能性较高的极早产儿,1621名(57.5%)主张告知适当信息但尊重父母意愿。
- 2051名(72.8%)认为中国提供全力救治的界限为28周,766名(27.2%)认为应小于28周。
- 上述态度差异与产科医生职称、地理区域、医院级别和类型、是否有极早产儿接生经验及单位年出生极早产儿总数显著相关。
适用人群与场景
- 中国30个省市的产科医生,共2817名有效问卷受访者(平均年龄41.76岁,标准差8.50;男性156人占5.5%,女性2661人占94.5%;副主任或主任医师1339人占47.5%;三级医院1662人占59.0%;有极早产儿接生经验2048人占72.7%)。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:横断面在线问卷调查;调查时间2021年6月至7月,通过问卷星平台进行;数据分析时间2021年8月至2022年1月;回收有效问卷2817份,来自中国大陆30个省市。
- 支持复苏早产儿的比例:胎龄24周19.1%(539人)、25周24.1%(679人)、26周54.8%(1543人)、27周100.0%(2817人)。
- 1326名产科医生(47.1%)报告极早产儿被放弃复苏、未收入NICU治疗的情况常见或非常常见。
- 对存活可能性较高的极早产儿,1621名(57.5%)主张告知适当信息但尊重父母意愿。
- 2051名(72.8%)认为中国提供全力救治的界限为28周;766名(27.2%)认为该界限不合适、应小于28周。
- 逻辑回归分析显示,上述差异与产科医生职称、地理区域、医院级别和类型、是否有极早产儿接生经验及单位年出生极早产儿总数显著相关。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:横断面在线问卷调查研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
IMPORTANCE: Extremely preterm infants (EPIs) are at high risk of mortality and disability, and whether obstetricians are active in treating EPIs is directly related to whether EPIs can get an opportunity to enter the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) for treatment. A greater understanding of the attitudes of obstetricians toward the treatment of EPIs is needed to improve treatment of this population and optimize pediatric health policies and services.
OBJECTIVE: To clarify the attitudes of obstetricians toward the treatment of EPIs in China.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: A cross-sectional, online, questionnaire-based survey was conducted among obstetricians from various provinces and cities in China through the wenjuanxing application (a survey platform) between June and July 2021. The questionnaire included characteristics of the participants, their experiences in delivering EPIs, their attitudes toward EPI resuscitation, and their opinions about the cutoff for providing full care to preterm infants in China. Possible factors associated with their attitudes toward the cutoff for providing full care to preterm infants were analyzed by logistic regression. Data analysis was performed from August 2021 to January 2022.
MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The attitudes of obstetricians toward the resuscitation and treatment of EPIs, and the current cutoff for providing full care to premature infants.
RESULTS: A total of 2817 valid questionnaires were recovered from 30 provinces and cities in mainland China. Of the 2817 obstetricians (mean [SD] age, 41.76 [8.50] years) investigated, 156 (5.5%) were male, 2661 (94.5%) were female, 1339 (47.5%) were deputy chief physicians or chief physicians, 1662 (59.0%) were from tertiary hospitals, and 2048 (72.7%) had experience in delivering EPIs. The proportion of obstetricians who supported resuscitation of preterm infants was 19.1% (539 respondents) at a gestational age 24 weeks, 24.1% (679 respondents) at 25 weeks, 54.8% (1543 respondents) at 26 weeks, and 100.0% (2817 respondents) at 27 weeks. A total of 1326 obstetricians (47.1%) reported that it was common or very common for EPIs to be withdrawn from resuscitation and not to be admitted to the NICU for treatment. Regarding the treatment of EPIs with higher possibility of survival, 1621 obstetricians (57.5%) maintained that appropriate information should be communicated but their parents' wishes should be respected. Most obstetricians (2051 respondents [72.8%]) maintained that 28 weeks was the cutoff for providing full care to preterm infants in China; 766 respondents (27.2%) thought of it as inappropriate, suggesting the cutoff should be less than 28 weeks. Logistic regression analysis showed that these differences were significantly associated with the professional titles of the obstetricians, geographical regions, hospital levels and types, whether they had any experience in delivering EPIs, and the total number of EPIs born yearly in their units.
CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: In this cross-sectional study, most Chinese obstetricians maintained a conservative attitude toward the treatment of EPIs. It was very common for EPIs to be withdrawn from treatment without entering the NICU directly after birth. Most obstetricians maintained that 28 weeks' gestational age should be the cutoff for providing full care to premature infants.
参考来源
- Han T, Wang D, Xie W, et al. Obstetricians' Attitudes Toward the Treatment of Extremely Preterm Infants in China. JAMA Netw Open. 2022. PMID: 36166226. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2022.33511
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。