医生职业倦怠与职业投入及患者照护质量的关联:系统评价与荟萃分析
该系统评价与荟萃分析检索Medline、PsycINFO、Embase和CINAHL至2021年5月,纳入170项观察性研究、239 246名医生。整体倦怠与工作满意度下降近四倍、职业选择后悔增加三倍以上、离职意向增加三倍以上相关,并使患者安全事件翻倍、低职业素养和患者不满意风险约翻倍。作者认为医疗机构应投入更多时间实施循证策略减轻医生倦怠,尤其急诊医学和培训/住院医师阶段。
要点
- 整体倦怠与工作满意度下降相关(OR 3.79,95%CI 3.24-4.43,I²=97%,k=73,n=146 980)。
- 整体倦怠与患者安全事件翻倍相关(OR 2.04,95%CI 1.69-2.45,I²=87%,k=35,n=41 059)。
- 倦怠与低职业素养风险增加相关(OR 2.33,95%CI 1.96-2.70,I²=96%,k=40,n=32 321)。
- 倦怠与患者不满意风险增加相关(OR 2.22,95%CI 1.38-3.57,I²=75%,k=8,n=1002)。
- 倦怠与离职意向增加三倍以上相关(OR 3.10,95%CI 2.30-4.17,I²=97%,k=25,n=32 271)。
适用人群与场景
- 纳入170项观察性研究、239 246名医生,评估职业倦怠与职业投入及患者照护质量的关联。
- 亚组分析涉及医院场景、31-50岁医生、急诊医学与重症医学、全科医生、20-30岁医生、50岁以上医生、培训或住院医师阶段、中低收入国家。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 职业倦怠定义包括情感耗竭、去人格化(对工作的讥讽和疏离感)以及无效能感和个人成就感低。
研究设计与关键结果
- 系统评价与荟萃分析,纳入170项观察性研究、239 246名医生;检索Medline、PsycINFO、Embase和CINAHL自建库至2021年5月。
- 整体倦怠与工作满意度下降近四倍相关(OR 3.79,95%CI 3.24-4.43,I²=97%,k=73,n=146 980)。
- 倦怠与职业选择后悔增加三倍以上相关(OR 3.49,95%CI 2.43-5.00,I²=97%,k=16,n=33 871),与离职意向增加三倍以上相关(OR 3.10,95%CI 2.30-4.17,I²=97%,k=25,n=32 271)。
- 倦怠与生产力小但显著的影响相关(OR 1.82,95%CI 1.08-3.07,I²=83%,k=7,n=9581),与职业发展相关(两项研究合并OR 3.77,95%CI 2.77-5.14,I²=0%,n=3411)。
- 倦怠使患者安全事件翻倍(OR 2.04,95%CI 1.69-2.45,I²=87%,k=35,n=41 059),低职业素养风险增加(OR 2.33,95%CI 1.96-2.70,I²=96%,k=40,n=32 321),患者不满意风险增加(OR 2.22,95%CI 1.38-3.57,I²=75%,k=8,n=1002)。
- 倦怠与较差工作满意度的关联在医院场景最大(OR 1.88,95%CI 0.91-3.86,P=0.09)、31-50岁医生(OR 2.41,95%CI 1.02-5.64,P=0.04)、急诊医学与重症医学(OR 2.16,95%CI 0.98-4.76,P=0.06);全科医生最低(OR 0.16,95%CI 0.03-0.88,P=0.04);这些关联在多变量回归中未保持显著。
- 倦怠与患者安全事件的关联在20-30岁医生(OR 1.88,95%CI 1.07-3.29,P=0.03)和急诊医学工作者(OR 2.10,95%CI 1.09-3.56,P=0.02)最大。
- 倦怠与低职业素养的关联在50岁以上医生最小(OR 0.36,95%CI 0.19-0.69,P=0.003),在培训或住院医师阶段最大(OR 2.27,95%CI 1.45-3.60,P=0.001),在医院工作者(OR 2.16,95%CI 1.46-3.19,P<0.001)、急诊医学专业(OR 1.48,95%CI 1.01-2.34,P=0.042)及中低收入国家(OR 1.68,95%CI 0.94-2.97,P=0.08)也较大。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 系统评价与荟萃分析,纳入170项观察性研究。
- 采用随机效应模型计算合并OR,预测区间表达异质性,荟萃回归评估潜在调节因素,显著性设定保守水平P<0.10。
- 数据由独立评审者双重提取,并通过联系所有作者核对,170名作者中84名(49%)确认了数据。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,医疗机构应投入更多时间和精力实施循证策略以减轻医生倦怠,尤其急诊医学及培训或住院医师阶段。
- 作者认为,医生倦怠主要与职业投入下降和离职相关,其次与患者照护质量降低相关,影响医疗组织的功能和可持续性。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To examine the association of physician burnout with the career engagement and the quality of patient care globally.
DESIGN: Systematic review and meta-analysis.
DATA SOURCES: Medline, PsycINFO, Embase, and CINAHL were searched from database inception until May 2021.
ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR SELECTING STUDIES: Observational studies assessing the association of physician burnout (including a feeling of overwhelming emotional exhaustion, feelings of cynicism and detachment from job defined as depersonalisation, and a sense of ineffectiveness and little personal accomplishment) with career engagement (job satisfaction, career choice regret, turnover intention, career development, and productivity loss) and the quality of patient care (patient safety incidents, low professionalism, and patient satisfaction). Data were double extracted by independent reviewers and checked through contacting all authors, 84 (49%) of 170 of whom confirmed their data. Random-effect models were used to calculate the pooled odds ratio, prediction intervals expressed the amount of heterogeneity, and meta-regressions assessed for potential moderators with significance set using a conservative level of P<0.10.
RESULTS: 4732 articles were identified, of which 170 observational studies of 239 246 physicians were included in the meta-analysis. Overall burnout in physicians was associated with an almost four times decrease in job satisfaction compared with increased job satisfaction (odds ratio 3.79, 95% confidence interval 3.24 to 4.43, I2=97%, k=73 studies, n=146 980 physicians). Career choice regret increased by more than threefold compared with being satisfied with their career choice (3.49, 2.43 to 5.00, I2=97%, k=16, n=33 871). Turnover intention also increased by more than threefold compared with retention (3.10, 2.30 to 4.17, I2=97%, k=25, n=32 271). Productivity had a small but significant effect (1.82, 1.08 to 3.07, I2=83%, k=7, n=9581) and burnout also affected career development from a pooled association of two studies (3.77, 2.77 to 5.14, I2=0%, n=3411). Overall physician burnout doubled patient safety incidents compared with no patient safety incidents (2.04, 1.69 to 2.45, I2=87%, k=35, n=41 059). Low professionalism was twice as likely compared with maintained professionalism (2.33, 1.96 to 2.70, I2=96%, k=40, n=32 321), as was patient dissatisfaction compared with patient satisfaction (2.22, 1.38 to 3.57, I2=75%, k=8, n=1002). Burnout and poorer job satisfaction was greatest in hospital settings (1.88, 0.91 to 3.86, P=0.09), physicians aged 31-50 years (2.41, 1.02 to 5.64, P=0.04), and working in emergency medicine and intensive care (2.16, 0.98 to 4.76, P=0.06); burnout was lowest in general practitioners (0.16, 0.03 to 0.88, P=0.04). However, these associations did not remain significant in the multivariable regressions. Burnout and patient safety incidents were greatest in physicians aged 20-30 years (1.88, 1.07 to 3.29, P=0.03), and people working in emergency medicine (2.10, 1.09 to 3.56, P=0.02). The association of burnout with low professionalism was smallest in physicians older than 50 years (0.36, 0.19 to 0.69, P=0.003) and greatest in physicians still in training or residency (2.27, 1.45 to 3.60, P=0.001), in those who worked in a hospital (2.16, 1.46 to 3.19, P<0.001), specifically in emergency medicine specialty (1.48, 1.01 to 2.34, P=0.042), or situated in a low to middle income country (1.68, 0.94 to 2.97, P=0.08).
CONCLUSIONS: This meta-analysis provides compelling evidence that physician burnout is associated with poor function and sustainability of healthcare organisations primarily by contributing to the career disengagement and turnover of physicians and secondarily by reducing the quality of patient care. Healthcare organisations should invest more time and effort in implementing evidence-based strategies to mitigate physician burnout across specialties, and particularly in emergency medicine and for physicians in training or residency.
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION: PROSPERO number CRD42021249492.
参考来源
- Hodkinson A, Zhou A, Johnson J, et al. Associations of physician burnout with career engagement and quality of patient care: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ. 2022. PMID: 36104064. doi:10.1136/bmj-2022-070442
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。