文献速递呼吸衰竭与机械通气心脑血管急症

YEARS、PEGeD、4PEPS 或单项「PE 是最可能诊断」策略在急诊肺栓塞诊断中的安全性与有效性比较:两项欧洲队列研究的事后分析

Comparison of the safety and efficacy of YEARS, PEGeD, 4PEPS or the sole item "PE is the most likely diagnosis" strategies for the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism in the emergency department: post-hoc analysis of two European cohort studies.
PubMed 文献 · Eur J Emerg Med · 2022-08-04
一句话结论在临床概率非高的急诊肺栓塞疑似患者中,PERC+YEARS、PERC+PEGeD、4PEPS 与 MODS 四种策略排除 PE 的失败率均低于 1.85%,均安全,失败率无显著差异。

该研究为两项欧洲队列(法国 PROPER 队列 1916 例、西班牙 MODIGLIANI 队列 1414 例)个体数据的事后分析,纳入 3330 例急诊临床概率非高的成人 PE 疑似患者,随访 3 个月。评估 PERC+YEARS、PERC+PEGeD、4PEPS 及 MODS(简化 YEARS 仅保留「PE 是最可能诊断」单项联合 PERC)四种高 D-二聚体阈值策略。3330 例中 150 例(4.5%)确诊 PE;四种策略漏诊 PE 分别为 25、29、30、26 例,失败率分别为 0.75%(95%CI 0.51%–1.10%)、0.87%(0.61%–1.25%)、0.90%(0.63%–1.28%)、0.78%(0.53%–1.14%),均低于预设 1.85% 安全界值,策略间失败率无显著差异。影像学使用率除 4PEPS 较 YEARS 显著降低(14.9% vs 16.3%,差值 -1.4%[95%CI -2.1% 至 -0.8%])外,其余策略间无差异。

要点

  • 3330 例急诊临床概率非高 PE 疑似患者中,PERC+YEARS 漏诊 25 例、失败率 0.75%(95%CI 0.51%–1.10%),低于 1.85% 安全界值。
  • PERC+PEGeD 漏诊 29 例、失败率 0.87%(0.61%–1.25%);4PEPS 漏诊 30 例、失败率 0.90%(0.63%–1.28%);MODS 漏诊 26 例、失败率 0.78%(0.53%–1.14%),均低于 1.85%。
  • 四种策略间失败率无显著差异;仅 4PEPS 的胸部影像使用率显著低于 YEARS(14.9% vs 16.3%,差值 -1.4%[95%CI -2.1% 至 -0.8%])。
  • MODS 策略(简化 YEARS 仅保留「PE 是最可能诊断」单项联合 PERC)的安全性亦得到确认,失败率 0.78%。

适用人群与场景

  • 法国与西班牙急诊科临床概率非高的成人 PE 疑似患者,共 3330 例(PROPER 队列 1916 例,MODIGLIANI 队列 1414 例),随访 3 个月。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 策略安全性的判定标准为失败率(3 个月内漏诊 PE 或深静脉血栓的比例)低于 1.85%。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型:两项欧洲队列研究(PROPER 与 MODIGLIANI)个体数据的事后分析,共 3330 例,来自法国和西班牙。
  • 人群中 150 例(4.5%)确诊 PE。
  • PERC+YEARS 策略漏诊 PE 25 例,失败率 0.75%(95%CI 0.51%–1.10%)。
  • PERC+PEGeD 策略漏诊 PE 29 例,失败率 0.87%(95%CI 0.61%–1.25%)。
  • 4PEPS 策略漏诊 PE 30 例,失败率 0.90%(95%CI 0.63%–1.28%)。
  • MODS 策略漏诊 PE 26 例,失败率 0.78%(95%CI 0.53%–1.14%)。
  • 各策略间失败率无显著差异。
  • 4PEPS 的胸部影像使用率显著低于 YEARS(14.9% vs 16.3%,差值 -1.4%[95%CI -2.1% 至 -0.8%]);其余策略间影像使用比例无差异。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:两项队列研究的事后分析;原文未报告证据等级。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 在急诊临床概率非高的 PE 疑似患者中,PERC+YEARS、PERC+PEGeD、4PEPS 及 MODS 策略排除 PE 均安全(失败率均低于 1.85%),策略间失败率无显著差异;4PEPS 较 YEARS 减少胸部影像使用(14.9% vs 16.3%)。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: The optimal strategy for the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism (PE) in the emergency department (ED) remains debated. To reduce the need of imaging testing, several rules have been recently validated using an elevated D-dimer threshold.

OBJECTIVE: To validate the safety of different diagnostic strategies and compare the efficacy in terms of chest imaging testing.

DESIGN AND PATIENTS: Post-hoc analysis of individual data of 3330 adult patients without a high clinical probability of PE in the ED followed-up at 3 months in France and Spain (1916 from the PROPER cohort, 1414 from the MODIGLIANI cohort).

EXPOSURE: Four diagnostic strategies with an elevated D-dimer threshold if PE is unlikely. The YEARS combined with Pulmonary Embolism Rule-out Criteria (PERC) the pulmonary embolism graduated D-dimer (PEGeD) combined with PERC and the 4-level pulmonary embolism probability score (4PEPS) rules were assessed. A modified simplified (MODS) rule with a simplified YEARS reduced to the sole item of "Is PE the most likely diagnosis" combined with PERC was also tested.

OUTCOME MEASURE AND ANALYSIS: The primary outcome was the proportion of diagnosed PE or deep venous thrombosis at 3 months in patients in whom PE could have been excluded without chest imaging according to the tested strategy. The safety of a strategy was confirmed if the failure rate was less than 1.85%. The secondary outcome was the use of imaging testing according to each rule.

RESULTS: Among 3330 analyzed patients, 150 (4.5%) had a PE. The number of missed PEs were 25, 29, 30 and 26 for the PERC+YEARS, PERC+PEGeD, 4PEPS and MODS rules respectively, with a failure rate of 0.75% (95% CI 0.51% to 1.10%), 0.87% (0.61% to 1.25%), 0.90% (0.63% to 1.28%) and 0.78% (0.53% to 1.14%) respectively. There was no significant difference in the failure rate between rules. Except for a significant lower use of chest imaging for 4PEPS compared to YEARS (14.9% vs 16.3%, difference -1.4% [95%CI -2.1% to -0.8%]), there was no difference in the proportion of imaging testing.

CONCLUSION: In this post-hoc analysis of patients with suspicion of PE, YEARS and PEGeD combined with PERC, and 4PEPS were safe to exclude PE. The safety of the modified simplified MODS strategy was also confirmed. There was no significant difference of the failure rate between strategies.

来源:Eur J Emerg Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Roussel M, Gorlicki J, Douillet D, et al. Comparison of the safety and efficacy of YEARS, PEGeD, 4PEPS or the sole item "PE is the most likely diagnosis" strategies for the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism in the emergency department: post-hoc analysis of two European cohort studies. Eur J Emerg Med. 2022. PMID: 36062433. doi:10.1097/MEJ.0000000000000967

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。