急性杀菌剂自服中毒——一项前瞻性病例系列研究
该研究在斯里兰卡9家医院前瞻性纳入2002–2020年杀菌剂自服中毒患者337例,涉及5类28种杀菌剂,酒精为唯一合并摄入物。绝大多数(98.8%)完全康复,仅2.37%需插管通气;4例死亡,病死率1.2%(95%CI 0.0–23.4),死亡与敌瘟磷(n=2)、霜霉威和吡唑醚菌酯相关。作者认为杀菌剂自服中毒危险性低于杀虫剂或除草剂,但敌瘟磷为例外,建议淘汰;霜霉威应以盐酸盐列入WHO危害分类;吡唑醚菌酯急需WHO分类。
要点
- 杀菌剂自服中毒337例中仅4例死亡,病死率1.2%(95%CI 0.0–23.4),死亡涉及敌瘟磷(n=2)、霜霉威和吡唑醚菌酯。
- 入院时格拉斯哥昏迷评分(GCS)中位数15(15–15);仅27例(8.0%)GCS<15,仅2例(0.6%)GCS 3/15。
- 333/337(98.8%)完全康复,其中仅8例(2.37%)需插管通气。
- 摄入至检查中位时间3.1(1.8–5.7)小时;共涉及5类28种不同杀菌剂,酒精为唯一合并摄入物。
- 作者认为敌瘟磷属WHO Ib类高度危险农药,建议全球农业淘汰并替代;霜霉威应以盐酸盐列入WHO危害分类;吡唑醚菌酯亟需WHO分类。
适用人群与场景
- 2002–2020年斯里兰卡9家医院就诊的杀菌剂自服中毒患者,酒精为唯一合并摄入物。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 敌瘟磷(edifenphos)摄入与死亡相关(n=2),属WHO Ib类高度危险农药。
- 霜霉威(propamocarb)摄入与死亡相关,其常见农业制剂为盐酸盐,毒性更高。
- 吡唑醚菌酯(pyraclostrobin)摄入已与一例死亡相关,目前无WHO分类。
研究设计与关键结果
- 前瞻性病例系列:2002–2020年斯里兰卡9家医院纳入337例杀菌剂自服中毒患者(酒精为唯一合并摄入物),涉及5类28种杀菌剂。
- 摄入至检查中位时间3.1(1.8–5.7)小时;入院时GCS中位数15(15–15),27例(8.0%)GCS<15,2例(0.6%)GCS 3/15。
- 333/337(98.8%)完全康复,其中仅8例(2.37%)需插管通气。
- 4例死亡,病死率1.2%(95%CI 0.0–23.4),死亡涉及敌瘟磷(n=2)、霜霉威和吡唑醚菌酯。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:前瞻性病例系列。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为杀菌剂自服中毒似乎比杀虫剂或除草剂自服中毒危险性低,同一队列中病死率大幅更低。
- 作者认为敌瘟磷是「低毒」规则的例外,作为WHO Ib类高度危险农药,建议全球农业淘汰并替代。
- 作者认为霜霉威应以盐酸盐列入WHO危害分类,以反映常见农业制剂更高的毒性。
- 作者认为吡唑醚菌酯目前无WHO分类,其摄入已与一例死亡相关,亟需建立分类。
- 作者认为需要更多前瞻性临床数据来扩展对这些不同化合物作用的认识。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Pesticide self-poisoning is a global clinical and public health problem. While self-poisoning with insecticides and herbicides has been extensively studied, there is minimal literature on acute fungicide self-poisoning. We aimed to study the clinical course and outcome of fungicide self-poisoned patients recruited to a prospective cohort in Sri Lanka.
METHODS: We conducted a prospective study of patients presenting with fungicide self-poisoning to nine hospitals in Sri Lanka between 2002 and 2020. Patients were enrolled by clinical research assistants, with clinical outcomes being recorded at regular review for each patient.
RESULTS: We identified 337 cases of self-poisoning with fungicides (alcohol as only co-ingestant), including 28 different fungicides across 5 different fungicide classes. Median time from ingestion to examination was 3.1 (1.8-5.7) h. Nearly all presented to hospital fully conscious (GCS 15, 15-15)- only 27 patients (8.0%) presented with reduced GCS (<15) and only 2 (0.6%) had GCS 3/15. Most patients (333/337, 98.8%) made a full recovery, of whom only eight (2.37%) required intubation and ventilation. Four patients died (case fatality rate: 1.2%; 95% CI 0.0-23.4) after ingestion of edifenphos (n = 2), propamocarb and pyraclostrobin.
CONCLUSION: Fungicide self-poisoning appears to be less hazardous than insecticide or herbicide self-poisoning, with a substantially lower case fatality in the same cohort. Edifenphos is an exception to this 'less toxic' rule; as a WHO Class Ib highly hazardous pesticide, we recommend its withdrawal from, and replacement in, global agricultural practice. Propamocarb should be listed in the WHO hazard classification as propamocarb hydrochloride to reflect the higher toxicity of the common agricultural formulation. Pyraclostrobin currently has no WHO classification; one is urgently required now that its ingestion has now been linked the death of a patient. Additional prospective clinical data on fungicide self-poisoning is required to expand knowledge on the effects of these diverse compounds.
参考来源
- Nendick E, Mohamed F, Raubenheimer J, et al. Acute fungicide self-poisoning - a prospective case series. Clin Toxicol (Phila). 2022. PMID: 35950874. doi:10.1080/15563650.2022.2105710
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。