指南与共识重症综合管理与镇静镇痛

德尔菲研究:制定成人ICU患者转至普通病房出院准备度评估标准的专家共识——欧洲视角

Delphi study to derive expert consensus on a set of criteria to evaluate discharge readiness for adult ICU patients to be discharged to a general ward-European perspective.
指南 / 共识 · BMC Health Serv Res · 2022-06-13
一句话结论国际专家组通过改良在线德尔菲法达成共识,形成28条成人ICU转出标准,采用二元决策指标并标注必须满足项及例外。

针对ICU转出决策常受床位压力影响且缺乏指南、评估主观的问题,研究采用改良在线德尔菲法,由27名国际重症专家经5轮投票,就28条ICU转出标准达成共识(共识阈值≥90%)。标准覆盖呼吸(7条)、心血管(9条)、中枢神经(1条)、泌尿生殖(2条)、疼痛(1条)、液体丢失与引流(1条)、药物与营养(1条)、患者诊断预后与偏好(2条)及机构特定标准(4条),每条均以「适合转出 vs 需继续重症治疗/监测」二元决策指标表述,并标注必须满足项及适用例外。该共识旨在标准化出院准备度评估,促进及时识别稳定患者并实现安全高效的照护过渡。

要点

  • 27名国际重症专家经5轮改良在线德尔菲法,就28条成人ICU转出标准达成共识,共识阈值≥90%。
  • 标准按器官系统分布:呼吸7条、心血管9条、中枢神经1条、泌尿生殖2条,另含疼痛、液体与引流、药物与营养、诊断预后与偏好及机构特定标准。
  • 每条标准均以二元决策指标表述:适合ICU转出 vs 需继续重症治疗/监测,并附有可适用的数值计算方法。
  • 标准附重要性排序,标注「必须满足」标志及适用的例外情况。
  • 作者认为标准化出院准备度评估应基于患者因素与组织边界条件,并涉及多方利益相关者。

适用人群与场景

  • 成人ICU患者,拟转出至普通病房
  • 欧洲视角的国际专家共识,适用于ICU转出决策场景

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 共识定义为≥90%的专家在Likert量表或多选题调查中对给定选项投票即达成共识。
  • 第1至3轮聚焦标准的纳入与排除,第3轮为重复确认以建立稳定性;第4至5轮聚焦每条标准的精确措辞、数值、决策者和评估时间框架。
  • 28条标准均以二元决策指标表述:适合ICU转出 vs 需继续重症治疗/监测。
  • 标准附有可适用的数值计算方法及重要性排序,标注「必须满足」标志和适用例外。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型:改良在线德尔菲过程;专家组:27名国际重症专家;共5轮投票。
  • 共识结果:就28条成人ICU转出标准达成共识,包括呼吸(7条)、心血管(9条)、中枢神经(1条)、泌尿生殖(2条)、疼痛(1条)、液体丢失与引流(1条)、药物与营养(1条)、患者诊断预后与偏好(2条)及机构特定标准(4条)。
  • 所有标准均以二元决策指标(适合ICU转出 vs 需继续重症治疗/监测)表述,并附可适用的数值计算方法和重要性排序,标注「必须满足」标志及适用例外。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:改良在线德尔菲专家共识(指南类)。
  • 共识阈值:≥90%专家投票同意。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,为及时识别稳定的重症患者并实现安全高效的照护过渡,标准化出院准备度评估应基于患者因素及组织边界条件,并涉及多方利益相关者。
  • 共识提供的28条二元决策标准及「必须满足」标志可用于结构化评估成人ICU患者转出至普通病房的准备度。

指南或共识出处

  • Delphi study to derive expert consensus on a set of criteria to evaluate discharge readiness for adult ICU patients to be discharged to a general ward-European perspective(BMC Health Serv Res)

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE: Discharge decisions in Intensive Care Unit (ICU) patients are frequently taken under pressure to free up ICU beds. In the absence of established guidelines, the evaluation of discharge readiness commonly underlies subjective judgements. The challenge is to come to the right decision at the right time for the right patient. A premature care transition puts patients at risk of readmission to the ICU. Delayed discharge is a waste of resources and may result in over-treatment and suboptimal patient flow. More objective decision support is required to assess the individual patient's discharge readiness but also the current care capabilities of the receiving unit.

METHODS: In a modified online Delphi process, an international panel of 27 intensive care experts reached consensus on a set of 28 intensive care discharge criteria. An initial evidence-based proposal was developed further through the panelists' edits, adding, comments and voting over a course of 5 rounds. Consensus was defined as achieved when ≥ 90% of the experts voted for a given option on the Likert scale or in a multiple-choice survey. Round 1 to 3 focused on inclusion and exclusion of the criteria based on the consensus threshold, where round 3 was a reiteration to establish stability. Round 4 and 5 focused on the exact phrasing, values, decision makers and evaluation time frames per criterion.

RESULTS: Consensus was reached on a standard set of 28 ICU discharge criteria for adult ICU patients, that reflect the patient's organ systems ((respiratory (7), cardiovascular (9), central nervous (1), and urogenital system (2)), pain (1), fluid loss and drainages (1), medication and nutrition (1), patient diagnosis, prognosis and preferences (2) and institution-specific criteria (4). All criteria have been specified in a binary decision metric (fit for ICU discharge vs. needs further intensive therapy/monitoring), with consented value calculation methods where applicable and a criterion importance rank with "mandatory to be met" flags and applicable exceptions.

CONCLUSION: For a timely identification of stable intensive care patients and safe and efficient care transitions, a standardized discharge readiness evaluation should be based on patient factors as well as organizational boundary conditions and involve multiple stakeholders.

来源:BMC Health Serv Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Hiller M, Wittmann M, Bracht H, et al. Delphi study to derive expert consensus on a set of criteria to evaluate discharge readiness for adult ICU patients to be discharged to a general ward-European perspective. BMC Health Serv Res. 2022. PMID: 35698122. doi:10.1186/s12913-022-08160-6

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。