指南与共识中毒与环境急症

国家基本解毒剂目录专家共识:电子德尔菲法

Expert consensus for a national essential antidote list: E-Delphi method.
指南 / 共识 · PLoS One · 2022-06-16
一句话结论采用三轮电子德尔菲法,30名多学科专家达成共识,形成科威特急诊医院43种基本解毒剂目录。

为帮助医院降低成本并改善患者救治,该研究旨在为科威特急诊医院制定国家层面的基本解毒剂目录。研究采用电子德尔菲法,对47种基本解毒剂进行三轮投票,专家组成员为来自公立和私立医院的30名医疗专业人员。共识标准为≥75%专家同意纳入且无强烈反对。第一轮41种解毒剂达成共识并新增7种建议,第二轮7种新建议中2种达成共识,第三轮为确认性投票,专家维持前两轮意见。最终形成包含43种解毒剂的基本解毒剂目录。

要点

  • 采用三轮电子德尔菲法,专家小组由30名来自公立和私立医院的医疗专业人员组成。
  • 共识定义为≥75%专家同意纳入且无任何强烈反对。
  • 第一轮47种解毒剂中41种达成共识,专家另建议7种新解毒剂;第二轮7种新建议中2种达成共识;第三轮确认前两轮意见。
  • 最终形成包含43种解毒剂的基本解毒剂目录,可作为医疗机构保障解毒剂供应的初始基础。
  • 确保解毒剂充分可及的最佳方法是持续监测当地中毒发生率和解毒剂需求,并由学术研究者与急诊临床医生协作。

适用人群与场景

  • 科威特公立和私立急诊医院的医疗专业人员(专家小组n=30),讨论对象为急诊医院应配备的基本解毒剂。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 共识标准:≥75%的专家组成员同意纳入该解毒剂,且无任何强烈反对。

处置流程与药物剂量

  • 第一轮:对47种基本解毒剂进行电子调查投票,41种达成共识,专家小组另建议7种新解毒剂。
  • 第二轮:对7种新建议解毒剂再次投票,其中2种达成共识。
  • 第三轮:确认性投票,专家小组同意前几轮的意见。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型为电子德尔菲法共识研究;专家小组为目的性抽样的30名来自公立和私立医院的医疗专业人员;通过三轮投票对47种基本解毒剂进行共识评估。
  • 第一轮:41种解毒剂达成共识,并新增7种解毒剂建议;第二轮:7种新建议中2种达成共识;第三轮为确认性投票,专家同意前几轮意见;最终形成包含43种解毒剂的基本解毒剂目录。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:专家共识(电子德尔菲法,三轮投票);共识阈值:≥75%同意且无强烈反对。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,基本解毒剂目录可作为医疗机构保障解毒剂供应的初始基础。
  • 作者认为,确保解毒剂充分可及的最佳方法是持续监测当地中毒发生率和解毒剂需求,并由学术研究者与急诊临床医生协作。

指南或共识出处

  • 国家基本解毒剂目录专家共识(电子德尔菲法),PLoS One。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

Antidote stocking represents a major challenge to hospitals all over the world, including Kuwait. In order to assist hospitals to reduce costs and improve patient care, an essential antidote list can be used as an initial foundation for securing sufficient antidote availability at healthcare institutions. The aim of our study is to generate a nationally relevant essential antidote list for emergency care hospitals in Kuwait using the e-Delphi method by establishing consensus through a multidisciplinary expert group of healthcare providers. An electronic survey with 47 essential antidotes was developed. The e-Delphi method was used, with three rounds of voting, to determine expert consensus on an essential antidote list for hospitals in Kuwait. A purposive sample of healthcare professionals from governmental and private hospitals were selected for this study (n = 30). Consensus was gained if ≥75% of the expert panel agreed on the inclusion of the antidote, without any strong disagreements. Round 1 of the e-Delphi resulted in 41 antidotes reaching consensus and seven new antidotes suggested by the expert panel. Round 2 had two antidotes (out of seven newly suggested ones) reaching consensus. Round 3 was a confirmatory round, where the expert group agreed on their previous rounds' opinions. This resulted in the development of an essential antidote list with 43 antidotes. The optimal approach for ensuring adequate availability of antidotes is continuous monitoring of local poisoning incidence and antidote requirements through collaborations between academic researchers and emergency care clinicians. The development of an essential antidote list, with expert consensus, is one of the initial steps in securing a foundation for appropriate provision of antidotes at all healthcare institutions. This is the first study that the authors are aware of that demonstrates that the e-Delphi technique can consolidate recommendations of experts in emergency medicine to provide a list of essential antidotes.

来源:PLoS One,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Al-Taweel D, Koshy S, Al-Ansari S, et al. Expert consensus for a national essential antidote list: E-Delphi method. PLoS One. 2022. PMID: 35709136. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0269456

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。