军民合作与临床战备任务:来自军事卫生系统与美国外科医师学会的初步研究
该研究基于《蓝皮书》(由军事卫生系统与美国外科医师学会战略合作项目联合发布,供拟建立军民合作(MCP)的机构参考)设计问卷,通过电子邮件调查MCP军队外科医生与民间接收方负责人。共10名军队外科医生和7名接收方负责人完成调查;90%的军队外科医生被派驻MCP担任3年讲师角色,80%为创伤外科医生,60%每年在创伤岗位工作≥13周。军队外科医生认为接收方在学术成长、部署准备和受重视感方面的支持是积极属性;民间接收方负责人一致认为科研暴露、领导创伤团队机会、专职重症监护病房时间和患者量是项目的积极属性。作者结论认为《蓝皮书》标准与双方体验相符,继续完善此类调查可能有助于MCP项目的遴选与评估。
要点
- 共10名MCP军队外科医生和7名民间接收方负责人完成问卷,为初步调查研究。
- 90%的军队外科医生被派驻MCP担任3年讲师角色,80%为创伤外科医生。
- 60%的军队外科医生每年在创伤岗位工作≥13周。
- 军队外科医生认为接收方在学术成长、部署准备和受重视感方面的支持是积极属性。
- 民间接收方负责人一致认为科研暴露、领导创伤团队机会、专职ICU时间和患者量是积极项目属性。
适用人群与场景
- 拟建立或已建立军民合作(MCP)的机构中的军队外科医生与民间接收方负责人
- 军队外科医生中80%为创伤外科医生,90%被派驻担任3年讲师角色
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为初步调查研究,通过电子邮件向MCP军队外科医生和民间接收方负责人发放问卷。
- 共10名MCP军队外科医生和7名民间接收方负责人完成调查。
- 90%的军队外科医生被派驻MCP担任3年讲师角色,80%为创伤外科医生。
- 60%的军队外科医生每年在创伤岗位工作≥13周。
- 军队外科医生将接收方在学术成长、部署准备和受重视感方面的支持列为积极属性。
- 民间接收方负责人一致报告科研暴露、领导创伤团队的机会、专职重症监护病房时间和患者量是积极的项目属性。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:初步调查研究(问卷),证据等级为治疗/照护管理 Level V。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,《蓝皮书》所列标准与MCP军队外科医生及接收方负责人的体验相符。
- 作者认为,继续完善本调查及类似调查可能有助于MCP项目的遴选与评估过程。
指南或共识出处
- 《蓝皮书》(由军事卫生系统与美国外科医师学会战略合作项目联合发布)
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: The Blue Book , published in conjunction with the Military Health System Strategic Partnership with the American College of Surgeons, serves as a reference manual for institutions wishing to establish a military-civilian partnership (MCP). To evaluate the applicability of the criteria contained in the Blue Book , we created a survey to be distributed to MCP military surgeons and their civilian host champions.
METHODS: E-mail surveys were sent to MCP military surgeons and civilian host champions. Military surgeons were queried about basic demographic information and aspects of the MCP including type, duration of assignment, onboarding, malpractice coverage, and billing for services. We gathered information on the role of military surgeons at the MCP, workload information, and trauma cases. The civilian host champions survey focused on institutional activities including trauma surgical volume, clinical and educational opportunities for the military surgeons, and exposure to research. Military-civilian partnership military surgeons and civilian host champions were questioned on program attributes: administrative support, budget, and profile of the program within the institution.
RESULTS: Ten MCP military surgeons and 7 host champions completed surveys. The majority of military surgeons were assigned to the MCP for a 3-year instructor role (90%), and most were trauma surgeons (80%). Clinical activities for the military surgeon were where 60% spent ≥13 weeks annually on trauma. Military surgeons identified host program support in academic growth, deployment preparation, and sense of value at the MCP as positive attributes. Civilian host champions unanimously reported that exposure to research, opportunities to lead trauma teams, dedicated intensive care unit time, and patient volume were positive program attributes.
CONCLUSION: This preliminary survey demonstrates that the criteria put forth in the Blue Book align with experiences of MCP military surgeons and host champions. Continued development of this survey and others like it may be useful in the MCP program selection and evaluation process.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic/care management; Level V.
参考来源
- Grabo DJ, Gurney JM, Parascandola L, et al. Military-civilian partnerships and the clinical readiness mission: A preliminary study from the Military Health System and the American College of Surgeons. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2022. PMID: 35583979. doi:10.1097/TA.0000000000003704
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。