穿透性颈部血管损伤的体征判读:硬/软体征与初始管理分析——基于全国血管创伤数据库
基于美国创伤外科协会前瞻性观察性血管损伤治疗登记库25个美国创伤中心的数据,分析232例穿透性颈部血管损伤患者按初始查体硬体征或软体征分组后的影像与手术探查/修复率。硬体征110例(47%),其中61例(56%)立即手术探查、44%接受CT;CT后20例(18%)需开放手术修复、7%行腔内介入,21例(19%)无需手术干预。软体征122例(53%),37例(30%)立即手术、85例(70%)接受CT;CT后9%腔内修复、7%开放手术、65例(53%)观察。硬体征患者手术与单纯观察的死亡率无差异(23% vs. 17%,p=0.6)。作者认为硬体征不应视为立即手术探查的绝对指征。
要点
- 232例穿透性颈部血管损伤中硬体征110例(47%)、软体征122例(53%),硬体征不应视为立即手术探查的绝对指征。
- 硬体征者61例(56%)立即手术探查,44%接受CT;CT后20例(18%)开放修复、7%腔内介入、21例(19%)无需手术干预。
- 软体征者37例(30%)立即手术、85例(70%)接受CT;CT后9%腔内修复、7%开放手术、65例(53%)观察。
- 硬体征患者手术与单纯观察的死亡率无差异(23% vs. 17%,p=0.6)。
- 出血作为主要硬体征者最常需手术(76%),但出血、缺血、扩大性血肿分别有19%、20%、24%无需任何干预。
适用人群与场景
- 美国创伤外科协会前瞻性观察性血管损伤治疗登记库中25个美国创伤中心的穿透性颈部血管损伤患者,共232例。
- 按初始查体分为硬体征组110例(47%,出血、扩大性血肿或缺血)与软体征组122例(53%)。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 硬体征:出血、扩大性血肿或缺血;软体征:初始查体无上述硬体征表现。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 硬体征者61例(56%)行立即手术探查,44%接受CT影像;CT后20例(18%)需开放手术修复、7%行腔内介入、21例(19%)无需手术干预。
- 软体征者37例(30%)行立即手术,85例(70%)接受CT影像;CT后9%行腔内修复、7%行开放手术、65例(53%)观察。
- 出血为主要硬体征者最常需手术(76%);无需干预比例:出血19%、缺血20%、扩大性血肿24%。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 出血、扩大性血肿或缺血等硬体征提示常需手术干预,但硬体征不应视为立即手术探查的绝对指征。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:基于美国创伤外科协会前瞻性观察性血管损伤治疗登记库的分析,纳入25个美国创伤中心的232例穿透性颈部血管损伤患者。
- 硬体征110例(47%)中,61例(56%)立即手术探查、44%接受CT;CT后20例(18%)开放手术修复、7%腔内介入、21例(19%)无需手术干预。
- 软体征122例(53%)中,37例(30%)立即手术、85例(70%)接受CT;CT后9%腔内修复、7%开放手术、65例(53%)观察。
- 硬体征患者手术管理与单纯观察的死亡率无差异(23% vs. 17%,p=0.6)。
- 出血为主要硬体征者最常需手术(76%);无需干预比例:出血19%、缺血20%、扩大性血肿24%。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:前瞻性观察性登记库分析;证据等级:预后/流行病学,Level IV。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,穿透性颈部血管损伤的硬体征不应视为立即手术探查的绝对指征;初始CT影像可促成腔内治疗选择或非手术管理。
- 硬体征患者中约19%无需手术干预,出血、缺血、扩大性血肿分别有19%、20%、24%无需任何干预;硬体征患者手术与观察的死亡率无差异(23% vs. 17%,p=0.6)。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Algorithms for management of penetrating cervical vascular injuries (PCVIs) commonly call for immediate surgery with "hard signs" and imaging before intervention with "soft signs." We sought to analyze the association between initial examination and subsequent evaluation and management approaches.
METHODS: Analysis of PCVIs from the American Association for the Surgery of Trauma Prospective Observational Vascular Injury Treatment vascular injury registry from 25 US trauma centers was performed. Patients were categorized by initial examination findings of hard signs or soft signs, and subsequent imaging and surgical exploration/repair rates were compared.
RESULTS: Of 232 PCVI patients, 110 (47%) had hard signs (hemorrhage, expanding hematoma, or ischemia) and 122 (53%) had soft signs. With hard signs, 61 (56%) had immediate operative exploration and 44% underwent computed tomography (CT) imaging. After CT, 20 (18%) required open surgical repair, and 7% had endovascular intervention. Of note, 21 (19%) required no operative intervention. A total of 122 patients (53%) had soft signs on initial examination; 37 (30%) had immediate surgery, and 85 (70%) underwent CT imaging. After CT, 9% had endovascular repair, 7% had open surgery, and 65 (53%) were observed. No difference in mortality was observed for hard signs patients undergoing operative management versus observation alone (23% vs. 17%, p = 0.6). Those with hemorrhage as the primary hard signs most often required surgery (76%), but no interventions were required in 19% of hemorrhage, 20% of ischemia, and 24% of expanding hematoma.
CONCLUSION: Although hard signs in PCVIs are associated with the need for operative intervention, initial CT imaging can facilitate endovascular options or nonoperative management in a significant subgroup. Hard signs should not be considered an absolute indication for immediate surgical exploration.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Prognostic/Epidemiological; Level IV.
参考来源
- Marrotte A, Calvo RY, Badiee J, et al. Reading the signs in penetrating cervical vascular injuries: Analysis of hard/soft signs and initial management from a nationwide vascular trauma database. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2022. PMID: 35545805. doi:10.1097/TA.0000000000003678
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。