前景理论在产科的应用:评估小于或适于胎龄儿的分娩方式与新生儿结局
该队列研究纳入以色列一家三级中心2006至2018年100 198例无畸形足月单胎新生儿,按产前是否怀疑胎儿生长受限(FGR)与出生体重分为4组。产前怀疑FGR但出生为适于胎龄儿(假阳性组)的剖宫产率为16.1%,校正后剖宫产风险独立增加(OR 1.72;95%CI 1.56-1.88;P<.001),而新生儿结局未见改善。作者认为该现象可用前景理论与认知偏倚解释。提示产前FGR诊断可能驱动不必要的产科干预。
要点
- 产前怀疑FGR但出生为适于胎龄儿(假阳性组)剖宫产率16.1%,校正后剖宫产风险独立增加(OR 1.72;95%CI 1.56-1.88;P<.001)。
- 产前怀疑FGR的两组引产率分别为假阳性组11.4%、真阳性组31.9%,高于假阴性组12.4%与真阴性组8.6%(P<.001)。
- 小于胎龄儿(真阳性组6.0%、假阴性组3.9%)NICU入住率高于适于胎龄儿(假阳性组0.9%、真阴性组0.8%)(P<.001)。
- 1分钟低Apgar评分(<7)在真阳性组4.9%、假阴性组4.5%,高于假阳性组2.2%与真阴性组1.9%(P<.001)。
- 作者认为产前FGR诊断相关的剖宫产增加而未改善新生儿结局,可能以前景理论与认知偏倚解释。
适用人群与场景
- 2006至2018年以色列耶路撒冷一家三级中心分娩的100 198例无畸形足月单胎新生儿,按产前是否怀疑FGR与最终出生体重分为4组:假阳性组5671例、真阳性组3040例、假阴性组8508例、真阴性组82 979例;母亲平均(SD)年龄28.6(5.7)岁。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- FGR定义为出生体重低于同胎龄第10百分位;产前胎儿体重估计于入院待产时通过超声(Hadlock公式)与由培训过的产科医生进行临床评估完成。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为队列研究;共100 198例足月单胎无畸形新生儿,其中男婴50 941例(50.8%)。
- 产前怀疑FGR的8711例中,34.9%出生体重低于第10百分位,65.1%为适于胎龄儿。
- 引产率:假阳性组649例(11.4%)、真阳性组969例(31.9%)、假阴性组1055例(12.4%)、真阴性组7136例(8.6%)(P<.001)。
- 剖宫产率:假阳性组915例(16.1%)、真阳性组556例(18.3%)、假阴性组1106例(13.0%)、真阴性组6588例(7.9%)(P<.001)。
- NICU入住率:真阳性组182例(6.0%)、假阴性组328例(3.9%)、假阳性组51例(0.9%)、真阴性组704例(0.8%)(P<.001)。
- 1分钟低Apgar评分(<7):真阳性组149例(4.9%)、假阴性组384例(4.5%)、假阳性组124例(2.2%)、真阴性组1595例(1.9%)(P<.001)。
- 多因素模型以真阴性组为参照,假阳性组剖宫产风险独立增加(OR 1.72;95%CI 1.56-1.88;P<.001)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型为队列研究;局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为产前FGR诊断独立增加适于胎龄儿剖宫产风险70%而未改善新生儿结局,该结果可能以前景理论与临床决策中的认知偏倚解释。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
IMPORTANCE: Antenatal diagnosis of fetal weight is challenging, and the detection rate of fetal growth restriction (FGR) is low. Neonates with FGR are known to have an increased rate of obstetric intervention during labor, but the association of antenatal fetal weight estimation with mode of delivery and neonatal outcomes among neonates who are small and appropriate for gestational age (SGA and AGA) has not been reported.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the association of antenatal fetal weight estimation with mode of delivery and neonatal outcomes among neonates who are SGA and AGA, applying psychological concepts of cognitive bias and prospect theory to a model of clinical behavior.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This cohort study was conducted between 2019 and 2020 using data from 2006 to 2018 at a tertiary care center in Jerusalem, Israel. Participants were 100 198 term singleton neonates without anomalies who were categorized into 4 groups according to the presence of an antenatal suspicion of FGR and final birth weight. Neonates with false positives (FPs; ie, group 1-FP: those with suspected FGR who were AGA) and neonates with true positives (TPs; ie, group 2-TP: those with suspected FGR who were SGA) were compared with neonates with AGA antenatal fetal weight estimation, including neonates with false negatives (FNs; ie, group 3-FN: those not suspected to have FGR who were SGA) and neonates with true negatives (TNs; ie, group 4-TN: those not suspected to have FGR who were AGA). Data were analyzed from July 2019 to July 2020.
EXPOSURES: Fetal weight estimation was performed according to sonographic and clinical evaluation at admission to labor, with FGR defined as a birth weight less than the 10th percentile for gestational age. Sonographic fetal weight estimation was performed according to Hadlock formula. Clinical weight estimation was performed by trained obstetricians.
MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The primary outcomes were obstetric intervention and mode of delivery; the secondary outcomes were neonatal Apgar score (with low Apgar score defined as <7) and neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) admission rates.
RESULTS: Among 100 198 neonates eligible for the study (50941 [50.8%] male neonates), there were 5671 neonates in group 1-FP, 3040 neonates in group 2-TP, 8508 neonates in group 3-FN, and 82 979 neonates in group 4-TN. Mean (SD) maternal age was 28.6 (5.7) years. Among 8711 neonates with suspected FGR, 34.9% were below the 10th percentile at birth, while 65.1% were AGA. Neonates with suspected FGR had a significantly increased rate of induction of labor (group 1-FP: 649 neonates [11.4%] and group 2-TP: 969 neonates [31.9%]) compared with neonates in group 3-FN (1055 neonates [12.4%]) and group 4-TN (7136 neonates [8.6%]) (P < .001) and a significantly increased rate of cesarean delivery (group 1-FP: 915 neonates [16.1%] and group 2-TP: 556 neonates [18.3%] vs group 3-FN: 1106 neonates [13.0%] and group 4-TN: 6588 neonates [7.9%]; P < .001). Increased NICU admission was found for neonates who were SGA compared with neonates who were AGA (group 2-TP: 182 neonates [6.0%] and group 3-FN: 328 neonates [3.9%] vs group 1-FP: 51 neonates [0.9%] and group 4-TN: 704 neonates [0.8%]; P <.001), as was increased rate of low Apgar score (eg, at 1 minute: group 2-TP: 149 neonates [4.9%] and group 3-FN: 384 neonates [4.5%] vs group 1-FP: 124 neonates [2.2%] and group 4-TN: 1595 neonates [1.9%]; P < .001). In a multivariable model comparing group 1-FP, group 2-TP, and group 3-FN with group 4-TN, suspicion of FGR was independently associated with increased risk of caesarean delivery among neonates in group 1-FP (odds ratio, 1.72; 95% CI, 1.56-1.88; P < .001).
CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: This study found that antenatal diagnosis of FGR was independently associated with an increase in risk of caesarean delivery by 70% in neonates who were AGA without improvement in neonatal outcomes. These findings suggest that such outcomes may be explained by application of prospect theory and may be associated with cognitive bias in clinical decision-making.
参考来源
- Michaeli J, Michaeli O, Rozitzky A, et al. Application of Prospect Theory in Obstetrics by Evaluating Mode of Delivery and Outcomes in Neonates Born Small or Appropriate for Gestational Age. JAMA Netw Open. 2022. PMID: 35289859. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2022.2177
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。