文献速递重症综合管理与镇静镇痛复苏、休克与脓毒症

COVID-19区域激增期间危机照护标准评分系统对资源优先分配及按种族、族裔和社会脆弱区域估计的超额死亡率评估

Assessment of a Crisis Standards of Care Scoring System for Resource Prioritization and Estimated Excess Mortality by Race, Ethnicity, and Socially Vulnerable Area During a Regional Surge in COVID-19.
PubMed 文献 · JAMA Netw Open · 2022-03-01
一句话结论回顾性队列显示,按马萨诸塞州指南的CSOC优先评分,黑人患者更易落入最低优先级组(15.2% vs 8.1%,P=0.046),且仅最高优先级组获呼吸机时黑人超额死亡43.9% vs 其他28.6%(P=0.05)。

该回顾性队列纳入2020年4月13日至5月22日波士顿6家医院ICU的608例成人患者,其中498例评分完整者纳入分析。采用SOFA评分评估急性病情严重度、合并症和预期寿命评分评估慢性严重度,按马萨诸塞州指南切点分为有序优先级。主要结局为最低优先级组比例按种族分层;黑人患者更易处于最低优先级组(12/79,15.2% vs 34/419,8.1%;P=0.046)。探索性模拟中,仅最高优先级组获呼吸机时黑人超额死亡43.9%(18/41)vs 其他28.6%(58/203)(P=0.05);最高+中间优先级组获呼吸机时分别为4.9%(2/41)vs 3.0%(6/203)(P=0.53)。随机抽签总体超额死亡更多但未改善种族公平。

要点

  • 黑人患者更易被CSOC评分归入最低优先级组:12/79(15.2%)vs 34/419(8.1%),P=0.046。
  • 优先评分区分度良好:ROC曲线下面积0.79,且在不同种族组间相似。
  • 模拟仅最高优先级组获呼吸机:黑人超额死亡43.9%(18/41)vs 其他28.6%(58/203),P=0.05。
  • 模拟最高+中间优先级组获呼吸机:黑人超额死亡4.9%(2/41)vs 其他3.0%(6/203),P=0.53。
  • 随机抽签分配导致的总体超额死亡多于评分系统,且未改善按种族的公平性。

适用人群与场景

  • 2020年4月13日至5月22日COVID-19区域激增期间,马萨诸塞州大波士顿地区6家医院医疗网络ICU的成人患者。
  • 仅纳入CSOC评分完整的患者(608例中498例)。
  • 研究人群中位(IQR)年龄67(56-75)岁,女性191例(38.4%),黑人79例(15.9%),COVID-19患者225例(45.7%)。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • CSOC评分:采用序贯器官衰竭评估(SOFA)评分评估急性病情严重度,采用合并症评分和预期寿命评分评估慢性严重度。
  • 评分为有序分类,切点依据马萨诸塞州指南建议。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型:回顾性队列分析;6家医院;498例评分完整的ICU成人患者。
  • 主要结局:黑人患者最低优先级组比例为12/79(15.2%),其他患者为34/419(8.1%),P=0.046。
  • 优先评分的ROC曲线下面积为0.79,且在不同种族组间相似。
  • 探索性模拟(仅最高优先级组获呼吸机):黑人超额死亡43.9%(18/41),其他患者28.6%(58/203),P=0.05。
  • 探索性模拟(最高和中间优先级组获呼吸机):黑人超额死亡4.9%(2/41),其他患者3.0%(6/203),P=0.53。
  • 随机抽签导致的超额死亡多于评分系统,且未改善按种族的公平性。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:回顾性队列分析。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,应评估CSOC政策与医疗保健中种族差异的潜在关联。
  • 本研究发现CSOC优先评分导致黑人患者获得稀缺资源的优先级更低;使用随机抽签的模型总体估计超额死亡更多,且未改善按种族的公平性。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

IMPORTANCE: Crisis standards of care (CSOC) scores designed to allocate scarce resources during the COVID-19 pandemic could exacerbate racial disparities in health care.

OBJECTIVE: To analyze the association of a CSOC scoring system with resource prioritization and estimated excess mortality by race, ethnicity, and residence in a socially vulnerable area.

DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This retrospective cohort analysis included adult patients in the intensive care unit during a regional COVID-19 surge from April 13 to May 22, 2020, at 6 hospitals in a health care network in greater Boston, Massachusetts. Participants were scored by acute severity of illness using the Sequential Organ Failure Assessment score and chronic severity of illness using comorbidity and life expectancy scores, and only participants with complete scores were included. The score was ordinal, with cutoff points suggested by the Massachusetts guidelines.

EXPOSURES: Race, ethnicity, Social Vulnerability Index.

MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The primary outcome was proportion of patients in the lowest priority score category stratified by self-reported race. Secondary outcomes were discrimination and calibration of the score overall and by race, ethnicity, and neighborhood Social Vulnerability Index. Projected excess deaths were modeled by race, using the priority scoring system and a random lottery.

RESULTS: Of 608 patients in the intensive care unit during the study period, 498 had complete data and were included in the analysis; this population had a median (IQR) age of 67 (56-75) years, 191 (38.4%) female participants, 79 (15.9%) Black participants, and 225 patients (45.7%) with COVID-19. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve for the priority score was 0.79 and was similar across racial groups. Black patients were more likely than others to be in the lowest priority group (12 [15.2%] vs 34 [8.1%]; P = .046). In an exploratory simulation model using the score for ventilator allocation, with only those in the highest priority group receiving ventilators, there were 43.9% excess deaths among Black patients (18 of 41 patients) and 28.6% (58 of 203 patients among all others (P = .05); when the highest and intermediate priority groups received ventilators, there were 4.9% (2 of 41 patients) excess deaths among Black patients and 3.0% (6 of 203) among all others (P = .53). A random lottery resulted in more excess deaths than the score.

CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: In this study, a CSOC priority score resulted in lower prioritization of Black patients to receive scarce resources. A model using a random lottery resulted in more estimated excess deaths overall without improving equity by race. CSOC policies must be evaluated for their potential association with racial disparities in health care.

来源:JAMA Netw Open,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Riviello ED, Dechen T, O'Donoghue AL, et al. Assessment of a Crisis Standards of Care Scoring System for Resource Prioritization and Estimated Excess Mortality by Race, Ethnicity, and Socially Vulnerable Area During a Regional Surge in COVID-19. JAMA Netw Open. 2022. PMID: 35289860. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2022.1744

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。