改善院内患者救援:早期预警评分研究缺失了什么?一项范围综述
该范围综述检索CINAHL、PubMed和Scopus数据库,纳入2009至2021年发表的英文早期预警评分(EWS)实施研究,限定成人内外科住院患者,排除儿科、产科、精神科、院前、门诊、降阶梯病房或ICU患者。最终总结21项研究(18项前后对照研究、3项随机试验),涉及54家医院、1,107,883例患者。12项报告了EWS响应团队的人员构成,10项报告了手术患者比例,1项报告了护理比,无一项报告ICU内驻院重症医师配置,无一项测量床位利用或可用性变化,无一项估算成本。作者认为,决策者若想判断EWS实施是否改善医院质量,可能需要同行网络和嵌套于本地卫生系统的实施试点等替代方式。
要点
- 21项EWS实施研究(18项前后对照、3项随机试验)覆盖54家医院、1,107,883例患者,均未报告ICU内驻院重症医师配置。
- 仅1项研究报告护理比,无一项测量床位利用或可用性变化,无一项估算实施成本。
- 12项报告EWS响应团队人员构成,10项报告手术患者比例,16项定性描述教育/技术实施资源。
- 无一项描述团队稳定性或安全文化等劳动力构成,多数研究未报告医院情境细节。
- 作者认为,决策者可能需要同行网络和本地实施试点来辅助判断EWS的现实效用。
适用人群与场景
- 成人内外科住院患者;排除儿科、产科、精神科、院前、门诊、降阶梯病房或ICU患者。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:范围综述;检索CINAHL、PubMed和Scopus数据库,纳入2009至2021年发表的英文EWS实施研究。
- 共识别1,434项研究进行标题/摘要筛选,352项进行全文审查,最终总结21项研究(18项前后对照研究、3项随机试验)。
- 21项研究涉及54家医院、1,107,883例患者。
- 12项报告EWS响应团队的人员构成;10项报告手术患者比例;1项报告护理比;无一项报告ICU内驻院重症医师配置。
- 无一项测量床位利用或可用性变化;16项定性描述教育/技术实施资源,但无一项估算成本;无一项描述团队稳定性或安全文化等劳动力构成。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:范围综述。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,多数EWS相关研究未报告医院情境细节,决策者若想判断EWS实施是否改善医院质量,可能需要同行网络和嵌套于本地卫生系统的实施试点等替代方式。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Administrative and clinical efforts to improve hospital mortality and intensive care utilization commonly focus on patient rescue, where deteriorating patients are systematically identified and intervened upon. Patient rescue is known to depend on hospital context inclusive of technologic environment, structural features, and hospital organizational behavioral features. With widespread adoption of electronic medical records, early warning score (EWS) systems, which assign points to clinical data elements, are increasingly promoted as a tool for timely patient rescue by referencing their prediction of patient deterioration. We describe the extent to which EWS intervention studies describe the hospital environment of the intervention-details that would be critical for hospital leaders attempting to determine the real-world utility of EWSs in their own hospitals.
DATA SOURCES: We searched CINAHL, PubMed, and Scopus databases for English language EWS implementation research published between 2009 and 2021 in adult medical-surgical inpatients.
STUDY SELECTION: Studies including pediatric, obstetric, psychiatric, prehospital, outpatient, step-down, or ICU patients were excluded.
DATA EXTRACTION: Two investigators independently reviewed titles/abstracts for eligibility based on prespecified exclusion criteria.
DATA SYNTHESIS: We identified 1,434 studies for title/abstract screening. In all, 352 studies underwent full-text review and 21 studies were summarized. The 21 studies (18 before-and-after, three randomized trials) detailed 1,107,883 patients across 54 hospitals. Twelve reported the staff composition of an EWS response team. Ten reported the proportion of surgical patients. One reported nursing ratios; none reported intensive care staffing with in-house critical-care physicians. None measured changes in bed utilization or availability. While 16 qualitatively described resources for education/technologic implementation, none estimated costs. None described workforce composition such as team stability or culture of safety in the hospitals.
CONCLUSIONS: Despite hundreds of EWS-related publications, most do not report details of hospital context that would inform decisions about real-world EWS adoption. To make informed decisions about whether EWS implementation improves hospital quality, decision-makers may require alternatives such as peer networks and implementation pilots nested within local health systems.
参考来源
- Esmaeilzadeh S, Lane CM, Gerberi DJ, et al. Improving In-Hospital Patient Rescue: What Are Studies on Early Warning Scores Missing? A Scoping Review. Crit Care Explor. 2022. PMID: 35224506. doi:10.1097/CCE.0000000000000644
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。