重症监护室非工作时间出科的患者伤害与机构可避免性:混合方法分析
该研究是REcovery FoLlowing intensive CarE Treatment混合方法研究的一部分,将16:00至07:59定义为非工作时间出科。研究进行20例ICU出科后院内死亡且此前被判定「可能可避免」的病例记录审查和20例存活病例审查,并对55名患者、家属和员工进行半结构化访谈,结合利益相关者焦点小组,采用基于人为因素的功能分析共振法绘制ICU出科流程。结果显示非工作时间出科常见,患者和员工认为因夜间人员配置和技能组合减少而不安全;非工作时间出科患者常被过早出科、交接不充分、生理不稳定,且病情恶化未被识别或适当升级。研究识别出促进及时ICU出科的五个相互依赖的功能键。结论认为非工作时间出科后护理提供存在显著局限,应尽可能在16:00前转出,无法避免时需实施支持系统确保夜间出科患者安全。
要点
- 非工作时间出科定义为16:00至07:59,该时段出科常见,患者和员工描述因夜间人员配置和技能组合减少而不安全。
- 非工作时间出科患者常被过早出科、交接不充分、生理不稳定,且病情恶化未被识别或适当升级。
- 研究识别五个相互依赖的功能键:多学科团队出科决策、患者出科准备、床位会议、床位管理员分配床位、病房床位可用。
- 作者结论认为应尽可能促进16:00前转出至病房;16:00后出科无法避免时,应实施支持系统确保夜间出科患者安全。
适用人群与场景
- 从ICU出科至病房的患者、其家属及参与照护的员工。
- 研究纳入20例ICU出科后院内死亡且此前回顾性结构化判断审查判定为「可能可避免」的病例记录,以及20例存活病例记录。
- 访谈55名患者、家属成员和具有ICU出科流程经验的员工。
- 场景为三所英国国家卫生服务体系(NHS)医院,选择以代表不同医院环境。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 非工作时间出科定义为16:00至07:59。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 非工作时间出科患者生理不稳定。
- 非工作时间出科患者病情恶化未被识别或适当升级。
- 非工作时间出科患者交接不充分。
- 非工作时间出科患者常被过早出科。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究为REcovery FoLlowing intensive CarE Treatment混合方法研究的一部分,进行20例「可能可避免」院内死亡病例记录审查和20例存活病例记录审查,访谈55名患者、家属和员工,并结合利益相关者焦点小组,采用基于人为因素的功能分析共振法绘制ICU出科流程。
- 非工作时间出科常见;患者和员工描述非工作时间出科因夜间人员配置和技能组合减少而不安全。
- 非工作时间出科患者常被过早出科、交接不充分、生理不稳定,且病情恶化未被识别或适当升级。
- 识别出促进及时ICU出科的五个相互依赖功能键:多学科团队出科决策、患者出科准备、床位会议、床位管理员分配床位、病房床位可用。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:混合方法研究,为REcovery FoLlowing intensive CarE Treatment研究的一部分。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为应尽可能促进16:00前转出至病房。
- 作者认为16:00后出科无法避免时,应实施支持系统以确保夜间出科患者安全。
- 作者工作突出可帮助使日间出科更可能的变化。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Out-of-hours discharge from ICU to the ward is associated with increased in-hospital mortality and ICU readmission. Little is known about why this occurs. We map the discharge process and describe the consequences of out-of-hours discharge to inform practice changes to reduce the impact of discharge at night.
DESIGN: This study was part of the REcovery FoLlowing intensive CarE Treatment mixed methods study. We defined out-of-hours discharge as 16:00 to 07:59 hours. We undertook 20 in-depth case record reviews where in-hospital death after ICU discharge had been judged "probably avoidable" in previous retrospective structured judgment reviews, and 20 where patients survived. We conducted semistructured interviews with 55 patients, family members, and staff with experience of ICU discharge processes. These, along with a stakeholder focus group, informed ICU discharge process mapping using the human factors-based functional analysis resonance method.
SETTING: Three U.K. National Health Service hospitals, chosen to represent different hospital settings.
SUBJECTS: Patients discharged from ICU, their families, and staff involved in their care.
INTERVENTIONS: None.
MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Out-of-hours discharge was common. Patients and staff described out-of-hours discharge as unsafe due to a reduction in staffing and skill mix at night. Patients discharged out-of-hours were commonly discharged prematurely, had inadequate handover, were physiologically unstable, and did not have deterioration recognized or escalated appropriately. We identified five interdependent function keys to facilitating timely ICU discharge: multidisciplinary team decision for discharge, patient prepared for discharge, bed meeting, bed manager allocation of beds, and ward bed made available.
CONCLUSIONS: We identified significant limitations in out-of-hours care provision following overnight discharge from ICU. Transfer to the ward before 16:00 should be facilitated where possible. Our work highlights changes to help make day time discharge more likely. Where discharge after 16:00 is unavoidable, support systems should be implemented to ensure the safety of patients discharged from ICU at night.
参考来源
- Vollam S, Gustafson O, Morgan L, et al. Patient Harm and Institutional Avoidability of Out-of-Hours Discharge From Intensive Care: An Analysis Using Mixed Methods. Crit Care Med. 2022. PMID: 35245235. doi:10.1097/CCM.0000000000005514
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。