儿童眶周与眶内蜂窝织炎:急诊医师调查及PERUKI网络临床实践指南分析
该研究于2018年11月23日至2019年1月22日对PERUKI站点急诊医师进行网络调查,并收集各站点临床实践指南(CPG),用标准化工具和RIGHT标准评估质量,同时比较调查结果与CPG推荐。83%(49/59)受邀机构提交了个人调查回复,67%的回复站点有CPG,63%(31/49)提交了CPG;CPG质量差(RIGHT标准平均6.7/35)。CPG共识别出21种不同的严重度标志物;多数CPG推荐对重症进行检查,但23%(7/31)建议普遍行血培养;90%的CPG建议轻症口服抗生素出院,但86%的受访者报告所有眶周蜂窝织炎患者均收治入院。几乎所有受访者将眼球突出、全身不适和视力障碍列为入院指征,但其他体征的重要性存在分歧。结论认为PERUKI网络内实践存在差异,CPG推荐不一,临床实践与CPG似乎不同,指南质量总体较差。
要点
- PERUKI网络83%(49/59)受邀机构提交调查回复,67%的回复站点有CPG,63%(31/49)提交了CPG。
- CPG质量差,RIGHT标准平均6.7/35;CPG共识别出21种不同的严重度标志物。
- 多数CPG推荐对重症进行检查,但23%(7/31)建议普遍行血培养。
- 90%的CPG建议轻症口服抗生素出院,但86%的受访者报告所有眶周蜂窝织炎患者均收治入院。
- 几乎所有受访者将眼球突出、全身不适和视力障碍列为入院指征,但其他体征的重要性存在分歧。
适用人群与场景
- PERUKI站点临床评估儿童的指定急诊医师,代表科室整体视角,涉及入院、严重度评估、治疗、处置和专科会诊请求。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 共识别出21种不同的严重度标志物(具体标志物未在摘要中列出)。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 90%的CPG建议轻症患者口服抗生素出院。
- 23%(7/31)的CPG建议普遍行血培养。
- 多数CPG推荐对重症患者进行检查。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 几乎所有受访者将眼球突出、全身不适和视力障碍列为入院指征。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为网络调查及CPG分析;83%(49/59)受邀机构提交个人调查回复。
- 67%的回复站点有CPG,63%(31/49)提交CPG;CPG质量差,RIGHT标准平均6.7/35。
- CPG共识别出21种不同的严重度标志物。
- 多数CPG推荐对重症进行检查,但23%(7/31)建议普遍行血培养。
- 90%的CPG建议轻症口服抗生素出院,但86%的受访者报告所有眶周蜂窝织炎患者均收治入院。
- 几乎所有受访者将眼球突出、全身不适和视力障碍列为入院指征,但其他体征的重要性存在分歧。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:指南质量分析及调查(来自Emerg Med J)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- PERUKI网络内儿童眶周蜂窝织炎严重度评估与处置存在差异,CPG推荐不一,临床实践与CPG似乎不同,指南质量总体较差;原文未据此给出推荐。
指南或共识出处
- PERUKI网络临床实践指南分析(Emerg Med J)。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Due to limited evidence to guide management of periorbital cellulitis (POC), we surveyed current practice and assessed quality and consistency of local clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) to highlight future research priorities.
METHODS: A web-based survey was sent to a designated emergency physician (who clinically assesses children) at Paediatric Emergency Research United Kingdom and Ireland (PERUKI) sites between 23 November 2018 to 22 January 2019. A nominated site lead offered one response as a department-wide perspective on admission, severity assessment, treatment, disposition and specialty consultation request. Sites shared their CPG. These were compared using a standardised data collection tool, and quality assessed using Standardised Reporting Practice Guidelines in Healthcare (RIGHT) criteria. Survey responses were also compared against CPG recommendations.
RESULTS: 83% (49/59) institutions invited submitted an individual survey response. 67% of responding sites had a CPG and 63% (31/49) submitted these. CPG quality was poor (mean 6.7/35 RIGHT criteria). 21 different severity markers were identified across CPGs. Most CPGS recommend investigations for severe disease, yet 23% (7/31) advise blood culture universally. 90% of CPGs advise discharge with oral antibiotics for milder cases, yet 86% of respondents reported departmental admission of all patients with POC. Nearly all respondents included proptosis, systemically unwell and visual disturbance as indications for admission but differed regarding importance of other signs.
CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrated variation in practice across the PERUKI network in assessment of severity and management of POC. CPGs vary in recommendations, and clinical practice appears to differ from CPGs. Guidelines were generally of poor quality when compared against RIGHT standards.
参考来源
- Tolhurst-Cleaver M, Evans J, Waterfield T, et al. Periorbital and orbital cellulitis in children: a survey of emergency physicians and analysis of clinical practice guidelines across the PERUKI network. Emerg Med J. 2022. PMID: 35264451. doi:10.1136/emermed-2021-211713
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。