重型创伤性脑损伤院外最佳血压:对当前低血压认识的挑战
本文为EPIC TBI研究预设的二次分析,纳入年龄≥10岁、重型TBI(Barell矩阵1型和/或简明损伤定级-头部≥3)且院外最低收缩压40–299 mmHg的患者,用广义相加模型在不预设低血压、正常血压或高血压阈值的前提下评估院外收缩压与多项院内结局的关联,并在指南实施后队列中验证模型。共纳入12,169例,死亡率模型显示三个区间:收缩压40–130 mmHg期间调整死亡概率单调下降,130–180 mmHg调整死亡率最低,>180 mmHg死亡率快速上升;孤立性TBI与多系统损伤合并TBI亚组模式相似,非死亡结局(住院时间、ICU时间、出院至专业护理/住院康复、住院费用)模式亦相似。作者认为这些发现提示损伤脑对既往被视为充足甚至正常的收缩压水平下的灌注不足高度敏感,但研究设计不能得出应提高现行<90 mmHg治疗阈值的结论。
要点
- 12,169例重型TBI中,院外收缩压130–180 mmHg对应最低调整死亡率,>180 mmHg死亡率快速上升。
- 收缩压40–130 mmHg期间调整死亡概率随收缩压升高单调下降,未见提示低血压阈值的拐点。
- 作者指出,现行TBI低血压定义(<90 mmHg)可能过低,但研究设计不能据此得出应提高治疗阈值的结论。
- 孤立性TBI与多系统损伤合并TBI亚组的收缩压-死亡率模式相似。
适用人群与场景
- 年龄≥10岁的重型TBI患者(Barell矩阵1型和/或简明损伤定级-头部严重度≥3),院外最低收缩压40–299 mmHg。
- 数据来自EPIC TBI研究,包括指南实施前队列(建模)与实施后队列(验证)。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 低血压未采用预设阈值定义,而是以广义相加模型将结局作为收缩压的平滑函数分析。
- 原文提及现行推荐的TBI治疗阈值为收缩压<90 mmHg。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:EPIC TBI研究预设的二次分析,共纳入12,169例,使用广义相加模型调整混杂因素,并在指南实施后队列中验证。
- 死亡率模型呈三段:收缩压40–130 mmHg期间调整死亡概率单调下降;130–180 mmHg调整死亡率最低;>180 mmHg死亡率快速上升。
- 孤立性TBI亚组与多系统损伤合并TBI亚组的收缩压-死亡率模式相似,且与主分析相似。
- 非死亡结局(住院时间、ICU住院时间、出院至专业护理/住院康复、住院费用)的收缩压区间略有不同,但模式与死亡率非常相似。
- 各模型均在指南实施后队列中得到验证。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:预设的二次分析(观察性研究),来自EPIC TBI研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性(作者指出研究设计不能得出应提高现行<90 mmHg治疗阈值的结论,并呼吁开展评估显著高于90 mmHg治疗水平的随机试验)。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,这些发现提示损伤脑对既往被视为充足甚至正常的收缩压水平下的灌注不足高度敏感。
- 作者指出,研究设计不能得出应提高现行推荐治疗阈值(<90 mmHg)的结论,但结果提示TBI场景下低血压的定义过低。
- 作者呼吁开展评估显著高于90 mmHg治疗水平的随机试验。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
STUDY OBJECTIVE: Little is known about the out-of-hospital blood pressure ranges associated with optimal outcomes in traumatic brain injuries (TBI). Our objective was to evaluate the associations between out-of-hospital systolic blood pressure (SBP) and multiple hospital outcomes without assuming any predefined thresholds for hypotension, normotension, or hypertension.
METHODS: This was a preplanned secondary analysis from the Excellence in Prehospital Injury Care (EPIC) TBI study. Among patients (age ≥10 years) with major TBIs (Barell Matrix type 1 and/or Abbreviated Injury Scale-head severity ≥3) and lowest out-of-hospital SBPs of 40 to 299 mmHg, we utilized generalized additive models to summarize the distributions of various outcomes as smoothed functions of SBP, adjusting for important and significant confounders. The subjects who were enrolled in the study phase after the out-of-hospital TBI guideline implementation were used to validate the models developed from the preimplementation cohort.
RESULTS: Among 12,169 included cases, the mortality model revealed 3 distinct ranges: (1) a monotonically decreasing relationship between SBP and the adjusted probability of death from 40 to 130 mmHg, (2) lowest adjusted mortality from 130 to 180 mmHg, and (3) rapidly increasing mortality above 180 mmHg. A subanalysis of the cohorts with isolated TBIs and multisystem injuries with TBIs revealed SBP mortality patterns that were similar to each other and to that of the main analysis. While the specific SBP ranges varied somewhat for the nonmortality outcomes (hospital length of stay, ICU length of stay, discharge to skilled nursing/inpatient rehabilitation, and hospital charges), the patterns were very similar to that of mortality. In each model, validation was confirmed utilizing the postimplementation cohort.
CONCLUSION: Optimal adjusted mortality was associated with a surprisingly high SBP range (130 to 180 mmHg). Below this level, there was no point or range of inflection that would indicate a physiologically meaningful threshold for defining hypotension. Nonmortality outcomes showed very similar patterns. These findings highlight how sensitive the injured brain is to compromised perfusion at SBP levels that, heretofore, have been considered adequate or even normal. While the study design does did not allow us to conclude that the currently recommended treatment threshold (<90 mmHg) should be increased, the findings imply that the definition of hypotension in the setting of TBI is too low. Randomized trials evaluating treatment levels significantly higher than 90 mmHg are needed.
参考来源
- Spaite DW, Hu C, Bobrow BJ, et al. Optimal Out-of-Hospital Blood Pressure in Major Traumatic Brain Injury: A Challenge to the Current Understanding of Hypotension. Ann Emerg Med. 2022. PMID: 35339285. doi:10.1016/j.annemergmed.2022.01.045
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。