指南与共识重症综合管理与镇静镇痛

CAMUS Delphi研究方案:泌尿外科手术并发症全面报告与分级的共识

Protocol for CAMUS Delphi Study: A Consensus on Comprehensive Reporting and Grading of Complications After Urological Surgery.
指南 / 共识 · Eur Urol Focus · 2022-02-25
一句话结论CAMUS Delphi研究拟通过多学科专家共识建立泌尿外科手术并发症标准化报告与分级系统,以解决现行系统报告不一致的问题。

该研究方案旨在开发一套标准化、可重复的围手术期并发症评估与报告语言,通过12部分基于REDCap的Delphi调查,纳入国际泌尿外科医生、麻醉科医生和重症监护专科医生,目标样本量至少750人(500名泌尿外科医生和250名重症监护专科医生)。调查评估参与者人口学特征、对并发症报告的意见、对拟议的泌尿外科大手术和小手术并发症(CAMUS)报告建议的认可度、使用现有Clavien-Dindo分类和拟议CAMUS分类对干预事件进行分级,以及对各种临床场景的评分。共识定义为≥75%的多数同意;若未达成共识,将在指导委员会指导下进行后续Delphi轮次。21名参与者完成了调查草案,中位完成时间为128分钟(四分位距88-135);90%的参与者认为当前并发症分类系统有用但不准确,100%的参与者认为普遍需要报告共识。局限性包括拟议补充分级的复杂性和调查完成时间。作者认为,通过Delphi调查获得的多学科专家共识开发的新CAMUS分类系统,可能最终实现泌尿外科并发症报告与分级的标准化,从而改善患者咨询和医疗质量。

要点

  • 目标样本量至少750名参与者,包括500名泌尿外科医生和250名重症监护专科医生,通过12部分REDCap Delphi调查进行。
  • 共识定义为≥75%的多数同意;若未达成共识,将在指导委员会指导下进行后续Delphi轮次。
  • 21名参与者完成调查草案,中位完成时间128分钟(四分位距88-135)。
  • 90%的参与者认为当前并发症分类系统有用但不准确,100%的参与者认为普遍需要报告共识。
  • 局限性包括拟议补充分级的复杂性和调查完成时间。

适用人群与场景

  • 国际泌尿外科医生、麻醉科医生和重症监护专科医生将参与调查。
  • 目标样本量至少750名参与者(500名泌尿外科医生和250名重症监护专科医生)。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 共识定义为≥75%的多数同意。
  • 若未达成共识,将在指导委员会指导下进行后续Delphi轮次。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 12部分基于REDCap的Delphi调查,与方法学家审阅和有经验的泌尿外科医生意见共同开发。
  • 调查评估参与者人口学特征、对并发症报告的意见、对拟议的泌尿外科大手术和小手术并发症(CAMUS)报告建议的认可度、使用现有Clavien-Dindo分类和拟议CAMUS分类对干预事件进行分级,以及对各种临床场景的评分。
  • 21名参与者完成了调查草案,中位调查完成时间为128分钟(四分位距88-135)。
  • 90%的参与者认为当前并发症分类系统有用但不准确,100%的参与者认为普遍需要报告共识。
  • 根据反馈进行了若干修订。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 研究类型:Delphi调查方案。
  • 局限性包括拟议补充分级的复杂性和调查完成时间。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,通过Delphi调查获得的多学科专家共识开发的新CAMUS分类系统,可能最终实现泌尿外科并发症报告与分级的标准化,从而改善患者咨询和医疗质量。

指南或共识出处

  • CAMUS Delphi研究方案(Eur Urol Focus)。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Reproducible assessment of postoperative complications is essential for reliable evaluation of quality of care to enable comparison between healthcare centres and ensure transparent patient counselling. Currently, significant discrepancies exist in complication reporting and grading due to heterogeneous definitions and methodologies.

OBJECTIVE: To develop a standardised and reproducible assessment of perioperative complications and overall associated morbidity, to allow for the construction of a uniform language for complication reporting and grading.

DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: The 12-part REDCap-based Delphi survey was developed in conjunction with methodologist review and experienced urologist opinion. International urologists, anaesthetists, and intensive care unit specialists will be included. A minimum sample size of 750 participants (500 urologists and 250 critical care specialities) is targeted.

OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS AND STATISTICAL ANALYSIS: The survey assesses participant demographics, opinion on complication reporting and the proposed Complications After Major & Minor Urological Surgery (CAMUS) reporting recommendations, grading of intervention events using the existing Clavien-Dindo classification and the proposed CAMUS classification, and rating of various clinical scenarios. Consensus will be defined as ≥75% majority agreement. If consensus is not reached, then subsequent Delphi rounds will be performed under steering committee guidance.

RESULTS AND LIMITATIONS: Twenty-one participants completed the draft survey. The median survey completion time was 128 min (interquartile range 88-135). The survey revealed that 90% of participants believe that the current complication classification systems are useful but inaccurate, while 100% of participants believe that there is a universal demand for reporting consensus. Several amendments were made following feedback. Limitations include complexity of the proposed supplemental grades and time to completion of the survey.

CONCLUSIONS: To ensure comprehensive and comparable complication reporting and grading across centres worldwide, a conclusive uniform language for complication reporting must be created. We intend to address shortcomings of the current complication reporting and classification systems with a new CAMUS classification system developed through multidisciplinary expert consensus obtained through a Delphi survey. Ultimately, standardisation of urological complication reporting and grading may improve patient counselling and quality of care.

PATIENT SUMMARY: The reporting and grading of operative complications that occur during or after an operation and associated costs provide a means to stratify quality of patient care. Current complication reporting and classification systems are not standardised and somewhat inaccurate, and thus significantly underestimate patient morbidity and surgical risk. This Delphi survey will provide the basis for the creation of a uniform complication reporting and grading system. Our new system may allow improved reporting and grading between centres, and ultimately improve patient counselling and care.

来源:Eur Urol Focus,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Soliman C, Mulholland CJ, Santaguida P, et al. Protocol for CAMUS Delphi Study: A Consensus on Comprehensive Reporting and Grading of Complications After Urological Surgery. Eur Urol Focus. 2022. PMID: 35221259. doi:10.1016/j.euf.2022.01.016

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。