尸猪骨模型下全血骨髓腔输注装置与配置的性能比较
本研究在新鲜高骨密度尸猪肱骨近端,经15G、45mm骨髓腔导管输注500mL全血,由3名受训医师按随机自身对照设计实施8种加压输注策略,每种30次、共240次。结果显示手动快速输注器流量最高(199±3 mL/min)但平均压和峰值压也最高;推拉法流量次之(60mL注射器67±5 mL/min,10mL注射器56±2 mL/min);手泵加或不加压力袋流量几乎相同(45±4 vs 44±3 mL/min);压力袋和重力法流量与使用者评分均低。作者认为部分加压骨髓腔输注方法可达到足以作为大量失血创伤患者复苏桥接的流量,但不同方法流量和压力差异很大,未来需体内模型评估可能的临床并发症。
要点
- 手动快速输注器流量最高(199±3 mL/min),使用者评分最有利,但平均压和峰值压也最高。
- 推拉法流量次之:60mL注射器67±5 mL/min,10mL注射器56±2 mL/min,压力也较高,使用者评分中至高。
- 手泵加压力袋(45±4 mL/min)与不加压力袋(44±3 mL/min)流量几乎相同,不加压力袋时使用者评分高。
- 压力袋和重力法流量低、使用者评分低。
- 作者指出各骨髓腔加压输注方法流量和压力差异大,需体内模型评估高压力方法可能的临床并发症。
适用人群与场景
- 新鲜、高骨密度尸猪肱骨近端骨髓腔,经15G、45mm骨髓腔导管输注500mL全血。
- 由3名受训医师操作,随机自身对照设计,每种方法30次,共240次。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 重力法:仅靠重力输注全血。
- 压力袋法:使用压力袋加压输注。
- 压力袋主动维持≥300 mmHg法:压力袋压力主动维持在不低于300 mmHg。
- 手泵法:使用手泵输注。
- 手泵联合压力袋法:手泵加压力袋输注。
- 推拉法(10mL注射器):用10mL注射器行推拉式输注。
- 推拉法(60mL注射器):用60mL注射器行推拉式输注。
- 手动快速输注器法:使用Manual Rapid Infuser输注。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为尸猪骨模型随机自身对照实验,共240次试验(每种方法30次),由3名受训医师操作。
- 手动快速输注器流量最高(199±3 mL/min),使用者评分最有利,但平均压和峰值压也最高。
- 推拉法流量次之:60mL注射器67±5 mL/min,10mL注射器56±2 mL/min,压力也较高,使用者评分中至高。
- 手泵加压力袋流量45±4 mL/min,不加压力袋44±3 mL/min,两者几乎相同;不加压力袋时使用者评分高。
- 压力袋法和重力法流量低、使用者评分低。
- 主要结局流量、平均压和峰值压及使用者评分的比较采用ANOVA,p<0.05。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:尸猪骨模型实验研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为部分加压骨髓腔输注方法可达到足以作为大量失血创伤患者复苏桥接的流量。
- 作者指出各骨髓腔加压输注方法流量和压力差异很大,手动快速输注器和推拉法流量高但压力也相对高。
- 作者强调未来需用体内模型评估这些有前景方法可能的临床并发症。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Intraosseous (IO) access can provide a critical bridge for blood product infusion when peripheral venous access is not obtainable. Successful pressurized IO infusion requires flow rates sufficient to preserve life, but with infusion pressures low enough to avoid clinical complications (e.g., hemolysis, bone damage, fat emboli). However, the optimal method for pressured IO delivery of blood was unknown.
METHODS: Three trained physicians infused 500 mL of whole blood through a 15-gauge, 45 mm IO catheter into fresh, high bone density cadaveric swine proximal humeri. Participants applied eight different pressure infusion strategies: (1) gravity, (2) pressure bag, (3) pressure bag actively maintained at or above 300 mmHg, (4) hand pump, (5) hand pump with pressure bag, (6) push-pull with 10 mL syringe, (7) push-pull with 60 mL syringe, and a (8) Manual Rapid Infuser in a randomized within-subjects design (30 trials per method, 240 trials total). The primary outcomes of flow rates, mean and peak pressures, and user ratings were contrasted using ANOVA at p < 0.05.
RESULTS: The Manual Rapid Infuser conferred the highest flow rates (199 ± 3 mL/min) and most favorable user ratings, but also the highest mean and peak pressures. Push-pull conferred the next highest flow rates (67 ± 5 mL/min for 60 mL, 56 ± 2 mL/min for 10 mL) and pressures, with intermediate-to-high user ratings. Hand pump flow rates were essentially identical with (45 ± 4 mL/min) or without (44 ± 3 mL/min) pressure bag, with high user ratings without a pressure bag. Pressure bag and gravity methods conferred low flow rates and user ratings.
CONCLUSIONS: Some pressured IO infusion methods can achieve flow rates adequate to serve as a resuscitative bridge in the massively hemorrhaged trauma victim, but flow rates and pressures vary greatly across IO pressurized infusion methods. Manual Rapid Infuser and push-pull methods conferred high flow rates but also relatively high pressures, highlighting the importance of using in vivo models in future research to assess the possible clinical complications of using these promising methods. Combined, present findings highlight the importance of studying pressurized IO methods towards preserving the life of the critically injured trauma victim.
参考来源
- Lee KJ, McGuire MM, Harvey WC, et al. Performance comparison of intraosseous devices and setups for infusion of whole blood in a cadaveric swine bone model. Am J Emerg Med. 2022. PMID: 35123236. doi:10.1016/j.ajem.2022.01.039
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。