种族与创伤死亡率:医院层面黑人-白人患者种族分布的影响
研究基于2017年美国全国住院患者样本,纳入年龄≥18岁、种族为黑人或有白色人种、损伤严重度评分≥4的创伤患者184,080例,按医院收治黑人患者比例将2,376家医院分为高比例收治黑人(H-BS,前5%)、中等(5-25%)和低比例(L-BS,后75%)三组。结果显示,黑人患者在H-BS医院死亡率最低(OR 0.76 [0.64-0.92]),在L-BS医院死亡率最高(OR 1.43 [1.13-1.80]);白人在L-BS医院死亡率最低(OR 0.76 [0.64-0.92])。作者认为,黑人和白人患者均在收治该种族患者最频繁的医院结局最好,提示可能存在机构层面的种族偏倚,需推动所有医院公平救治。
要点
- 黑人创伤患者在H-BS医院死亡率最低(OR 0.76 [0.64-0.92]),在L-BS医院死亡率最高(OR 1.43 [1.13-1.80])。
- 白人创伤患者在L-BS医院死亡率最低(OR 0.76 [0.64-0.92])。
- 29.8%的黑人患者和3.6%的白人患者在H-BS医院治疗;71.7%的白人患者和23.6%的黑人患者在L-BS医院治疗(p < 0.001)。
- 研究纳入184,080例创伤患者(中位年龄72岁[IQR 55-84],ISS 9 [4-10]),黑人占11.7%,总死亡率4%。
- 2,376家医院中,126家(5.3%)为H-BS,469家(19.7%)为中等收治黑人比例医院。
适用人群与场景
- 2017年美国全国住院患者样本中年龄≥18岁、种族为黑人或有白色人种、损伤严重度评分≥4的创伤患者。
- 研究场景为住院创伤救治,非急诊或ICU专门场景。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 损伤严重度评分≥4(依据国际疾病分类第十版代码计算)。
- 医院按收治黑人患者比例分组:H-BS为前5%,中等为5-25%,L-BS为后75%。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为基于2017年全国住院患者样本的横断面分析;样本量184,080例;人群为成人黑人或有白色人种创伤患者(ISS≥4);中位年龄72岁(IQR 55-84),ISS 9(4-10),黑人占11.7%,总死亡率4%。
- 2,376家医院中,H-BS 126家(5.3%),中等收治黑人比例医院469家(19.7%);29.8%的黑人患者和3.6%的白人患者在H-BS医院治疗,71.7%的白人患者和23.6%的黑人患者在L-BS医院治疗(p < 0.001)。
- 采用种族与医院服务等级交互变量的校正逻辑回归(参照组:H-BS医院的白人患者)显示,黑人患者在H-BS医院死亡率最低(OR 0.76 [0.64-0.92]),在L-BS医院死亡率最高(OR 1.43 [1.13-1.80]);白人患者在L-BS医院死亡率最低(OR 0.76 [0.64-0.92])。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:预后与流行病学研究;证据等级:Level IV。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,黑人和白人患者均在收治该种族患者最频繁的医院结局最好,提示可能存在机构层面的种族偏倚;需进一步努力促进所有医院公平救治并缩小这些差异。
指南或共识出处
- J Trauma Acute Care Surg
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Race-related health disparities have been well documented in the United States. In some settings, Black patients have better outcomes in hospitals that serve high proportions of Black patients. We hypothesized that Black trauma patients would have lower mortality in high Black-serving (H-BS) hospitals.
METHODS: We identified all adult patients with Black or White race and with an Injury Severity Score of ≥4 from the 2017 National Inpatient Sample. We collected hospital identifier, mechanism, age, sex, comorbidities, urban-rural location, insurance, zip code income quartile, and injury severity calculated from International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Revision, codes. We used a previously published method to group hospitals by proportion of Black patients served: HB-S (top 5%), medium Black serving (5-25%), and low Black serving (L-BS; bottom 75%). Adjusted logistic regression using an interaction variable between race and hospital service rank (reference: White patients in H-BS) was used to identify factors associated with mortality.
RESULTS: We analyzed 184,080 trauma patients (median age, 72 years [interquartile range, 55-84 years]; Injury Severity Score, 9 [4-10]), of whom 11.7% were Black. Overall mortality was 4%. Of 2,376 hospitals, 126 (5.3%) were H-BS and 469 (19.7%) were medium Black serving. Furthermore, 29.8% of Black and 3.6% of White patients were treated at H-BS hospitals, while 71.7% of White and 23.6% of Black patients were treated at L-BS hospitals (p < 0.001). Black patients had the lowest mortality at H-BS hospitals (odds ratio [OR], 0.76 [0.64-0.92]) and the highest mortality (OR, 1.43 [1.13-1.80]) at L-BS hospitals. White patients had the lowest mortality at L-BS hospitals (OR, 0.76 [0.64-0.92]).
CONCLUSION: After adjusting for patient and hospital factors, disparities exist such that Black and White patients have the best outcomes in hospitals that treat those patients most frequently, suggesting potential for racial bias at the institutional level. Further efforts must be made to promote equitable treatment at all hospitals and reduce these disparities.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Prognostic and Epidemiologic; Level IV.
参考来源
- Kishawi SK, Tseng ES, Adomshick VJ, et al. Race and trauma mortality: The effect of hospital-level Black-White patient race distribution. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2022. PMID: 35125445. doi:10.1097/TA.0000000000003538
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。