创伤抢救室虚拟现实——ATLS教学与评估的变革者
该先导研究在一级创伤中心纳入31名提供者(急症外科主治、新手MS4与PGY1、初级PGY2-3、高级PGY4-6住院医),用钝性多发伤VR抢救场景评估10个关键决策点。所有31人均完成插管和静脉通路;新手与初级住院医常在高渗盐水和过度通气决策上失败,初级住院医在环甲膜切开(60%)和去手术室(100%)决策上常失败。除去手术室外,所有组平均决策时间均长于急症外科主治;外科主治与高级住院医每分钟决策数显著高于初级与新手。模拟死亡率新手92.3%、初级80%、高级25%、主治0%。参与者认为TVRSim舒适、易用、能提升表现并帮助技能习得与学习。
要点
- 所有31名提供者均完成插管和静脉通路;新手与初级住院医常在高渗盐水和过度通气决策上失败。
- 初级住院医在环甲膜切开决策上失败率60%,在去手术室决策上失败率100%。
- 除去手术室外,所有组平均决策时间均长于急症外科主治;外科主治与高级住院医每分钟决策数显著高于初级与新手。
- 模拟死亡率:新手92.3%、初级80%、高级25%、主治0%。
- 参与者认为TVRSim舒适、易用/易交互/能提升表现,并帮助技能习得与学习。
适用人群与场景
- 一级创伤中心的提供者:急症外科主治、新手(MS4与PGY1)、初级(PGY2与PGY3)、高级(PGY4-6)住院医,共31名。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 采用钝性多发伤VR抢救场景,评估10个关键决策点:插管、环甲膜切开、胸腔置管、静脉通路、创伤重点超声评估、骨盆带、启动大量输血方案、给予高渗盐水、过度通气、决定去手术室。
- 学员评估基于正确决策的频率和决策时间。
研究设计与关键结果
- 先导研究,在一级创伤中心纳入31名提供者(急症外科主治、新手、初级、高级住院医),使用便利样本,运行钝性多发伤VR抢救场景。
- 所有31名提供者均完成插管和静脉通路。
- 新手与初级住院医常在高渗盐水和过度通气决策上失败。
- 初级住院医在环甲膜切开决策上失败率60%,在去手术室决策上失败率100%。
- 除去手术室外,所有组平均决策时间均长于急症外科主治。
- 外科主治与高级住院医每分钟决策数显著高于初级与新手。
- 模拟死亡率:新手92.3%、初级80%、高级25%、主治0%。
- 参与者认为TVRSim舒适、易用/易交互/能提升表现,并帮助技能习得与学习。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:先导研究;证据等级:诊断试验或标准,Level IV。
- 局限:使用便利样本;作者结论称TVRSim可能是有用的辅助手段,用于教学和评估ATLS技能。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为TVRSim可能是有用的辅助手段,用于教学和评估ATLS技能。
- 所有学员认为该平台提升了他们的表现并促进了技能习得与学习。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Medical educational research highlights the need for high-fidelity, multidisciplinary simulation training to teach complex decision-making skills, such as those taught in Advanced Trauma Life Support (ATLS). This approach is, however, expensive and time-intensive. Virtual reality (VR) education simulation may improve skill acquisition in a cost-effective and time-sensitive manner. We developed a novel trauma VR simulator (TVRSim) for providers to apply ATLS principles. We hypothesized in this pilot study that TVRSim could differentiate practitioner competency with increasing experience and would be well accepted.
METHODS: Providers at a Level I trauma center (acute care surgeons, novice (MS4 & PGY1), junior (PGY2 & 3), senior (PGY4-6) residents) ran a blunt, polytrauma VR code. Ten critical decision points were assessed: intubation, cricothyroidotomy, chest tube, intravenous access, focused abdominal sonography for trauma examination, pelvic binder, activation of massive transfusion protocol, administration of hypertonic saline, hyperventilation and decision to go to the operating room (OR). Learner assessment was based on frequency and time to correct decisions. Participant satisfaction was measured using validated surveys.
RESULTS: All 31 providers intubated and obtained intravenous access. Novices and juniors frequently failed at hypertonic saline and hyperventilation decisions. Juniors often failed at cricothyroidotomy (60%) and OR (100%) decisions. Mean time to all decisions except going to the OR was longer for all groups compared to acute care surgeons. Mean number of decisions/min was significantly higher for surgeons and seniors compared to juniors and novices. Mortality was 92.3% for novices, 80% for juniors, 25% for seniors and 0% for the attendings. Participants found TVRSim comfortable, easy to use/interact with/performance enhancing, and helped develop skills and learning.
CONCLUSIONS: In this pilot study using a sample of convenience, TVRSim was able to discern decision-making abilities among trainees with increasing experience. All trainees felt that the platform enhanced their performance and facilitated skill acquisition and learning. TVRSim could be a useful adjunct to teach and assess ATLS skills.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Diagnostic Test or Criteria; Level IV.
参考来源
- Colonna AL, Robbins R, Stefanucci J, et al. Trauma bay virtual reality-A game changer for ATLS instruction and assessment. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2022. PMID: 35170584. doi:10.1097/TA.0000000000003569
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。