成人重症监护病房镇静、镇痛、活动、谵妄与睡眠剥夺实践(SAMDS-ICU):COVID-19 大流行前后的一项国际调查
该研究为开放式多国电子调查,面向成人 ICU 医师,分 COVID-19 大流行前与大流行期间两步实施,共分析 1768 份问卷,其中 1539 份(87%)完整。大流行前最常用的评估工具为疼痛视觉模拟量表(VAS,61.5%)、行为疼痛量表(BPS,48.2%)、Richmond 躁动镇静量表(RASS,76.6%)和 ICU 意识模糊评估法(CAM-ICU,66.6%);最常用于诱导镇静和镇痛的药物为咪达唑仑(84.8%)和芬太尼(78.3%),谵妄治疗最常处方氟哌啶醇(68.8%)和非典型抗精神病药(69.4%)。大流行期间机械通气率更高,患者接受镇静更频繁(94% vs 86.1%,p<0.001),每日查房讨论镇静目标更频繁,镇痛主要用药为吗啡(77.2%),咪达唑仑、丙泊酚、氯胺酮和喹硫平等镇静药使用更频繁。结论认为多数实践在大流行前后可比,重症专业独立关联最佳实践,但部分实践仍需改进。
要点
- 大流行前最常用评估工具:VAS 61.5%、BPS 48.2%、RASS 76.6%、CAM-ICU 66.6%,分别对应疼痛、镇静深度和谵妄评估。
- 大流行前诱导镇静和镇痛最常用药物为咪达唑仑(84.8%)和芬太尼(78.3%);谵妄治疗最常处方氟哌啶醇(68.8%)和非典型抗精神病药(69.4%)。
- 大流行前部分医师常规为机械通气患者处方药物诱导睡眠(19.1%)或常规下达机械约束医嘱(6.2%)。
- 大流行期间机械通气率更高,患者接受镇静更频繁(94% vs 86.1%,p<0.001),每日查房讨论镇静目标更频繁;镇痛主要用药为吗啡(77.2%),咪达唑仑、丙泊酚、氯胺酮和喹硫平使用更频繁。
- 大流行期间重症专业独立关联最佳实践;多数实践与大流行前可比,但部分实践仍需改进。
适用人群与场景
- 面向在成人重症监护病房(ICU)工作的医师,为开放式多国电子调查,分 COVID-19 大流行前与大流行期间两步实施。
- 共分析 1768 份问卷,其中 1539 份(87%)完整;大流行前收到 1476 份问卷,另有 292 份较晚提交。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 大流行前疼痛评估最常用 VAS(61.5%)、镇静深度评估最常用 RASS(76.6%)、谵妄评估最常用 CAM-ICU(66.6%),疼痛评估 also 常用 BPS(48.2%)。
- 大流行前诱导镇静最常用咪达唑仑(84.8%)、镇痛最常用芬太尼(78.3%);谵妄治疗最常处方氟哌啶醇(68.8%)和非典型抗精神病药(69.4%)。
- 大流行前部分医师常规为机械通气患者处方药物诱导睡眠(19.1%)或常规下达机械约束医嘱(6.2%);非药物策略常用于疼痛、谵妄和睡眠剥夺管理。
- 大流行期间镇痛主要用药为吗啡(77.2%),咪达唑仑、丙泊酚、氯胺酮和喹硫平等镇静药使用更频繁。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为开放式多国电子调查,共分析 1768 份问卷,其中 1539 份(87%)完整;大流行前收到 1476 份问卷,另有 292 份较晚提交。
- 大流行前最常用评估工具:VAS 61.5%、BPS 48.2%、RASS 76.6%、CAM-ICU 66.6%。
- 大流行前诱导镇静和镇痛最常用药物:咪达唑仑 84.8%、芬太尼 78.3%;谵妄治疗最常处方氟哌啶醇 68.8%、非典型抗精神病药 69.4%。
- 大流行前部分医师常规为机械通气患者处方药物诱导睡眠(19.1%)或常规下达机械约束医嘱(6.2%)。
- 大流行期间机械通气率更高,患者接受镇静更频繁(94% vs 86.1%,p<0.001),每日查房讨论镇静目标更频繁;镇痛主要用药为吗啡(77.2%),咪达唑仑、丙泊酚、氯胺酮和喹硫平使用更频繁。
- 大流行期间重症专业独立关联最佳实践。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:开放式多国电子调查。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为多数镇静、镇痛和谵妄实践在大流行前后可比,大流行期间重症专业独立关联最佳实践;尽管许多发现与循证推荐一致,部分实践仍需改进。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Since the publication of the 2018 Clinical Guidelines about sedation, analgesia, delirium, mobilization, and sleep deprivation in critically ill patients, no evaluation and adequacy assessment of these recommendations were studied in an international context. This survey aimed to investigate these current practices and if the COVID-19 pandemic has changed them.
METHODS: This study was an open multinational electronic survey directed to physicians working in adult intensive care units (ICUs), which was performed in two steps: before and during the COVID-19 pandemic.
RESULTS: We analyzed 1768 questionnaires and 1539 (87%) were complete. Before the COVID-19 pandemic, we received 1476 questionnaires and 292 were submitted later. The following practices were observed before the pandemic: the Visual Analog Scale (VAS) (61.5%), the Behavioral Pain Scale (BPS) (48.2%), the Richmond Agitation Sedation Scale (RASS) (76.6%), and the Confusion Assessment Method for the Intensive Care Unit (CAM-ICU) (66.6%) were the most frequently tools used to assess pain, sedation level, and delirium, respectively; midazolam and fentanyl were the most frequently used drugs for inducing sedation and analgesia (84.8% and 78.3%, respectively), whereas haloperidol (68.8%) and atypical antipsychotics (69.4%) were the most prescribed drugs for delirium treatment; some physicians regularly prescribed drugs to induce sleep (19.1%) or ordered mechanical restraints as part of their routine (6.2%) for patients on mechanical ventilation; non-pharmacological strategies were frequently applied for pain, delirium, and sleep deprivation management. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the intensive care specialty was independently associated with best practices. Moreover, the mechanical ventilation rate was higher, patients received sedation more often (94% versus 86.1%, p < 0.001) and sedation goals were discussed more frequently in daily rounds. Morphine was the main drug used for analgesia (77.2%), and some sedative drugs, such as midazolam, propofol, ketamine and quetiapine, were used more frequently.
CONCLUSIONS: Most sedation, analgesia and delirium practices were comparable before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. During the pandemic, the intensive care specialty was a variable that was independently associated with the best practices. Although many findings are in accordance with evidence-based recommendations, some practices still need improvement.
参考来源
- Luz M, Brandão Barreto B, de Castro REV, et al. Practices in sedation, analgesia, mobilization, delirium, and sleep deprivation in adult intensive care units (SAMDS-ICU): an international survey before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. Ann Intensive Care. 2022. PMID: 35122204. doi:10.1186/s13613-022-00985-y
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。