评估急诊医师在院外心脏骤停中识别可除颤心律的表现:一项观察性模拟研究
该观察性模拟研究于2019年邀请六家法国急救医疗服务机构的全部262名急诊医师,通过网页应用模拟手动除颤器,对60条真实院外心脏骤停心电图依次判断是否放电,并与三名专家一致意见的金标准比较。190名医师纳入分析,57%偏好手动除颤。放电决策中位敏感度0.91(IQR 0.81-1.00),不放电中位特异度0.91(IQR 0.80-0.96);室性心动过速与粗颤敏感度均为1.0(1.0-1.0),细颤敏感度仅0.6(0.2-1);无脉电活动不放电特异度0.83(0.72-0.86),停搏0.93(0.86-1)。结论认为总体表现与已发表的自动体外除颤器研究相当,但细颤、停搏和无脉电活动的决策准确性较低。
要点
- 190名急诊医师对可除颤心律的放电中位敏感度为0.91(IQR 0.81-1.00),对不可除颤心律的不放电中位特异度为0.91(IQR 0.80-0.96)。
- 室性心动过速和粗颤的放电敏感度均为1.0(1.0-1.0),决策中位速度分别为2.0秒(1.6-2.7)和2.1秒(1.7-2.9)。
- 细颤的放电敏感度仅0.6(0.2-1),决策中位速度2.8秒(2.1-4.3)。
- 对无脉电活动不放电的特异度为0.83(0.72-0.86),对停搏不放电的特异度为0.93(0.86-1)。
- 57%的急诊医师偏好手动除颤,总体敏感度和特异度与已发表的自动体外除颤器研究相当。
适用人群与场景
- 六家法国急救医疗服务机构的急诊医师,2019年全部262名受邀,215名应答,190名纳入分析。
- 场景为院外心脏骤停,通过网页应用模拟手动除颤器对60条真实院外心脏骤停心电图记录进行放电决策。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 以三名专家一致意见作为金标准,判断是否放电。
- 敏感度定义为对可除颤心律决定放电,特异度定义为对不可除颤心律决定不放电。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 细颤放电敏感度仅0.6(0.2-1),决策中位速度2.8秒(2.1-4.3),识别准确性较低。
- 无脉电活动不放电特异度0.83(0.72-0.86),决策中位速度2.8秒(2.0-4.2),存在误放电风险。
研究设计与关键结果
- 观察性模拟研究,190名急诊医师分析60条真实院外心脏骤停心电图,与三名专家一致意见金标准比较。
- 57%的急诊医师偏好手动除颤。
- 放电中位敏感度0.91(IQR 0.81-1.00),不放电中位特异度0.91(IQR 0.80-0.96)。
- 室性心动过速和粗颤放电敏感度均为1.0(1.0-1.0);细颤放电敏感度0.6(0.2-1)。
- 无脉电活动不放电特异度0.83(0.72-0.86),停搏不放电特异度0.93(0.86-1)。
- 决策中位速度:室性心动过速2.0秒(1.6-2.7),粗颤2.1秒(1.7-2.9),停搏2.4秒(1.8-3.5),无脉电活动2.8秒(2.0-4.2),细颤2.8秒(2.1-4.3)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:观察性模拟研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 总体敏感度和特异度与已发表的自动体外除颤器研究相当,但细颤、停搏和无脉电活动的决策准确性较低。
- 临床预后最好的可除颤心律(室性心动过速和粗颤)被非常快速地识别,敏感度很好。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Emergency physicians can use a manual or an automated defibrillator to provide defibrillation of patients who had out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA). Performance of emergency physicians in identifying shockable rhythm with a manual defibrillator has been poorly explored whereas that of automated defibrillators is well known (sensitivity 0.91-1.00, specificity 0.96-0.99). We conducted this study to estimate the sensitivity/specificity and speed of shock/no-shock decision-making by prehospital emergency physicians for shockable or non-shockable rhythm, and their preference for manual versus automated defibrillation.
METHODS: We developed a web application that simulates a manual defibrillator (https://simul-shock.firebaseapp.com/). In 2019, all (262) emergency physicians of six French emergency medical services were invited to participate in a study in which 60 ECG rhythms from real OHCA recordings were successively presented to the physicians for determination of whether they would or would not administer a shock. Time to decision was recorded. Answers were compared with a gold standard (concordant answers of three experts). We report sensitivity for shockable rhythms (decision to shock) and specificity for non-shockable rhythms (decision not to shock). Physicians were also asked whether they preferred manual or automated defibrillation.
RESULTS: Among 215 respondents, we were able to analyse results for 190 physicians. 57% of emergency physicians preferred manual defibrillation. Median (IQR) sensitivity for a shock delivery for shockable rhythm was 0.91 (0.81-1.00); median specificity for no-shock delivery for non-shockable rhythms was 0.91 (0.80-0.96). More precisely, sensitivities for shock delivery for ventricular tachycardia (VT) and coarse ventricular fibrillation (VF) were both 1.0 (1.0-1.0); sensitivity for fine VF was 0.6 (0.2-1). Specificity for not shocking a pulseless electrical activity (PEA) was 0.83 (0.72-0.86), and for asystole, specificity was 0.93 (0.86-1). Median speed of decision-making (in seconds) were: VT 2.0 (1.6-2.7), coarse VF 2.1 (1.7-2.9), asystole 2.4 (1.8-3.5), PEA 2.8 (2.0-4.2) and fine VF 2.8 (2.1-4.3).
CONCLUSIONS: Global sensitivity and specificity were comparable with published automated external defibrillator studies. Shockable rhythms with the best clinical prognoses (VT and coarse VF) were very rapidly recognised with very good sensitivity. The decision-making for fine VF or asystole and PEA was less accurate.
参考来源
- Derkenne C, Jost D, Roquet F, et al. Assessment of emergency physicians' performance in identifying shockable rhythm in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: an observational simulation study. Emerg Med J. 2022. PMID: 35172979. doi:10.1136/emermed-2021-211417
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。