儿童头痛在初级保健与急诊科的处理:RAND/UCLA 法共识
该共识旨在定义初级保健儿科医生(PCP)与医院之间管理儿童头痛的共享临床路径。研究选取艾米利亚-罗马涅(Emilia Romagna)卫生区的医院儿科医生组和 PCP 组,采用 RAND/UCLA 适宜性方法达成共识,共开发 39 个临床场景,每个场景要求参与者对每个选项的适宜性按 1 至 9 分排序,若 ≥75% 的参与者评分落在同一适宜性范围内则达成一致。答案、结果和讨论帮助确定了诊断-治疗过程中证据水平较低的步骤的适宜性:初级保健评估、急诊科评估、住院、急性治疗、预防和随访。RAND 被证明是评估程序适宜性和定义适合当地实际的儿童头痛诊断-治疗路径的有效方法。根据结果,制定了一些有用的建议,以优化初级保健服务与医院之间的医疗专业人员网络。
要点
- 共识采用 RAND/UCLA 适宜性方法,由医院儿科医生和初级保健儿科医生共同参与,针对 39 个临床场景评分。
- 适宜性评分范围为 1 至 9 分,≥75% 的参与者评分落在同一适宜性范围内即达成一致。
- 共识覆盖儿童头痛诊断-治疗过程的六个步骤:初级保健评估、急诊科评估、住院、急性治疗、预防和随访。
- RAND 方法被证明可用于评估证据水平较低的操作的适宜性,并定义适合当地实际的诊断-治疗路径。
- 共识结果形成了优化初级保健与医院之间医疗专业人员网络的有用建议。
适用人群与场景
- 儿童头痛患者,在初级保健和急诊科场景中管理。
研究设计与关键结果
- 共识采用 RAND/UCLA 适宜性方法,选取艾米利亚-罗马涅卫生区的医院儿科医生组和初级保健儿科医生组参与。
- 共开发 39 个临床场景,参与者对每个选项的适宜性按 1 至 9 分评分,≥75% 的参与者评分落在同一适宜性范围内即达成一致。
- 共识确定了诊断-治疗过程中证据水平较低的步骤的适宜性,包括初级保健评估、急诊科评估、住院、急性治疗、预防和随访。
- RAND 被证明是评估程序适宜性和定义适合当地实际的儿童头痛诊断-治疗路径的有效方法。
- 根据结果制定了优化初级保健服务与医院之间医疗专业人员网络的有用建议。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:共识(指南),采用 RAND/UCLA 适宜性方法。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 该共识旨在定义初级保健儿科医生与医院之间管理儿童头痛的共享临床路径,覆盖初级保健评估、急诊科评估、住院、急性治疗、预防和随访。
- 共识结果形成了优化初级保健服务与医院之间医疗专业人员网络的有用建议。
指南或共识出处
- 指南名称:儿童头痛在初级保健与急诊科的处理:RAND/UCLA 法共识(Pediatric Headache in Primary Care and Emergency Departments: Consensus with RAND/UCLA Method)。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Headache is the most frequent neurological symptom in childhood and the main reason for admission to pediatric emergency departments. The aim of this consensus document is to define a shared clinical pathway between primary care pediatricians (PCP) and hospitals for the management of children presenting with headache. For the purposes of the study, a group of hospital pediatricians and a group of PCP from the Emilia Romagna's health districts were selected to achieve consensus using the RAND/UCLA appropriateness method. Thirty-nine clinical scenarios were developed: for each scenario, participants were asked to rank the appropriateness of each option from 1 to 9. Agreement was reached if ≥75% of participants ranked within the same range of appropriateness. The answers, results, and discussion helped to define the appropriateness of procedures with a low level of evidence regarding different steps of the diagnostic-therapeutic process: primary care evaluation, emergency department evaluation, hospital admission, acute therapy, prophylaxis, and follow-up. The RAND proved to be a valid method to value appropriateness of procedures and define a diagnostic-therapeutic pathway suitable to the local reality in the management of pediatric headache. From our results, some useful recommendations were developed for optimizing the healthcare professionals' network among primary care services and hospitals.
参考来源
- Prezioso G, Suppiej A, Alberghini V, et al. Pediatric Headache in Primary Care and Emergency Departments: Consensus with RAND/UCLA Method. Life (Basel). 2022. PMID: 35207430. doi:10.3390/life12020142
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。