全美研究界定创伤与急诊外科1.0全职工作量
该研究向美国I、II、III级创伤中心科室负责人发放工作量调查问卷,并对同意受访者进行虚拟半结构化访谈,用主题分析描述当前人员配置挑战与「理想」模式。483名科室主任/医疗主任中68名回复(14%),66%来自I级中心;全职工作量中位描述为26周(四分位距13周),中位每月8个(四分位距8个)12小时值班。III级中心更常开展择期手术、承担更多值班且多从家中待命。作者结论认为I级中心1.0全职急诊外科医生合理工作量为每年24–28个服务周、每月4–5个院内值班。
要点
- 调查回复率14%(68/483),66%的回复者来自I级创伤中心,结果代表性受限。
- 全职工作量中位描述为每年26周(四分位距13周),中位每月8个(四分位距8个)12小时值班。
- III级中心比I级中心更常开展择期手术、承担更多值班,且通常从家中待命。
- 作者结论:I级中心1.0全职急诊外科医生合理工作量为每年24–28个服务周、每月4–5个院内值班。
- 作者认为夜间与日间人员配置需求可能不一致,并可能与管理层产生冲突。
适用人群与场景
- 美国I、II、III级创伤中心中创伤与急诊外科的科室负责人/医疗主任(调查对象为部门领导,非一线全体外科医生)。
- 定性访谈对象为同意接受虚拟半结构化访谈的回复者。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 1.0全职工作量中位描述为每年26周(四分位距13周)。
- 值班中位数为每月8个(四分位距8个)12小时值班。
- 作者提出的I级中心1.0全职急诊外科医生合理工作量为每年24–28个服务周、每月4–5个院内值班。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为全美调查加虚拟半结构化访谈,483名科室主任/医疗主任中68名回复(14%),66%来自I级中心。
- 各中心在临床职责、择期手术覆盖、值班数量及值班报酬方面存在差异。
- 全职工作量中位描述为每年26周(四分位距13周),中位每月8个(四分位距8个)12小时值班。
- III级中心更常开展择期手术、承担更多值班,且通常从家中待命。
- 定性访谈识别的主题包括:服务模式与人员配置不一致、外科医生与管理层冲突、择期手术受生产力和意愿驱动。
- 作者结论:I级中心1.0全职急诊外科医生合理工作量为每年24–28个服务周、每月4–5个院内值班;夜间与日间人员配置需求可能不一致并可能与管理层冲突。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型为预后与流行病学研究,证据等级Level III(原文标注)。
- 局限:调查回复率为14%(68/483)。
- 局限:作者指出未来研究应考虑个体外科医生对全职工作量定义的观点。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为界定全职创伤与急诊外科医生工作量需考虑本地手术量、病情严重度和文化,不能统一套用。
- 作者结论提出I级中心1.0全职急诊外科医生合理工作量为每年24–28个服务周、每月4–5个院内值班,可作本地人员配置讨论的参照。
- 作者认为夜间与日间人员配置需求可能不一致,并可能与管理层产生冲突。
- III级中心更常开展择期手术、承担更多值班且多从家中待命,配置时需与I级中心区分。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Trauma and acute care surgery (ACS) staffing models vary widely across the United States, resulting in large discrepancies in staffing, compensation, schedule, and clinical/nonclinical expectations. An urgent need exists to define clinical, academic, and schedule expectations for a full-time employment (FTE) of a trauma and ACS surgeon in the United States.
METHODS: A survey was distributed to departmental leaders at Levels I, II, III trauma centers across the United States regarding current workload. Variables concerning the responsibilities of surgeons, compensation models, and clinical expectations were collected. This was followed by virtual semistructured interviews of agreeable respondents. A thematic analysis was used to describe current staffing challenges and "ideal" staffing and compensation models of trauma centers.
RESULTS: Sixty-eight of 483 division chiefs/medical directors responded (14%), the majority (66%) representing Level I centers. There were differences in clinical responsibilities, elective surgery coverage as well as number of and reimbursement for call. The median description of an FTE was 26 weeks (interquartile range, 13 weeks) with a median of 8 (interquartile range, 8) 12-hour call shifts per month. Level III centers were more likely to perform elective surgery and covered more call shifts, typically from home. In our qualitative interviews, we identified numerous themes, including inconsistent models and staffing of services, surgeon-administration conflict and elective surgery driven by productivity and desire.
CONCLUSION: Defining the workload of a full-time trauma and ACS surgeon is nuanced and requires consideration of local volume, acuity and culture. Between the quantitative and qualitative analysis, a reasonable workload for a 1.0 FTE acute care surgeon at a Level I center is 24 to 28 service weeks per year and four to five in-house calls per month. Nighttime and daytime staffing needs can be divergent and may lead to conflict with administration. Future research should consider the individual surgeon's perspective on the definition of an FTE.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Prognostic and epidemiological, Level III.
参考来源
- Murphy PB, Coleman J, Karam B, et al. A national study defining 1.0 full-time employment in trauma and acute care surgery. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2022. PMID: 34936589. doi:10.1097/TA.0000000000003504
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。