院前疼痛管理循证指南:推荐意见
本指南由技术专家小组基于AHRQ系统评价制定,针对EMS临床医生处理中重度疼痛的镇痛选择提出推荐。小组围绕9个PICO问题及1个儿科镇痛问题形成推荐。对无静脉通路的儿科患者,强烈推荐经鼻芬太尼而非静脉阿片类药物;对静脉非甾体抗炎药与静脉对乙酰氨基酚、静脉氯胺酮与静脉阿片类药物等多项比较给出条件性推荐;对体重剂量静脉氯胺酮联合体重剂量静脉阿片类药物对比单用体重剂量静脉阿片类药物给出条件性不推荐。指南强调EMS医疗主任和临床医生在制定患者照护指南时有多种有效选择。
要点
- 无静脉通路的儿科患者,强烈推荐经鼻芬太尼而非静脉阿片类药物。
- 条件性推荐静脉非甾体抗炎药而非静脉对乙酰氨基酚。
- 条件性推荐静脉氯胺酮或静脉阿片类药物均可;静脉非甾体抗炎药或静脉阿片类药物均可;静脉芬太尼或静脉吗啡均可;静脉氯胺酮或静脉非甾体抗炎药均可。
- 条件性推荐静脉对乙酰氨基酚而非静脉阿片类药物。
- 条件性不推荐体重剂量静脉氯胺酮联合体重剂量静脉阿片类药物对比单用体重剂量静脉阿片类药物;口服途径首选时条件性推荐口服对乙酰氨基酚或口服非甾体抗炎药均可。
适用人群与场景
- 院前环境中重度疼痛患者,由EMS临床医生处理。
- 儿科患者中无静脉通路者。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 无静脉通路的儿科患者:强烈推荐经鼻芬太尼而非静脉阿片类药物。
- 条件性推荐静脉非甾体抗炎药而非静脉对乙酰氨基酚。
- 条件性推荐静脉氯胺酮或静脉阿片类药物均可。
- 条件性推荐静脉非甾体抗炎药或静脉阿片类药物均可。
- 条件性推荐静脉芬太尼或静脉吗啡均可。
- 条件性推荐静脉氯胺酮或静脉非甾体抗炎药均可。
- 条件性推荐静脉对乙酰氨基酚而非静脉阿片类药物。
- 条件性不推荐体重剂量静脉氯胺酮联合体重剂量静脉阿片类药物对比单用体重剂量静脉阿片类药物;口服途径首选时条件性推荐口服对乙酰氨基酚或口服非甾体抗炎药均可。
研究设计与关键结果
- 技术专家小组基于康涅狄格大学循证实践中心为AHRQ准备的已发表系统评价,制定院前镇痛循证指南。
- 基于AHRQ系统评价的关键问题形成9个PICO问题,另增设1个PICO问题专门讨论儿科镇痛。
- 对无静脉通路的儿科患者,基于支持证据、有效性、给药便利性及患者和提供者接受度,强烈推荐经鼻芬太尼而非静脉阿片类药物。
- 对静脉非甾体抗炎药对比静脉对乙酰氨基酚,作出条件性推荐使用静脉非甾体抗炎药。
- 对静脉氯胺酮或静脉阿片类药物、静脉非甾体抗炎药或静脉阿片类药物、静脉芬太尼或静脉吗啡、静脉氯胺酮或静脉非甾体抗炎药,均作出条件性推荐两者均可。
- 对静脉对乙酰氨基酚对比静脉阿片类药物,作出条件性推荐使用静脉对乙酰氨基酚。
- 对体重剂量静脉氯胺酮联合体重剂量静脉阿片类药物对比单用体重剂量静脉阿片类药物,作出条件性不推荐联合方案。
- 口服途径首选时,条件性推荐口服对乙酰氨基酚或口服非甾体抗炎药均可;因缺乏支持证据,无法对一氧化二氮对比静脉阿片类药物、或静脉氯胺酮联合静脉阿片类药物对比单用静脉氯胺酮作出推荐。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:指南,基于AHRQ系统评价制定,采用技术专家小组形成推荐。
- 推荐强度:强烈推荐、条件性推荐、条件性不推荐。
对床旁实践的改变
- EMS医疗主任和EMS临床医生在制定患者照护指南和照护急性疼痛患者时,除阿片类药物外有多种有效选择。
- 对无静脉通路的儿科患者,经鼻芬太尼优于静脉阿片类药物。
- 因缺乏支持证据,无法对一氧化二氮对比静脉阿片类药物、或静脉氯胺酮联合静脉阿片类药物对比单用静脉氯胺酮作出推荐。
指南或共识出处
- 指南名称:院前疼痛管理循证指南:推荐意见(Evidence-Based Guidelines for Prehospital Pain Management: Recommendations),发表于Prehospital Emergency Care。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
This project sought to develop evidence-based guidelines for the administration of analgesics for moderate to severe pain by Emergency Medical Services (EMS) clinicians based on a separate, previously published, systematic review of the comparative effectiveness of analgesics in the prehospital setting prepared by the University of Connecticut Evidence-Based Practice Center for the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ). A technical expert panel (TEP) was assembled consisting of subject matter experts in prehospital and emergency care, and the development of evidence-based guidelines and patient care guidelines. A series of nine "patient/population-intervention-comparison-outcome" (PICO) questions were developed based on the Key Questions identified in the AHRQ systematic review, and an additional PICO question was developed to specifically address analgesia in pediatric patients. The panel made a strong recommendation for the use of intranasal fentanyl over intravenous (IV) opioids for pediatric patients without intravenous access given the supporting evidence, its effectiveness, ease of administration, and acceptance by patients and providers. The panel made a conditional recommendation for the use of IV non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) over IV acetaminophen (APAP). The panel made conditional recommendations for the use of either IV ketamine or IV opioids; for either IV NSAIDs or IV opioids; for either IV fentanyl or IV morphine; and for either IV ketamine or IV NSAIDs. A conditional recommendation was made for IV APAP over IV opioids. The panel made a conditional recommendation against the use of weight-based IV ketamine in combination with weight-based IV opioids versus weight-based IV opioids alone. The panel considered the use of oral analgesics and a conditional recommendation was made for either oral APAP or oral NSAIDs when the oral route of administration was preferred. Given the lack of a supporting evidence base, the panel was unable to make recommendations for the use of nitrous oxide versus IV opioids, or for IV ketamine in combination with IV opioids versus IV ketamine alone. Taken together, the recommendations emphasize that EMS medical directors and EMS clinicians have a variety of effective options for the management of moderate to severe pain in addition to opioids when designing patient care guidelines and caring for patients suffering from acute pain.
参考来源
- Lindbeck G, Shah MI, Braithwaite S, et al. Evidence-Based Guidelines for Prehospital Pain Management: Recommendations. Prehosp Emerg Care. 2022. PMID: 34928760. doi:10.1080/10903127.2021.2018073
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。