制定国家创伤研究行动计划:院前与大规模伤亡研究德尔菲调查结果
为响应2016年美国国家科学院、工程院与医学院创伤系统报告关于制定国家创伤研究行动计划的建议,11个专家小组开展德尔菲调查。院前与大规模伤亡创伤护理小组招募31名跨学科国家专家(含军队与民用代表),经四轮德尔菲调查生成490个研究问题,其中433个(88%)在优先级上达成共识。433个问题中81个(19%)为高优先级、339个(78%)为中优先级、13个(3%)为低优先级;81个高优先级问题涉及46个分类学概念,包括救治体系(36个)、干预性临床试验与比较效果(32个)、死亡率作为结局(30个)、院前时间/转运方式/响应者级别(24个)、系统基准(17个)和液体/血制品复苏(17个)。该分析为研究者和资助机构提供未来创伤研究的优先方向。
要点
- 31名跨学科国家专家(含军队与民用代表)经四轮德尔菲调查生成490个院前与大规模伤亡创伤研究问题。
- 433个(88%)问题达成优先级共识:81个(19%)高优先级、339个(78%)中优先级、13个(3%)低优先级。
- 81个高优先级问题覆盖46个分类学概念,包括救治体系(36个)、干预性临床试验与比较效果(32个)、死亡率作为结局(30个)。
- 高优先级问题还涉及院前时间/转运方式/响应者级别(24个)、系统基准(17个)和液体/血制品复苏(17个)。
- 共识定义为对优先级类别≥60%一致,问题按9点李克特量表分为低、中、高优先级。
适用人群与场景
- 院前与大规模伤亡创伤护理领域,由跨学科国家专家(含军队与民用代表)参与共识调查。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 共识定义为对优先级类别≥60%一致。
- 采用9点李克特量表将研究问题分为低、中、高优先级。
- 使用包含9个类别、118个研究概念的分类学对研究问题进行编码。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:德尔菲调查(四轮),由院前与大规模伤亡创伤护理专家组完成,招募31名跨学科国家专家(含军队与民用代表)。
- 专家生成490个研究问题,其中433个(88%)在优先级上达成共识。
- 433个共识问题的优先级分布:81个(19%)高优先级、339个(78%)中优先级、13个(3%)低优先级。
- 81个高优先级问题涉及46个分类学概念,包括救治体系(36个问题)、干预性临床试验与比较效果(32个问题)、死亡率作为结局(30个问题)。
- 高优先级问题还涉及院前时间/转运方式/响应者级别(24个问题)、系统基准(17个问题)和液体/血制品复苏(17个问题)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:专家共识德尔菲调查(美国国家创伤研究行动计划院前与大规模伤亡创伤护理专家组)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 该德尔菲缺口分析确定的81个高优先级研究问题,可供研究者和资助机构指导未来创伤研究。
指南或共识出处
- 美国国家科学院、工程院与医学院2016年创伤系统报告建议制定国家创伤研究行动计划。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016 trauma system report recommended a National Trauma Research Action Plan to strengthen and guide future trauma research. To address this recommendation, 11 expert panels completed a Delphi survey process to create a comprehensive research agenda, spanning the continuum of trauma care. We describe the gap analysis and high-priority research questions generated from the National Trauma Research Action Plan panel on prehospital and mass casualty trauma care.
METHODS: We recruited interdisciplinary national experts to identify gaps in the prehospital and mass casualty trauma evidence base and generate prioritized research questions using a consensus-driven Delphi survey approach. We included military and civilian representatives. Panelists were encouraged to use the Patient/Population, Intervention, Compare/Control, and Outcome format to generate research questions. We conducted four Delphi rounds in which participants generated key research questions and then prioritized the questions on a 9-point Likert scale to low-, medium-, and high-priority items. We defined consensus as ≥60% agreement on the priority category and coded research questions using a taxonomy of 118 research concepts in 9 categories.
RESULTS: Thirty-one interdisciplinary subject matter experts generated 490 research questions, of which 433 (88%) reached consensus on priority. The rankings of the 433 questions were as follows: 81 (19%) high priority, 339 (78%) medium priority, and 13 (3%) low priority. Among the 81 high-priority questions, there were 46 taxonomy concepts, including health systems of care (36 questions), interventional clinical trials and comparative effectiveness (32 questions), mortality as an outcome (30 questions), prehospital time/transport mode/level of responder (24 questions), system benchmarks (17 questions), and fluid/blood product resuscitation (17 questions).
CONCLUSION: This Delphi gap analysis of prehospital and mass casualty care identified 81 high-priority research questions to guide investigators and funding agencies for future trauma research.
参考来源
- Newgard CD, Braverman MA, Phuong J, et al. Developing a National Trauma Research Action Plan: Results from the prehospital and mass casualty research Delphi survey. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2022. PMID: 34789701. doi:10.1097/TA.0000000000003469
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。