公众号 / 文章复苏、休克与脓毒症

中小学生分层急救培训方案:深圳宝安社会急救医学培训「宝安模式」建设实践

[Hierarchical first aid training scheme for elementary and middle school students: the practices from the construction of "Baoan Model" social emergency medicine training].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Wei Zhong Bing Ji Jiu Yi Xue · 2021-01-01
一句话结论宝安区中小学生分层急救培训方案可行,课程内容应由易到难设计,并需同步配备足够的培训导师和培训模型以保证质量。

该文分享了2018年8月至2019年8月深圳市宝安区中小学生分层急救培训方案的实施经验并评估培训效果。研究按小学、初中、高中三个年龄层次设置由易到难的课程,共12 896名学生、2 086名培训导师参与200场培训,使用8 557具心肺复苏训练模型和8 493具自动体外除颤器模型。课程结束时10 494名学生参加考核,参与率81.37%,10 114人通过,通过率96.38%;分层分析显示初中、高中学生考核参与率高于小学生,但通过率低于小学生。作者认为分层方案可行,课程内容应由易到难设计,并应同步配备足够的培训导师和培训模型以保证质量。

要点

  • 共12 896名学生、2 086名培训导师参与200场急救培训,使用8 557具心肺复苏训练模型和8 493具自动体外除颤器模型。
  • 每场平均学生65.27±5.61人、培训导师10.52±10.43人,心肺复苏训练模型43.09±19.06具、自动体外除颤器模型42.77±18.61具。
  • 生师比6.07±1.47,学生与心肺复苏模型比1.54±1.02,学生与自动体外除颤器模型比1.54±1.03。
  • 课程结束时10 494名学生参加考核(参与率81.37%),10 114人通过(通过率96.38%)。
  • 初中生考核参与率81.07%(6 667/8 224)、高中生100%(2 313/2 313),均高于小学生64.18%(1 514/2 359)(均P < 0.05);通过率初中生95.47%(6 365/6 667)、高中生96.88%(2 241/2 313),均低于小学生99.60%(1 508/1 514)(均P < 0.01)。

适用人群与场景

  • 2018年8月至2019年8月参加深圳市宝安区急诊救援培训中心举办急救培训的中小学生。
  • 按小学、初中、高中三个年龄层次分层,分别接受由易到难的不同课程。

处置流程与药物剂量

  • 小学生课程:拨打120、识别意外伤害的智能动画、自动体外除颤器与海姆立克手法演示、心肺复苏练习(40分钟)。
  • 初中生课程:拨打120、识别意外伤害与简单处置、心肺复苏与自动体外除颤器的应用、练习心肺复苏与自动体外除颤器及海姆立克手法(90分钟)。
  • 高中生课程:拨打120、识别意外伤害与正确处置、识别院外心脏骤停、心肺复苏与自动体外除颤器要点、练习心肺复苏与自动体外除颤器、海姆立克手法与止血包扎(120分钟)。
  • 课程结束时小学生自愿参加技能考核;初中生仅小班强制参加技能考核、大班不要求考核仅作演示;高中生全部强制参加技能考核。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型为培训实施经验总结与效果评价,共12 896名学生、2 086名培训导师参与200场急救培训,使用8 557具心肺复苏训练模型和8 493具自动体外除颤器模型。
  • 每场平均学生65.27±5.61人、培训导师10.52±10.43人,心肺复苏训练模型43.09±19.06具、自动体外除颤器模型42.77±18.61具;生师比6.07±1.47,学生与心肺复苏模型比1.54±1.02,学生与自动体外除颤器模型比1.54±1.03。
  • 课程结束时10 494名学生参加考核,参与率81.37%;10 114人通过,通过率96.38%。
  • 与小学生相比,初中生每场平均人数显著增加(69.94±8.77例 vs. 58.69±6.12例,P < 0.05),高中生每场平均人数显著减少(57.35±5.79例 vs. 58.69±6.12例,P < 0.05)。
  • 初中生培训中导师比例显著降低(5.94±1.39 vs. 6.48±2.02,P < 0.05)。
  • 初中生和高中生考核参与率显著升高[81.07%(6 667/8 224)、100%(2 313/2 313)vs. 64.18%(1 514/2 359),均P < 0.05],但考核通过率显著降低[95.47%(6 365/6 667)、96.88%(2 241/2 313)vs. 99.60%(1 508/1 514),均P < 0.01];原文认为这可能与小学生考核难度低及强制考核比例低有关。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:培训实施经验总结与效果评价(非随机对照研究)。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为分层方案对中小学生急救培训可行,课程内容应由易到难设计。
  • 作者认为应同步配备足够的培训导师和培训模型以保证培训质量。
  • 原文提示小学生考核通过率虽高(99.60%)但考核参与率较低(64.18%),初中生与高中生强制考核后参与率升高而通过率降低。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVE: To share the implementation experience of hierarchical first aid training scheme for elementary and middle school students in Baoan District of Shenzhen City and evaluate its effect of training.

METHODS: During August 2018 and August 2019, elementary and middle schools students who participated in the first aid training held by emergency rescue training center of Baoan District were enrolled. Baseline information including the number of students, the number of attending tutors, the number of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) training models, automated external defibrillator (AED) models were recorded. According to hierarchical levels of three age, students received different courses with content from simple to hard: the course of elementary school students was consisting of dialing 120, smart animation on how to identify accidental damage, demonstration of AED and Hemlick techniques, CPR practise (40 minutes). The course of junior high school students was consisted of how to dial 120, how to identify accidental damage and simple disposal, application of CPR and AED, practice CPR and AED and Hemlick techniques (90 minutes). The course of high school students was consisted of how to dial 120, identify accidental damage and right disposal, identification of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, the key-point of CPR and AED, practice CPR and AED, Hemlick techniques and hemostatic bandage (120 minutes). At the end of course, elementary school students were voluntary for skill assessment; junior high school students only were compulsory for skill assessment in small classes but not required in large classes, just for demonstration; additionally, the whole high school students were compulsory for skill assessment. The characteristics of first aid training students at different levels were collected in order to compare the differences on the usage of CPR training model and AED training model, the distribution of emergency resource, the ratio for passing examination.

RESULTS: A total of 12 896 students and 2 086 training instructors took parted in 200 lists of first aid training courses, 8 557 CPR models and 8 493 AED models were used. On average, there are 65.27±5.61 students in each session, and 10.52±10.43 training instructors. There are 43.09±19.06 CPR training models and 42.77±18.61 AED training models. The mean ratio of student to tutor was 6.07±1.47, student to CPR model was 1.54±1.02, and student to AED model was 1.54±1.03. In the end of course, 10 494 students participated in the examination with the participation rate of 81.37%; 10 114 students passed the examination with the passing rate of 96.38%. Hierarchical analysis showed: compare to elementary school students, the average number of junior high school students in every training session significantly increased (cases: 69.94±8.77 vs. 58.69±6.12, P < 0.05), but the average number of high school students in every training session significantly decreased (cases: 57.35±5.79 vs. 58.69±6.12, P < 0.05). The proportion of instructors in junior high school students' training significantly reduced (5.94±1.39 vs. 6.48±2.02, P < 0.05). The examination ratio of junior high school students and high school students was increased significantly [81.07% (6 667/8 224), 100% (2 313/2 313) vs. 64.18% (1 514/2 359), both P < 0.05], but the ratio of passing the examination was significantly reduced [95.47% (6 365/6 667), 96.88% (2 241/2 313) vs. 99.60%(1 508/1 514), both P < 0.01]. This might be related to the low difficulty of elementary school students' assessment and the low proportion of compulsory examination.

CONCLUSIONS: Hierarchical scheme is feasible for first aid training in elementary and middle school students, the content of course should be desighed from easy to hard. Synchronously, sufficient training instructors and training models should be equipped to ensure the quality.

来源:Zhonghua Wei Zhong Bing Ji Jiu Yi Xue,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Lin J, Wang C, Fang Y, et al. [Hierarchical first aid training scheme for elementary and middle school students: the practices from the construction of "Baoan Model" social emergency medicine training]. Zhonghua Wei Zhong Bing Ji Jiu Yi Xue. 2021. PMID: 34839873. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn121430-20210413-00551

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。